Thursday, March 29, 2007

Theological "Debate"

I've posted this on Barkings of an Old Dog, which blog I will link to, as it's gentle, thoughtful, diverse, and liberal (though, doubtless, it will be seen as a monstrous attack on all things orthodox to whom "I disagree" is the cruelest thing you could say). My post there, in response to a specific post of Clumber's, does however apply to the ongoing debate, so I'll put it here:


When I read the explanations of Scripture from Matt, Frederica Matthewes-Greene, Duncan, and any other number of people who want to just love us gays to death, I can't help but think of my mother's expression that they're
"going around their ass to get to their elbow." Dan et al says: "[it addresses
pagan] temple worship: here's why, why, and why." Matt et al says: "Ah! But when
you take it in context of the word 'is' as understood by the Greek fisherman of
the Oygothumpem district of the town of Caesarea, and read that through the lens
of what we expect the Jews of Lower Backwater, Galilee understood at the time at
4 o'clock on a Tuesday, maybe, and after having dragged the text through the
wardrobe to Narnia, we see that it comes to something near enough to what I
believe to suit me."

However, these same people,before any scholarly refutation, will claim a "clear reading" of the text affirms what they say. What kind of honest debate is that?

No comments: