Monday, October 22, 2007

That's IT

I have been accused of not respecting the dignity of Fundies and Reasserters (and one alleged Catholic priest).

Guilty.

They have no dignity and I do not respect them. They've done nothing to earn it. They do tend to cry a lot about being cast as ignorant troglodytes when they say they're really very well-informed on human sexuality, etc. Well, if they are so well-informed and still cling to untruth, that is, indeed, not ignorance. It is stupidity. I don't owe respect to those who behave stupidly and demand respect for it.

I really feel, the more I deal with my fellow Christians - liberal and conservative - that I have no place in this world and will be very glad to leave it. This is the message Christianity has given to me. I do not see that there is good to be accomplished in allowing others to run roughshod over women, gays, the poor, children, whoever because it isn't nice to call them the complete bastards they are! Perhaps I'm truly inhuman and not destined for anything but oblivion, but, whatever, I've had enough of tiptoeing around pretending bad people are good.

I have no interest in relationships, long or short term. I'm not seeking Holy Orders, and, thanks to my fellow Christians, have little interest in what the larger community has to say about me or mine. I am a white man. Poor, yes, but not destitute as yet. Therefore, I have no dog in yonder fight. I'm tired of feeling slapped on the wrist and like a truly crappy individual because I simply recognize that all this niceness is accomplishing nothing and leading to actual harm. From now on, I retire.

I've never had a place in this world, and, increasingly, don't want one. Torn between oppressors and malevolent conspirators on one side and those afraid to do anything on the other, what's the choice?

Humans! Feh!

27 comments:

MadPriest said...

Don't you dare go a.w.o.l. soldier. We need you. Nuff said.

Mike in Texas said...

"I'm tired of feeling slapped on the wrist and like a truly crappy individual because I simply recognize that all this niceness is accomplishing nothing and leading to actual harm."

You are not alone, Mark. Count me in with you.

When more importance is attached to style rather than to substance, it's a big clue that there is no substance.

Interesting that this should come up now. I just wrote the following in an e-mail John Kirkley in response to his blog entry, http://revkirkley.blogspot.com/2007/10/letter-to-presiding-bishop.html.

I woke up far too early this morning and decided to spend some time following links from some of the Episcopal blogs I've been reading. I followed a link your your blog and found your letter to the PB.

Yours is the first statement about the recent HOB meeting and her statement following it that seems to match what I've been thinking. These things have disturbed me so much that I've basically stopped participating in some of the blogs where I've been a regular (Mike in Texas, in case you read any of them) for some time. It is not the statements alone that disturb me so much. I am also greatly disturbed by many reactions to them, even by many G/L people who seem to be developing a "battered spouse" mentality and just keep talking themselves into going back for more abuse.

On a local level, I belong to a wonderfully inclusive and supportive parish. My partner of 37 years has been its music director for the last 27 or 28 years. However, as wonderful as the parish is, we are trapped in a so-called "Windsor Diocese" where the current bishop will not even allow consideration of G/L clergy. As bad as that sounds, he is an improvement over the previous 2 bishops.

We have actively participated in the parish's recurrent sexuality discussions since the late 80s. When the two previous bishops forbade the formation of an Integrity chapter, we started a group of our own. It started simply as a monthly dinner in our home with the G/L choir members, lay readers, and ushers in the parish. It gradually grew to include other G/L parishioners as well as supportive straight parishioners and clergy. Eventually it became a diocesan-wide group far too large to gather comfortably in homes. To his credit, the current bishop makes the diocesan facilities available to the group despite the cries of the "orthodox" to ban us. We had also had the previous bishop and his wife in our home on a number of occasions for dinner during the time he was the parish rector and also while he was bishop, although he still compares us to murderers and when he reciprocates he invites only my partner as if I do not exist.

I keep hearing from others that what we need to do is to let others know us. However, we have been doing that for nearly 30 years now, and I've grown weary. I feel like I am heading into a period of "fasting" from it all, to quote the PB. I am no longer willing to be a spiritually battered "spouse" of TEC.

I thank you for being the voice of those who left before me and those like me who are weary and seriously considering a "fast" from TEC. The next time we're in San Francisco visiting my sister and her partner I hope I find a chance to visit your church and say hello.

Mike in Texas said...

One more thing, Mark. Since I just found your blog today for the first time I've been reading some of your other entries. I was particularly touched by the one titled "Don't Go Where Ya Ain't Wanted" because I have felt exactly the same way.

I have remained silent on the school in Africa because considering it completely apart from the circumstances the idea came from, it's a lovely idea.

However, in the larger picture it struck me as sending the message, "Stop bothering me. Go away and do something else."

I've kept silent about this on the blogs. I don't wish to be critical of that very sweet man, Harry. But I've re-thought it time and time again, and continue to keep coming up with same feeling about it.

Suzer said...

I hear you, brother, and share much of what you are feeling.

Hey -- if I'm ever down in Albany, maybe we can get together for coffee or something. I have a friend there that I keep promising to visit, so if I do make it down at some point and you're interesting in a friendly chat with me and my partner, let me know. I'll contact you through here and leave you my e-mail addy. I have no idea if and when this will happen, but I'll let you know, OK?

Hang in there, Mark! We love ya. :)

Anonymous said...

Hey, Mark, here's loads of hugs comin your way.

I just want you to know that I love you alot. It's true, we don't agree on tons of issues. But, I don't even care.

You are a precious child of God, and an important part of the body of Christ. (Second what MP said.)

Some of the folks most important to me, are the ones I can disagree with the most. Hey, we're all fallen sinners tryin to get it right.

Our Lord bless your life, and fill you up with His total peace.

Grace

KJ said...

We've not met, but in cyberspace, but I would have to say that your place in this world seems to be being the face of Christ to those who feel they have no place in this world. I believe that all that we experience, especially the crap, is to make us of some earthly and heavenly use.

And what others think of us is nor our business. Dying to what others think of us brings a great deal of release, as what they think is quite irrelevant. Talk about freedom!

I hope that the parish you attend, though involved in the current nonsense, has not made that its primary focus. If that were the case for me, I would be consumed by the nonsense on cyberspace AND church and would have to walk away to find rest. It really is much more important to focus on the needs of others rather than ecclesiastical screwing, and the digital age makes it perhaps too easy for us to focus on the screwing, and not the good.

And, if nothing else, remember that in some ways it's an honor to experience this crappy stuff now for the sake of those to follow. They'll have different struggles, and I think that's quite encouraging.

And here I'll quit before I sound like a greeting card. Perhaps it is too late for that. However, these things are easy for me to believe today, so I'll believe them for you for now. However, you can count on needing to believe them for another in the future.

Peace

Wormwood's Doxy said...

Mark---I saw that comment to you and was shocked by the commenter. The stuff that gets published on her blog (with comments moderated, even!) from the asshat side of the fence astonishes me---so I don't know why you got called out.

Don't know what else to say except that I agree with you on what you said here. I struggle to be forgiving, but not at the expense of allowing real harm to continue unchecked.

I guess, at the end of the day, the important thing is that God loves both of us---and loves them too, as much as I question Her judgment. I try to remember that when I want to strangle both the fundagelicals and my fellow liberals who can't or won't call evil when they see it.

Pax,
Doxy

Anonymous said...

Mark, Thanks for being honest about the fundagelicals. They're among the most obnoxious people in the world. The Christian Right is dangerous and we should oppose them as strongly as we can. Best of luck to you.

Doorman-Priest said...

I was so glad to read your post. I often feel bad about not liking Christians, but the fact is so many of them seem to go out of their way to be dislikable, so its sort of a duty on my part really.

D.P.

Anonymous said...

(((Mark)))

Anonymous said...

It's not just you...
I have to wonder about the sanity of anyone who is happily Episcopalian these days.

I am less and less attached to TEC and Christianity in general. As a form, it just comes with too much baggage.

Hang in there. You are not alone. And you are infinitely loved. No army of asshats can change that.

All good things,

Lindy

Anonymous said...

