Friday, March 16, 2007

Seriously

Since the biggest concerns here seems to be that a non-celibate homosexual will get into the priesthood or the episcopate and the sanctity and seriousness of marriage, I believe, in all seriousness all sincerity and for due consideration, we should consider a much more restrictive view of the married clergy, along the lines of that in the Orthodox Church.

First, priests either come to the priesthood married or do not marry at all. This is reasonable. A person enters the priesthood with what is needed to tend to a congregation. To suddenly add a family on top of that is unfair to priest and parish. If the priest simply must marry after vows, he must be removed from his post -- not defrocked, perhaps, but relieved of priestly duties, at least, and seek secular employment. This is upfront and makes no demands that someone entering the priesthood should object to as too much.

Second, the discernment process for marrieds to enter the clergy should be much more rigorous. A full opening of the household and its running should be presented to the bishop and discernment committee. This is where the greatest problems will come in for the priest, and he cannot place family above priesthood. He is set aside for God and His people, not in the ordinary course of things as the average married person. The slightest hint of instability in the marriage, poor parenting, or an inability to put priestly duties first should be enough to stop the discernment, formation, or active priestly duties.

Third, bishops, as pastors for an entire diocese, must be unmarried. Whether widowers or single, gay or straight, they must be celibate and free of romantic relationship. Those in married or "dating" relationships should be phased out immediately.

Fourth, divorce and remarriage are absolute disqualifiers to the Holy Orders. Those currently serving as ordained clergy in such a relationship should be placed in an immediate process of "phasing out." Those divorcing while in the ordained clergy must be secularized, as they have provided a failed example of marriage as sacramental bond. Some way of allowing them to support themselves in the process of finding new employment must, of course, be implemented.

None of this is beyond the capacity of those who are called to the clergy by God, nor is it unreasonable to require such rigorous discipline. Does it hold clergy to a much higher standard? Absolutely, and rightly so!

It does not address the issue of homosexuality adequately, but, at least, it would keep the burden from being unequally placed upon homosexuals. Equally, though, it is not punitive towards heterosexuals as it provides a rigorous commitment witness from the clergy and a positive witness to the sanctity and gravity of marriage.

4 comments:

david+ said...

I agree. However, one small quarrel might be that (re#3) if one is celibate one is not "gay or straight."

Bateau Master said...

Except for point #3, which contradicts scripture, i.e. Timothy 3:2 – I, can live with and within these standards. Good work.

Anonymous said...

Note that the diocese of Sydney applies option 2 and 4. It's the fastest growing diocese in the "west" today. I wonder why.

and of course, divorce, remarriage, or any sexual activity after converstion and outside marriage completely disqualifies candidates from ordination.

MarkBrunson said...

Thank you for your insights.

I would counter-quarrel, Fr. David, that orientation does not matter in the case of celibacy, but it is still present. Still, I see what you're saying.

Bateau, I understand where you're coming from -- the injunction that a bishop must be a "man with one wife," but, taken in the context of Paul's additional subordination of marriage to celibacy, that celibacy is still the higher path for the bishop. Taken with the modern requirements for a bishop to cover a large diocese, it makes sense to go ahead and require celibacy. There's the additional benefit that a widow/er will have acquired a depth of compassion and wisdom from such loss, while a person celibate for life will have learned a stability and shown a grace in light of such a strong natural impulse as the sex drive.

Anonymous,
It depends. Numbers don't mean that much to me, though I congratulate you on a more rigorous process. In matters of clergy selection, I am actually extremely conservative, approaching the point of saying they must be converts to Christianity with the last name Cohen or Levi :). If God doesn't send workers committed to the field enough under strict requirements, we must wonder about the seed we're planting.