Christ Church, Savannah, has made its dramatic bid to go to Uganda (if only they would). They're playing it all breathless and heroic, of course, but, unfortunately for them, they are not the only people in the Diocese of Georgia with access to computers.
The reality is this:
Christ Church the building is important only as a monument. It would honestly have more meaning to Methodists than to Episcopalians, given its relationship to the Wesleys. It has styled itself as our principle church, though only one church was ever officially named as our Pro-Cathedral, and that was not Christ Church but St. Paul the Apostle's.
The leadership of Christ Church is considered to be, even by most conservatives, a group of extremist nutballs. There's no kinder way of putting it. Having huffed off to play in a corner alone numerous times, the congregation is no longer considered a de facto part of the diocese. The fact is, both Bishop Louttit, and moreso, his predecessor, Bishop Shipps, have been very considerate of the conservatives, bending over to reassure them that they would not be forced to endure women in the Sanctuary nor queers outside the choir. Shipps is notoriously conservative Anglo-Catholic (even wearing the zuchetta), and even he grew weary of the constant complaining of Christ Church. In short, Christ Church has no complaints in its own diocese (they're even allowed to use the '28 and only the '28 Prayer Book) and has been represented by two theologically-conservative bishops who've allowed them (to the detriment of the entire diocese) to do pretty much as they wish.
The straw was overt threats in the form of letters to the present Bishop to withdraw church property from the diocese, resulting in a letter from the chancellor (which Christ Church tried, unsuccessfully, to use as proof of martyrdom) saying that they had been given enough time to decide if they were in or out, to declare themselves within in a certain time period, and, if they were in, to pay money owed to the diocese, and if they were out, to relinquish the property and godspeed. The result was a sudden back-pedalling from Christ Church vestry saying, in essence, "Are you severing your pastoral relationship, Bishop? We don't want to leave. Please don't make us." The chancellor wrote back that they were being given options, not an ultimatum.
So, it is dishonest to portray this as Christ Church's out-of-the-blue decision: they chose one of two options, even beyond the deadline given. They take people none of us are acquainted with, as they've withdrawn even when deigning to attend Diocesan Convention, and money we've operated without for at least a decade I know of.
As for the building, I'd be just as happy if they sold it to the Methodists or Savannah's Historical Society, as it is the ugliest of the diocese's churches, looking more like a bank or a Masonic lodge than a church. It certainly is nothing in comparison to the Cathedral of St. John the Baptist (St. Jean Batiste[sic]) in Savannah(RC), the Episcopal church of St. Paul the Apostle, or even Temple Mickve Israel, built by Christian immigrants who'd never seen a proper synagogue and built a lovely church with a Star of David where the cross would normally be. As for their owning the place; they own it as much as I own Georgia because I pay taxes and live here. I can, of course, take Georgia with me if I move to a different state.
No comments:
Post a Comment