Don't let the bastards get you down.

Try this: instead of cursing their stupidity, just laugh at them. And keep on laughing. They really *are* quite ridiculous funny when you think about it.

MarkBrunson said...

Everyone, thanks.

Well, I am glad to know I'm not alone.

I simply don't think it's enough to laugh them off. People who goosestep and wear elaborate outfits with melodramatic insignia like lightning bolts and skull-and-crossbones are ridiculous-looking too.

It's time we started being serious about this. It's time we let our allies know they're falling down, too. I'm specifically thinking, Doxy, about that commenter, and it makes me think that many of my agnostic/atheist friends may be right about it being primarily self-loathing homosexuals who seek out a place in the church -- maybe it's just that those are primarily elevated to leadership: the safe, inoffensive ones. Look, if they want to invite those kind of monstrous people into their lives, that's fine, but they're inviting them into my life, too, by expecting that I'm to "respect" a clear attack on personhood and allow them to derail and even set policy.

In short, I guess what I would say to my allies is that who you choose to be beaten by is up to you, but don't bring 'em to beat me up, too.

Alcibiades said...

Thinking of you from the other side of the planet, and while I don't know much of your circumstances, my heart is with you.

On the subject of laughing, we're laughing at them, not so they'll go away, but because they'll either get mad and rage impotently (while looking even sillier) or maybe, just maybe, realise the evil stupidity of their ways. Which is, I realise, very unlikely - but stranger things have happened.

Never think laughing at them is an alternative to taking them seriously; the crap that these people come out with is dangerous, and really does kill people. There's nothing wrong with belting them as hard into the ground as you're able - it's just more fun if you're laughing at the same time.

..and if you're too tired for fighting, and need a rest, then that's ok too - the bullies have no right to set anyone's agenda, let alone yours. Never forget it's ok to take time out occasionally - Jesus did.

MarkBrunson said...

And, sorry, Suzer;

I'd love to meet you if you're ever down in Albany. I can arrange to show you the sight.

:D

terri c said...

I am not currently affiliated with a denomination but (perhaps unfortunately) Christianity is the faith tradition that is "in my bones." Mark, I loved your summation. Other things I say is that the mainstream denominations are maintaining "communion" and "dialog" on the backs of us sexual minority persons and that is really not OK; also, I am tired of being a cash cow for the religious right. You might want to read Mark Jordan's The Silence of Sodom for interesting thoughts on gay males in the RC church. Hang in there.

Mike in Texas said...

Mark, some years ago there was a horrible bigot from your town on Prodigy and Delphi both. Michael D. O'Neal, pastor of Gospel Light Baptist Church. Apparently he's still there. I just checked.

Somewhere around here I still have a copy of a sermon he was hawking online, "The Biblical Way to Hate Queers." I've posted an excerpt of it here.

Doorman-Priest said...

Mike: My that O'Neal's a piece of work! Don't you have anti-hate laws?
D.P.

Anonymous said...

Mark,

I didn't read the post you are referring to, but is it possible this commentator is trying to reach these conservative folks, and has a concern for their conversion.

She may not at all be self-loathing, but instead so confident and accepting within herself that she is able to feel compassion for even her enemies.

She may be looking at positive ways to impact their hearts in order to see lasting changes in the culture, and in the church, to even save the lives of GLBT in the third world.

I don't know Mark, and I"m so sorry that you're hurting, but I'm trying to see this also from another perspective. Everyone is not at the same place in this. I wouldn't expect them to be.

Can you understand??


Grace.

Mike in Texas said...

DP, no we do not have laws prohibiting that kind of hate speech.

The US is a bit different than most of the civilized world in that regard. In the US freedom of speech trumps human rights. I know that probably seems backwards to you. It does to me too.

Suzer said...

Wow! I didn't know there was a sight in All-benny. Now we'll have to make plans to come. :)

MarkBrunson said...

