Tuesday, October 2, 2007

Maybe It's Just Me

I've no use for heroes. Those are people you look to to defend you, and will stand up for no matter how ridiculously ineffectual they are . . . "My hero, right or wrong!"

I think a lot of liberals have our Presiding Bishop as a hero.

All she seems to do is travel around, speaking here and there, and I constantly hear "Wow! Just listen to her! She's great!"

Have you listened to her? Other than a husky, hypnotic voice, I mean.

She may sound great, but strip away the usual cliches, the ecclesial buzzwords, and the occasional mild joke, and I believe she is the most banal speaker I've ever heard. She may be brilliant, but she certainly hides it. Maybe it's just her spectacular humility. As for what she's saying, it's hardly any different from Bush-style "Stay the course" rhetoric. Try actually listening to her, reading a transcript of one of these spectacularly trite addresses, giving clearly perfunctory assurances, and you'll wonder if it's not an election year.

I understand that women were glad to have her elected. Hell, I was glad to have a woman PB, as I've found women are often more effective at actually accomplishing things than men -- especially in ecclesial surroundings! But, beginning with wriggling her way into the House of Deputies to ensure the excresence we call B033 and its passage, right up to her current use (for the 15,000th time) of "We're not going backwards!" if I were a woman, I'd be demanding a recount! She is a disgrace compared to every female leader I've ever had the honor of serving under. Frankly, I've begun to think that if you hear "We're not going backwards!" and find it anything but hollow, you may, as Lewis Black suggests, need shock treatment.

As far as I'm concerned, KJS has a loooooong way to go to prove herself worthy of the title "Leader." At this point, I'm forced to conclude that she is rendered either completely incompetent by the systemic built-in mediocrity that seems to be a prerequisite of the episcopate, or she is a career politician of the worst, most duplicitous sort, working with what she has learned is an easily-duped and criminally self-negligent constituency.

Shape up, Katharine, or step down.

3 comments:

Anonymous said...

Oh, I think she's probably a great old gal and probably the smartest PB we've had in my lifetime. I'd love to have a beer with her and talk about squid which, just personally, I think are from outer space.

The problem with ++Katharine is that the institution which she is bound to preserve has framed the discussion in terms of homosexuals instead of homophobia. For them it's about pretty little gay people. Patient, long suffering, and insignificant little gay people. Nothing will change until the discussion is re-framed to examine the evil of homophobia, and the homophobes themselves are the ones whose place in the life of the church is under consideration. THEN we'll see some change... whatever century that may happen in.

Linda Diane McMillan

MarkBrunson said...

Well, if she doesn't address that, she's not really that great or smart, to me.

Again, maybe it's just me.

Anonymous said...

Well, I do think she's smart about squid. Probably smarter than me about a lot of things.

Clearly she is clueless about either the gay world or the Gospel. I'll give you that.

Lindy