Thursday, March 15, 2007

The American Problem

That's what it is, really, isn't it?

It's not about TEC. No. It's fueled because we Americans are seen as synonymous with our government -- currently, a spoiled, paranoid, bullying government. The Episcopal Church has become conflated with that, and, as such, is fair game.

It's not helped by the fact that the loudest and most insistent public face of the church in this country -- the schismatics -- are, themselves, spoiled, paranoid and bullying. This is entirely evident in the "demands" to make TEC acceptable to their lordships of the "orthodox anglicans" presented by one virtueless Virtue -- you can find the answers posted on Telling Secrets in the post "What Would It Take." Go there. Don't be lazy. Look at it and Virtue in all their glory, and see the true face of the "loyal opposition." I can guarantee you the rest of the world sees it.

Zbigniew Brzezinski referred to our current government's stance as "Manichaean paranoia" -- the belief that, we, the Good, are entitled to use any tactics, any manipulations, against the Evil, them. Make no mistake, the "orthodox" in TEC are doing the same. And the rest of the AC sees them.

I had been confused by the accusations of ecclesial imperialism against TEC; we have not forced our practices or consciences on any other, even our own. The disingenuous claims of the Virtues and Andersons and Minnses and Duncans are just that: disingenuous. They know that they will not be held responsible by God if TEC is mistaken in it's "liberal agenda" (as the "orthodox" would have it). If they disagree, well and good and we've MADE ROOM FOR THEM! So, where is the ecclesial imperialism? There is none in TEC for the AC to have seen.

But it is in the "orthodox" -- they will have their way, over all objections, using any means. This is what the AC sees, and expects of us on the liberal side, if we "win." Why shouldn't they? The schismatics are obnoxiously and aggressively visible, claiming to speak for all American christians. The AC is legitimately afraid we will shove our beliefs on them, because they can see the Network, CANA et al doing just that to us. What we need to do is reassure them, we are not like that. If we can. The lies from the right are so strident and blatant, they are hard to keep up with (Manichaean paranoia at work!)

To those in the Global South, believe me about this: you are being used, just as we are. These "orthodox" are very stereotypically American, and, when they've used you to become Top Anglican Dog in America, they will use their money and influence to start directing you "poor, misguided foreigners" in the way to do things. Don't fall for it. We can't offer you greater power, but we're not interested in taking it from you, either.

1 comment:

johnieb said...

Thanks for the "Manichean paranoia" nugget; it's very apt.