Grace,

Then she is wasting her time. The fact is, these people have made clear they will NOT listen. To that end, she is abusing herself to no good end, no worthwhile end. Sad for her, and indicative of an unhealthy sense of self. Even Christ said there were places in which we should shake the dust from our feet. If it were just her being affected, however, that would be one thing. By insisting on allowing these people to continue in our church structure, however, the rest of us are being abused.

The Reasserters should have been forcefully evicted some time ago. There is no hope for them, and we need to shake the dust off and move on, and the church and its leadership have no place exposing the rest of us to needless harm just so they can play at diplomat.

MarkBrunson said...

Madpriest,

I'm sorry. I didn't mean to ignore you, but I was stunned at not being savaged for what I said.

You've made good contacts here, and you see the names of most of those who are willing to actually do and risk something to stand against the spread of this Reasserter/Asshat Darkness, but, I'm afraid, if you're looking to TEC as a national institution for leadership on an international scale . . . well, all I can say is you can see how serious they are about supporting their own "prophetic" stance.

Anonymous said...

Mark,

I listened, though. Someone reached me.

Mark, I know you're so hurt and angry. But, many of these conservative people are not at all what you think.

Outside of these progressive blogs, just about every Christian I know, and folks in general, do not think that homosexuality or same-sex marriage should be affirmed by our culture, or is of the Lord.

And, yet these folks are, for the most part all very caring, moral people who in their own minds, would not want to harm a fly.

Many would give folks the shirt off their back, and are involved in every ministry from working with the poor, to fostering special needs kids.

They truly do not know and understand the damage and harm they are causing.

I think no one is beyond change, and the grace of God, Mark.

Please hang in there, and don't give up trying to make a difference.

Love,
Grace.

MarkBrunson said...

Grace,

I live in and among and surrounded by these sort of people. Of course they're nice . . . to you. Of course they wouldn't hurt a fly . . . if it was straight. Don't underestimate these folks, Grace.

Yes, someone reached you. Do you think we've been trying to reach them for any less time? But, you responded, because you are a good and decent person. Mimi responded. I've known so many who have . . .

. . and that's rather the point -- they have responded, not "will" or "might" or "should."

Just wearing the title "Christian" doesn't mean that these folks have anything to do with - or want anything to do with - God.

Mike in Texas said...

WHY THE LACK OF EXPRESSED OUTRAGE?
Jerry Maneker

I can't think of any reason why most all LGBT people, and decent people everywhere, aren't outraged at the fact that our LGBT brothers and sisters being demonized, and denied full and equal civil and sacramental rights! I do think that the outrage is there, but most feel that to express that outrage, and fight for the same civil and sacramental rights as are enjoyed by all other citizens in the U.S., would hammer home a truth that few really want to confront: The fact that many of those whom they consider "friends" would turn on them at a moment's notice if they did insist on those rights, and that LGBT people and allies would have to face their needed "season of suffering" (To use Martin Luther King's apt words.) before those rights are won!

When one is both filled with self-loathing, and when one wants to be accepted, and when one wants friends and allies, it is disconcerting, to say the least, to risk realizing that their "friends" and their "acceptance" are contingent upon LGBT people "keeping and knowing their place." For example, even in churches, many in the congregation know who are Gay, and will embrace them, even giving them responsible positions in those churches, be it as teachers, deacons, music directors, etc.

However, deep down those Gay people fully realize that if they insist on the same rights as the others in that congregation, such as the right to marriage, or even anemic "commitment ceremonies" as a phony substitute for marriage, all hell will break loose, and their "friends" will quickly turn on them, and it takes someone of enormous ego strength to contemplate this reality, and have to face this reality, if he/she wants to be approved by others.

So, the choice comes between adhering to the status quo where LGBT people remain second class citizens, deprived of full and equal civil and sacramental rights and are "allowed" to be conditionally accepted and used on those terms, OR insist on being treated as everyone else with all the rights and privileges accorded others and know that their "friends'" gloves will come off and they will betray their true colors and turn on them, thereby profoundly hurting them emotionally, and have that hurt culminate in their being prevented from engaging in those ministries to which they have been called in the church; being similarly betrayed and emotionally, if not physically, hurt in secular society by many who either don't go to church or who do go to church who discriminate against LGBT people, even to the point of violence, all the while thinking that they are doing God a favor by so doing.

