We. Don't. Have. A. Place. At. Any. Table!
YOU ARE NOT HERE!
YOU ARE HERE
You're place at the table is this: TEC has been told, "Hey, you give us the money for food, and we'll let you sit with us!" The Primates have had dessert and coffee and are laughing behind their hands at you while you wait for them to open the door for you.
NO. TABLE.
12 comments:
This is the only thing you have said I would argue with, Mark.
Since I have taken communion from the hands of gay and lesbian priests, I can say that they DO have a place at The Table---whether anyone likes it or not.
The main point--for me, anyway--is to open the way for *all* those who are called to serve God at that Table. Not just those who happen to live in a diocese with an inclusive bishop.
And to reach the point where the orientation of both the celebrant and the communicants is never an issue.
Having said all that, I agree completely with you that progressives are not doing what needs to be done. Bonnie Anderson's comment to Via Media Forth Worth was the most egregious recent example, in my book. You simply do not tell faithful Christians in trouble to "saddle your own horses"!
And you never, ever lay a cross on the back of someone else, which is exactly what our national leadership has done. For +Katharine to use crucifixion language and to tell GLBTs to "wait" for full recognition of their personhood, their relationships, and their vocations is incredibly offensive and damaging. I confess that I expected so much more from the first woman PB---but then I think about Margaret Thatcher and wonder why I was surprised...
Doxy,
Of gays and lesbians, that's true -- no one can separate us from communion in Christ. However, I'm talking about the sheep-bleating that we hear about TEC's position in the AC -- whether we like to hear the truth or not, TEC is being disregarded and ignored. We DO NOT have a place from which to launch any sort of help for GLBT's or women or anyone else within the AC.
Davis Mac-Iyalla feels differently, Mark. He is adamant that TEC makes a difference in the lives of GLBT Christians in Africa.
That's the only reason I don't give up on the whole thing, quite frankly. Because Davis sat on my sofa, looked me in the eye, and said "We need you. You make a difference."
Davis has put his very life on the line to make a place for GLBTs in the church, and he says he needs us.
How can I, who risks NOTHING for the Gospel, tell him that I'm just too pissed off to be bothered?
How can I---in my nice, safe, suburban, lily-white, upper-middle-class parish, say "Sorry man---you're on your own"?
That would be the same as what Bonnie Anderson did to Fort Worth Via Media--told them they were on their own and then flew back to her nice, inclusive diocese. (Can you tell that this REALLY pissed me off?)
Can't do it, my friend. As much as I hate the whole freaking idea of the Anglican Communion, I cannot leave Davis twisting in the wind. He is not an abstraction, like the AC is. We have broken bread together---and caring for my brother Davis, and all those he works with and for, is an obligation now.
Doesn't mean I have to like it---and doesn't mean that I won't keep criticizing our leadership loudly, strongly, and at every turn either.
Since the dyke of alternative episcopal oversight has been breached and shows no sign of ever being repaired, I'm all ready to support TEC oversight of parishes and dioceses in the Global South that don't like the "Hate Fags" agenda. Sauce for the gander, eh?
That may be the ultimate answer when schism comes---by continuing to insist on our Anglican identity, TEC will be in a position to protect the Davises of the world.
And that, dear Mark, is the ONLY thing worth fighting for in all this mess---to keep Davis and others like him from being sacrificed in a very literal way on that stone table of yours.
Ah, Mark. We are both very fortunate that we do not know each other in the realyworld, since we would drive each other mad. I tend to be a "glass is half-full" kind of guy, which does not mean that I settle for the status quo.
However, there is nothing that other "believers" can do that defines my spirituality. If there is, then I've given them power that is not theirs to have.
That's just one of the lessons I learned in my liberating exodus out of Evangelical Land.
Please feel free to tell me to "Shut the fuck up!"
Peace
Mark, I continue to pray for you, my friend. God's blessings be upon you.
Mimi,
I thank you. I certainly need prayers.
KJ,
I'm not complaining about the acceptance of gays and lesbians in TEC, or the degree of its liberal bent. Even here in good ol' SOWEGA our priest made a rather bold sermon defending liberality and the liberal tradition and criticizing the Reasserters for cutting themselves off.
My point is this:
Our leadership is sedentary and complacent. Because they go to Lambeth and Rowan pretends to listen, they are satisfied. Until we are at a point at which we can elect ourselves new and effective leadership, we have to relegate them to a completely ceremonial position -- which is all they serve at this "table" calle the Anglican Communion. We are not listened to and our leadership is fine with that, apparently.
Doxy,
I am not suggesting that we abandon our brothers and sisters in the Third World. Rather, we should be more concerned about that than the survival of TEC, which is what Schori et al are solely concerned with, I assure you.
Frankly, I couldn't have looked Davis in the eye and accepted his gratitude. I would've been too ashamed, knowing how much we can do and how little we've actually done.
That's my point, you see, not that TEC is doing too much, but too damn little on anything importance. If our bishops will not act to defend and advocate those in need, then we must, as Christians, shove them out of the way and take over. We can do nothing, though, as long as we entertain this fond notion that simply belonging to the Anglican Communion means that we are accomplishing what we can or should.
I'm not agitating for the destruction of the AC, but the creation of a new worldwide communion which will take seriously and actively its duty to gays, lesbians, transexuals, the poor, children, women and stop worrying about our damned market share!
If we are so concerned that we'll fail without the funding, then what is our faith in? What does our action spring from?
I'm not agitating for the destruction of the AC, but the creation of a new worldwide communion which will take seriously and actively its duty to gays, lesbians, transexuals, the poor, children, women and stop worrying about our damned market share!
Actually, I think that was what I was arguing for too...
And the reason I even make the argument is because I was ready to cut the ties completely. What do I care what a bunch of homophobic asshats in Africa or Latin America choose to do? Or to plagiarize a famous philosopher: "What has Abuja to do with Raleigh?"
I was---and remain--concerned with how MY parish welcomes (or doesn't) the marginalized. Africa seems mighty far away on any given day, and it's easy to convince myself that it doesn't matter in my little world.
So that's why I was making the case. Because *I* was ready to focus only on my parish, my diocese, my national church.
And, FTR, I did not "accept Davis' gratitude." He wasn't being grateful, for one thing---he was calling me to action. Much like MP does...by reminding me that I'm not the only one that matters.
So---I agree with everything you said about the bishops and about it being our responsibility to lead since they won't. And I agree that we need a new Anglican Communion---one that offers the fullness of God's blessing and mercy to ALL who come in search of it.
Pax,
Doxy
Doxy,
I'm sorry if I have offended. My use of the word gratitude was merely a reflection of my own attitude when telling someone they are needed and making a difference. I certainly can't imagine you playing "Lady of the Manor" nor Davis playing the role of one effusive over being "Brought up to the big house." I merely meant to convey those points that, after long miscommunication on my part, we seem to agree on; we could be doing more.
I should've just shut up and dropped the whole topic like I promised.
No offense, my friend! I just wanted to clarify.
I share your anger at the hierarchy, and unlike many progressives, I'm not ready to "make nice." So I'm glad I have an ally SOMEWHERE in the blogosphere! ;-)
Cheers,
Doxy
Well said.
Very well said.
Lindy
Post a Comment