Wednesday, March 14, 2007

They Really Are Just Bad People.

While I stand by the belief that most of those in the pews who are on the opposing side concerning homosexuality are basically good people, whenever I read something by one of their talking heads, especially Kendall Harmon, or Matt Kennedy, of King Bob of Pennsylvania, I am reminded that these people are, in the end, just bad people. They enjoy hurting others, they delight in degrading others, they simply trill with joy like little tiny carrion birds over any "wit" they think they can show at a liberal's - especially a gay liberal's - expense. All you need to do is go to StandFirm or Titus or even comments in Thinking Anglicans to see behavior akin to a pogrom.

Unfortunately, I see many more in the comments fields of various blogs taking up the same language and banner. Some may stumble here and say, per usual complaint, that my remarks don't help the ongoing dialogue. Well, with such people, the dialogue is over. It was when they shut off their hearts, seeking to dominate and win. In so doing they stepped outside of Christlike behavior, and, while I'll pray for them, I'm not required to help them in their wickedness. I've seen them lie, I've seen them purposely try to do harm -- these are simply NOT decent people. Sorry if that hurts anyone, but you gotta face hurtful facts, sometimes.

Take heart, though! Evil always fights hardest when God's Grace is closest to winning, and we have to be ready to make welcome those of basic decency and goodwill who differ with us, or wish them well if they will not stay.

17 comments:

Anonymous said...

"these are simply NOT decent people. Sorry if that hurts anyone, but you gotta face hurtful facts, sometimes."

Anyone who knows Kendall or Bishop Duncan knows that neither of them have a mean bone in their body. Kendall says, on his blog, that he has never met you. Yet you condemn them for their principled stand that sex is reserved for traditional marriage. You know, by these standards you would have to condemn most of the godly heritage of saints that went before them: Augustine, Aquinas, CS Lewis, Theresa of Avila, MLK Jr . . .the list is long. Additionally, I have never seen Bishop Duncan utter a mean word directed at a person in the way you have just singled him and others out. Can you point to one ad hominem statement he has made? I ask this, as someone in the middle, not as a part of Duncan's group, because no one has pointed me to one such thing yet. I get the feeling that the intensity of the revisionist's about their cause turns into an anger and, in your post above, a hatred toward anyone who contests them in a firm way. So, if you are a truthful person, which I figure you want to be via this blog. Point to one 'bad' or 'evil' thing Duncan has said, or one time that he has resorted to ad hominem argument. Thank you.

Anonymous said...

What hate-filled diatribe.

You get VERY personal without providing evidence that you have met any of the people you slam or providing evidence that you know what is in their hearts, i.e., that they are "just bad people."

How does THAT work???

It's one thing to be opposed (or even hate) a person's theology/ideology/thinking, etc. It's quite another to get as personal as you have. These are human beings too and regardless of what you think or feel about their beliefs, NO ONE deserves this kind of treatment. NO ONE.

You really do yourself and your cause no good by posting this kind of garbage.

Contrast this to Harmon's response on T19. I am satisfied to let him speak for himself. Reasonable readers who take the time to read this post and his will readily see which behavior is charitable and gracious.

My hope/prayer for you is that God will help you lose your anger and hatred. Not only does it hurt those against whom you rail, it also hurts YOU. Certainly it does nothing to advance the Gospel.

And so the next time you are tempted to write such a hateful diatribe, I encourage you to stop and look inwardly before casting stones outwardly. You may find your own house is equally fragile.

Anonymous said...

"publically ridicules her Christology." (1) I would ridicule her Christology, as reported by the media, but Duncan has not ridiculed it at all. Rather, speaking clearly, whihch itself is virtuous in these time IMHO, he called it 'heterodox.' (2) Again, where is any bile or vitriol from Duncan who--back to the isssue here--has been called a BAD PERSON. Show me the quote.
(3) Duncan has never wanted to tear TEC apart. In my view if the revisionists would have done the right thing, namely, labor for their cause with a theological rationale for SSS (same-sex stuff, win a consensus on the issues itself, including a change of canons, the BCP, and get it passed by the whole church as such, then we might have made it through these years with this fracture. Maybe not, but maybe. Instead they acted precipitously, in a number of ways, and now--because of the VGR consecration and the movement to support SSS as clearly, unambiguously of God--they must bear the blame for the fracturing of the communion and the break up, or breaking apart in some measure of, TEC.

And, again, I would say if one is willing to post such claims, calling Kendall, Duncan, and others evil, let's back it up with some citations. I haven't seen any yet.

Anonymous said...

Yes, that is hate filled rhetoric that you posted. Terrible stuff and a million miles away from anything Kendall or Duncan have ever said. There are mean people out there. Duncan and Kendall, however, have done nothing to earn the label.

Anonymous said...