One of the worst mistakes we can make is to be inauthentic so that we can win others' approval, and be accepted, fully knowing that that "acceptance" is contingent upon that inauthenticity, even carrying that inauthenticity to the point where many Gay people have not only internalized homophobia but externalize that homophobia so that they demonize and condemn others who dare to assert their right to sit at the same table, partaking of the same food, as everyone else.

Jesus says, "For what shall it profit a man, if he shall gain the whole world, and lose his own soul?" (Mark 8:36) This admonition isn't only given for the benefit of Christians, but for all people who seek to live an authentic, fulfilling life!

If you're liked and accepted for being something other than who you are, and you compound that inauthenticity by self-loathing that manifests itself in your own misery, and you then further compound that self-loathing by expressing homophobia to others who do seek to live free and equal lives, you are not only committing a great sin against yourself, but you are committing a great sin against the truth and against others, thereby helping to retard the realization of full and equal civil and sacramental rights for all LGBT people.

This retardation can also be seen to take the form of begging, and being grateful, for crumbs in the form of incrementalism: for example, settling for Domestic Partnerships and Civil Unions rather than fight for full marriage rights; voting for a politician because, although he/she still demeans you, he/she seems to demean you less than another politician; justifying voting for reactionary candidates by viewing oneself as not being a single issue voter (In this connection, see "The Pathology of the Gay Conservative".); justifying homophobic religion by attending homophobic churches, and giving credibility and justification to homophobic clergy by attending their churches and putting money in their collection plates which also help get their message out how Gay people are responsible for assorted ills in society, such as the breakdown of the family, the ephebophilia scandals that have rocked the RC Church, and for Hurricane Katrina.

When the chickens come home to roost due to selling out one's integrity, selling out one's brothers and sisters, and selling out the principle of full and equal civil and sacramental rights for all, and LGBT people are then forced to confront the ugly truth regarding the cost paid by, and incurred due to, those sell outs, maybe it will only be then that Jesus' statement will hit home: when one sells his/her soul, when you sell yourself out, when you sell others out, you will reap the whirlwind of having sacrificed justice for living a life of illusion bereft of authenticity, justice, and love.

And, when one finally realizes that fact, despite living this inauthentic life, he/she has pushed back the clock when full and equal civil and sacramental rights could have been achieved, then he/she will be far more motivated to become meaningfully activist.

Never be afraid! Never unduly care what others think of you! And never, never, never, seek to curry favor with others by selling yourself short or selling yourself out, and/or selling our brothers and sisters out for any reason!

For to do so is no less a sin than than are the expressions of hate out of the mouths and actions of the most virulent homophobic elements in our society! Because, you see, that hate expressed by those homphobic elements is largely fueled, and made possible, because of those LGBT people and "allies" who favor the status quo so as to be somewhat "accepted" and, like all bullies, religious, political, and other homophobes are emboldened both by our silence, as well as by those who curry favor with them by selling themselves and others out, and by settling for incrementalism at the expense of justice for everyone, as most recently seen in the pathetic ENDA bill and by Obama's keeping Mary Mary and McClurkin on board.

Only when our outrage is expressed, when meaningful grassroots activism occurs that is contingent upon taking to heart Jesus' admonition that we are never to sell out our souls, so that LGBT people and allies demand that LGBT people be treated with the same dignity as accorded everyone else, that full and equal civil and sacramental rights will be won, and not a moment before!

Anonymous said...

Hey, ((Mike,))

I agree that you should always be authentic, and honest, true to yourself. It's a great way to know who your friends really are. They'll still love and accept you, even if they disagree with every word out of your mouth. It's the only way to live.

But, please don't leave the church to do all this. We need both of you. Speak the truth, and stay around.

Who is to say that our Lord has not called you and Mark for such a time as this. It's not about us. It's all about our Lord, and His purpose for our lives in advancing the gospel of the kingdom.

Grace.