Monday, March 26, 2007

What Don't They Get? Or Do They Not Care?

The "orthodox" are still not getting that the message they're giving gays and lesbians is not Good News. It's not even good news.

As far as the reasons given, it's Scripture, Scripture, Scripture, as if that somehow trumped, rather than complimented, human existence. It's simply madness. Even David, in his psalms, said that "God's Law" was found to be good after thorough testing, and the whole anti-gay position has not been found good.

Look, I've been given the gift of celibacy. I'm not in a relationship, not interested in one. That is a gift, not something foisted on me. It came. There is no gift in demanding celibacy. There is no love or goodness to be found in demanding someone give up another who compliments, or some way, completes them. Such demands are not good, not holy, and not justified by any amount of actual testing.

There's also a great deal of outright arrogance in claiming to know what is actually going on in a homosexual relationship from the outside. From a hostile viewpoint. From someone who has no experience of such a relationship.

Do these "orthodox" care? I've arrived at the opinion they don't. It's not about spiritual care, no concern for gay people at all. As long as we weren't in public, and not in their churches, they wouldn't give two craps if we were having orgies while shooting heroin into our eyeballs. It's selfishness, on their part. That's all I can believe. Otherwise, how could they NOT understand that their message is not one of hope or joy or goodness to those hearing it? Not a message of freedom, but of mindless, unwarranted emptiness and deprivation? How can they not see that the message requires -- if the Biblical injunctions are taken literally -- that homosexuals, not homosexual acts, must be excluded from the church? Paul didn't say "Those committing homosexual acts. . ." but "homosexuals" will not inherit the Kingdom. At least Fred Phelps has enough Integrity to carry it all the way!
How can they not realize, these "orthodox," that they are, indeed, driving people from the Gospel (if they truly believe they are preaching the One and Only Gospel)? How can they not realize that, through their teachings, are responsible for the despair, the abuse, the violence, the death that gays have experienced? How?

They don't care.

Finally, and what makes me finally know we must divorce from these people or forever be made unhealthy and beaten down, is the sheer amount of dissembling and sleight-of-hand they do in self-justifying. On Fr. Jake's Dan and Matt Kennedy, Dan gave some very thorough and grounded exegesis on the Romans clobber verse (a monstrous bit of ignorance if read literally), while Kennedy simply says over and over that Dan is reading things in that aren't stated. Later, the subject of Pauline marital injunctions are brought up, and Kennedy, who I still give "props" for his level tone, answers:

No, in the context, there was an engaged couple obviously intending on a life-long relationship but having difficulty maintaining celibacy. Paul advises marriage so that they do not commit fornication.
Now, please feel free to go to 1 Corinthians 7 and find the reference to "Johnny and Suzy Engaged-Couple." Here: http://www.biblegateway.com/passage/?book_id=53&chapter=7&version=31&context=chapter.

Sorry, but their god is not a god I owe anything to, having created me for nothing more than his amusement and my misery in the only life I know I have, and a relationship with his followers is not a relationship I owe anything to.

2 comments:

June Butler said...

Mark, I could not agree more with your view on celibacy as a gift from God. I posted briefly on this on my blog as a "Thought For The Day".

Here's what I said:

Celibacy is a vocation, a special call from God. No human can call another human to a life of celibacy. Only God can make that call. Therefore no human has the right to declare to a Christian gay man or lesbian, "You are called to a life of celibacy".

It's easy to lay heavy burdens on others, but Jesus had harsh words for the Pharisees for doing just that.

MarkBrunson said...

Exactly!

Thank you, Grandmere!