Ask Kendall or Duncan or Matt Kennedy whether those who unrepentantly practise or support gay sex or abortion will see heaven. Ask them whether they believe in the a literal heaven and a literal hell.

Matt Kennedy has said yes to both propositions.
Akinola - we don't even need to ask.
Duncan and Kendall would never say this so plainly but this is what they believe.

The Gospel is offensive. It's offense is only justified if it is the Truth: but if it is the Truth, no amount of polite conversation, careful language, or avoiding answering questions can remove the offense.

Anonymous said...

I, the author of the first post, will put my name--it's John--at the bottom of my posts to distinguish me from the other "Anonymous" or "Anonymouses" :)! The other "Anonymous" said: "The Gospel is offensive. It's offense is only justified if it is the Truth" apparently to justify making claims that damn other people to hell. All I can say is that Duncan, whom I know best of the lot, is too far along in the Way to have fallen into the trap. He has always spoken civily, charitably, and pleadingly to his theological opponents. Again, there is a ton of stuff on the Internet, copies of his sermons and talks and addresses . . .but no meanness.

It's hardly convincing to play the 'let's corner him with these questions about hell and unrepentant sinners' as if that illumines anything. Don't we all know that's God's business? Aren't we under orders (see 1 Peter) to pray that all might be saved, and live accordingly? And I would add that as far as I know unrepentant pride--and that's very hard to repent of in a once-and-for-all way!--is as damnable, viz., not worthy of cohabitation with God, as anything else. No hierarchy of sins where I come from. For a fact, I know Duncan would agree with me. Why? Because I once had a conversation with him about how tough it is for homosexuals to feel, under the weight of our tradition and churchly condemnation, that they are guilty of a sin like no other (which is how some of them feel). He was 100% in agreement, totally pastoral, totally supportive of the idea that there is not a hierarchy of sins and that part of our pastoral ministry was too relieve the pathological part of that guilt. No, I don't think he's backing down from the gospel or faith once delivered, but he's a lot more pastoral than the blogs give him credit for. (My guess is that Luther was, too.) It's part of the price when history forces you to make a stand.

Anne said...

anonymous said:

"Ask Kendall or Duncan or Matt Kennedy whether those who unrepentantly practise or support gay sex or abortion will see heaven. Ask them whether they believe in the a literal heaven and a literal hell.

Matt Kennedy has said yes to both propositions."

It would be nice if you actually asked me before you presumed to answer in my stead.

I would not presume to answer the first question. No one comes to the Father except through Jesus Christ: the way and the truth and the life. Judgements as to the eternal destiny of souls and bodies belong to God alone.

As for the second question. Yes, I believe that Heaven and Hell are both very real.

Matt Kennedy

Anonymous said...

Mark, I hope you're maintaining well in the midst of all this. I was horrified to learn that they had singled you out and ganged up on you, first in their own little clubhouse, and then coming over here to harass and bully. Please don't let them get you down.

You are a truly good Christian man who has experienced the risen Christ in your own life. He will never abandon you. He loves you -- and these people have nothing whatsoever to do with that.

You've been an inspiration to me and others many, many times on another blog; you write with such truthfulness, straight from the heart. I've meant to come over here and tell you how much I like your blog, your paintings, your "boys" (I have two also), and your devotion to your church. Stay close to those who know and appreciate you for who you are.

I hope things have been going well for you in "real life."

Peace and joy to you, Mark.

-- fs

Anonymous said...

"I was horrified to learn that they had singled you out and ganged up on you"

What are you talking about? Surely the owner of this blog can at least respond and defend his malicious charges, can't he?

Anonymous said...

Matt

I don't undstand why you feel the need to dilute the gospel to placate pagans.

I didn't ask, but on StandFirm someone else did. And you posted:

The scriptures are very clear that whilst human judgements are always untrustworthy and tainted with sin, the judgements of God as revealed in his word are pure and good and holy. Moreover, they are to be applied in rebuking, correcting, encouraging and teaching (2nd Timothy 3:15-16). God, in other words, commands us to communicate and declare his judgement, not our own. This, often, sounds like “judging” but that is because we do not know our scriptures or how the Lord has commanded us to use them in the Church. The most loving thing we can do for ourselves and those enslaved to sin is to keep constantly before our eyes the just judgements and revelations of God.

Link is here: http://www.standfirminfaith.com/index.php/site/article/2525/#39717

You have said many times that hell is real, and that the bible says unrepentant homosexuals will go to hell. Indeed, on the thread last week you argued strongly that to even to offer communion to such people risked both their and your own salvation. In earlier threads you have made exactly the same points about abortion.

This is the Gospel. It is offensive. It is the truth. Not my truth, nor as you say your own truth. God makes the judgements: but tells us what those judgements will be - and His judgement is terribly clear. No one who does such things shall enter the kindom of heaven.

Anne said...

anon,

Read my comment above. I definitely believe in a real heaven and a real hell.

The quote you provide says nothing about whether a homosexual person goes to hell? I simply said that the bible is very clear with regard to the sinfulness of homosexual behavior.

As I noted, again clearly, in my comment above. I believe very strongly in a real Heaven and a real Hell.

Because we are all sinners the only way to enter into the real heaven, is through faith in Jesus Christ.

I believe quite strongly in sola fide.

As someone with Reformed convictions it would be close to impossible for me to say what you suggest I said with regard to unrepentant homosexual people going to hell?

I have not and would not say:

"the bible says unrepentant homosexuals will go to hell."

Hell is certainly real. And unrepentant sinners of any sort go there if they are not in Christ.

"Do you not know that the wicked will not inherit the Kingdom of God? Do not be decieved: Neither the sexually immoral nor idolators nor adulterers nor male prostitutes nor homosexual offenders nor theives nor nor the greedy nor drunkards nor slanderers nor swindlers will inherit the kingdom of God. And that is what some of you were. But you were washed, you were sanctified, you were justified in the name of the Lord Jesus Christ." (1Cor 6:9-11)

And the Church leads people closer to hell and further from when she affirms sinful behavior rather than rebuking it.

But I think you are missing a key element of my thinking on this.

I hold to Reformed doctrine accross the board which means I believe very strongly in the perseverance of believers. ie. once a person has truly surrendered himself/herself to Christ, he/she is adopted into the household of God and his/her ultimate salvation is assured based not on his/her righteousness but on the alien righteousness of Christ.

"he who began a good work in you will carry it on to completion until the day of Christ Jesus" (Phil 1:6)

After someone is justified, the Holy Spiirit begins the work of sanctification: reorienting the heart toward God and moving the will toward obedience. But since salvation is founded on Christ's righteousness the process of sanctification does not effect a sinners eternal destiny.

Thus, doctrinally speaking, someone could be justified but backslide into a sinful behavior such as homosexuality and still be saved.

Anonymous said...

I think that the nastiness of the sex-obsessed, hateful fundamentalists who poured into this site confirms what has been said about them here.

And it is very shocking to see Matt Kennedy attacked as insufficiently "orthodox." That says a lot for the lunatic fringe. I mean, I'm no Kennedy fan, but no one can deny the man's intellectual and spiritual rigor.

These people really are the western equivalent of the Taliban.

Anonymous said...

Replying to Matt:

(whom I'm not attaching as being insufficieny orthodox, for goodness sake!)

Matt writes:

And unrepentant sinners of any sort go there [to hell] if they are not in Christ.

and

once a person has truly surrendered himself/herself to Christ, ...

the issue I'm trying to clarify is not backsliding: it's whether such people have every "slid forwards" in the first place.

I think we both agree that those who persist in homosexual practice, and those who support them in that practice are unrepentant sinners; and that people who does not divest themselves of such advocay and belief have not truly surrendered themselves to Christ, and so are not in Christ.

---------

I'll resist asking about Matt's interpretation of the unforgiveable sin for now: I don't think that applies to most homosexuals, but I think it probably does apply to the leaders and supporters who encourage them, even if once Christian.

Anonymous said...

It's not nasty and hateful if it's true, Sweetcheeks.

Suzer said...

Hi Mark! I, for one, appreciate the viewpoints you share here. It is strange to see so many "anonymous" commenters come here to tear you down, when they don't have the courage to even name themselves. Shows what they're made of, I guess.

While I'm not sure I agree that Duncan and his ilk are "bad people," I do understand the frustration that would lead you to say that. I have made it a rule not to go to Stand Firm or Virtue Online or any of those sites anymore. The anger and hatred shown by some of the posts over there is spirit-killing, which I suspect is exactly what they intend. I would not say that of everyone on those sites, but it is enough for me to avoid them altogether.

As for Duncan, Harmon, etc. -- I simply think they have been taught untruth. While they are certainly learned men, they have absorbed some teachings that are not Christlike, and that in my opinion are Biblically unsupportable. They however, will argue to the end of their days that they are right. And that's fine. I'm not sure it makes them bad people. Are they damaging to the faith? Yes. Are they hurtful to GLBT people and any others they may consider unrepentant sinners? Yes. Do they do some wonderful and giving things with their lives? Yes, the probably do. They are human, like us all.

I do not like what they do with their positions of power and leadership. But all I can do is pray for them, hope that God will open their eyes. In the meantime, I hope you will keep blogging and ruffling feathers a bit. It helps folks (on every side of an issue) think a bit.

Blessings to you...

Susan

Suzer said...

Forgot to add, it's nice to see another Episcopal blogger in Georgia!

Susan

Anonymous said...

The taliban routinely execute people in the street. Liberals don't execute people (except the unborn).

Oh wait a minute, perhaps you've got a point...