Thursday, March 8, 2007

Maturity of Faith?

It seems to me that a mark of maturity (and I'm certainly not claiming any great measure of maturity for myself) is the ability to tolerate uncertainty, tension, disagreement, even conflict. I'm not talking of hopeless confusion, on the one hand, nor a dead resignation on the other. Rather, I'm talking of the ability to pick a way through life's multiplicity and facticity in a way that is authentic, that has integrity, while recognizing our own limitations and the possibilities within others, even in the face of conflicting beliefs.

Anyone who has studied adolescent behavior, or, for that matter, dealt with or been an adolescent, knows that a part of that developmental stage is a need for certainty coupled with a passionate defense of one's own understanding as the only, or at least, best certainty. There is little tolerance in most adolescents for differing opinion, and passionate defense -- to the point of stormy and melodramatic displays -- of one's understanding is typical. This is a good and necessary part of development. It allows the adolescent psyche to seek a stable platform from which to operate while in the process of differentiation from the parents, thus facilitating the development of a more secure individual for the future. At the same time we respect that development, though, we recognize it is not a stable way to form a society. It's why we restrict the voting age, why we have ages of consent and allow for an adult to have custody of a youth who is physically capable of caring for and providing for him/herself.

Yet, Christianity has historically not given its own structures the same consideration. One needs only to read any theologian, including (perhaps especially) the Church Fathers, to see a sort of adolescent brashness. Edith Pargeter, writing as Ellis Peters, noted in one of her Cadfael mysteries that theologians seemed more intent on discrediting and deriding opposing theologians than on glorifying God. The Church, in its structure and traditions, has attempted to grasp at God, to encapsulate and delimit God's activity and structure Grace in an absolutist, closed system. Again, this is necessary to support the maturing of Christian faith, but, should such a mindset be allowed to define the Christian religion? We protect our socio-economic systems, our political systems, from the excesses and perversions that arise from such artificial certainty, recognizing that these systems must be an adult contract. At the same time, we give over our faith systems to the loudest, brashest and most demanding voice - "Give us Barabbas!!" It would seem we take the care of our money and land far more seriously than the nourishment of our souls.

No comments: