Responding to the comments on the previous thread (which were overwhelmingly supportive -- I thank you), it occurs to me that what really gets me is the way in which our allies - and, more importantly, those on whose behalf the fight is being conducted - are falling down, utterly.
We keep talking about doing something "prophetic," but, to put it bluntly, haven't the guts to back that up. It's cowardice at best, laziness at worst -- future generations will benefit, we say, while not lifting a flipping hand to do more than lodge protests, to engage in hand-wringing-bitch-and-moan parties on the internet, try to "convince" ossified brains by being oh-so-polite, and . . . of course . . . the old Anglican standby committees, committees, committees!
What a joke.
No wonder no one takes us seriously. Perhaps, just perhaps, I've misjudged Rowan and his back-and-forth, up-and-down, now-you-see-him-now-you-don't act -- maybe he's trying to set forth the unique proposition that we are SUPPOSED TO FREAKING DO SOMETHING FOR OURSELVES!!!!
Ya think?
Prophets are not nice people -- that's why people kept driving them off and trying to kill them. What we're seeing - from gays and lesbians, and allies - is a lovely middle-class pantomime of prophecy -- as long as no one really gets down on us and we can win the PR war, it's worth it. Give me a break! What is wrong with these people?! Tell the truth to the ABC and everyone else -- these are rotten people seeking to do real harm, and they won't stop there if a little enlightened self-interest helps you, Milord! Stop trying to convince them your the good guys -- show them that you are up against the bad guys! Stop enabling the homophobes by being so damn polite to them!
That's if we actually have something to say!
At this point, the continual little sidestep that the liberal side are dancing inspires nothing so much as disgust at an obvious, self-parodying political attempt at emotional ingratiation. Stop being so damn polite to these lukewarm, self-interested "allies," too! You've let Schori run right over you without so much as an attempt to hold her responsible for her utter incompetence and disingenuousness as a leader!
I keep saying "you" because, until I start seeing some fire there, I'm out. Why fight for those determined to be mistreated, who will simply beat you if you don't allow them to be beaten? No one takes you seriously, no one's joining up from outside or speaking up from other corners because of the simple fact that you make make absolutely no effort to appear that you're taking it seriously yourself. There's no engagement. Emotional engagement is messy, but without it, you're not taking what you're professing seriously, and no one else will either.
On the previous thread, I wrote:
It's time we let our allies know they're falling down, too . . . it makes me think that many of my agnostic/atheist friends may be right about it being primarily self-loathing homosexuals who seek out a place in the church -- maybe it's just that those are primarily elevated to leadership: the safe, inoffensive ones. Look, if they want to invite those kind of monstrous people into their lives, that's fine, but they're inviting them into my life, too, by expecting that I'm to "respect" a clear attack on personhood and allow them to derail and even set policy.
In short, I guess what I would say to my allies is that who you choose to be beaten by is up to you, but don't bring 'em to beat me up, too.
I hate to tell you guys, but if you're serious about unity, then what you're doing is utter crap. Forget the justice -- just look for unity, because justice cannot be unified with those who deny it. If you're serious about justice, then grow up and stop trying to look like the good guys and be the good guys. Whatever you do, here's the thing: your unity with someone is going to be lost -- at the present tack, it's going to be those who are outspoken and determined to reform, and then, those who're left will have no one to speak out when the wolves finally turn on the nice, quiet, polite gays and other liberal "impure."
1 comment:
"You've let Schori run right over you without so much as an attempt to hold her responsible for her utter incompetence and disingenuousness as a leader!
That's because we can't find her down there at the foot of the cross.
And you might add Bishop Robinson to the list of those who ought to be held accountable. Despite having already been already canonized with
Mary and Joseph, et al... he voted for the most recent ridiculous statement from the HOB. Why? Because he's got his so now he can sign on to all the lunacy of the bishops? Give me a break...
You are on target with all this.
Lindy
Post a Comment