I just really feel like I don't have a place on my favorite blogs, anymore (with the exception of Madpriest, of course, but I usually have little of substance to offer there, it being far above my own intellect - yes, I mean that).
I simply am not impressed by Harry's story of dinner with Katharine. Not Harry's telling, mind you, as he is a splendid writer, but the event itself. The whole "build me a school" thing -- it seems terribly contrived, and a rather easy out for KJS. Let's face it, there is little else she could've suggested that would have tugged more at the heartstrings, short of building a school/orphanage/kitten-and-puppy shelter. I'm not against the project - if I can help, I will - but it seems like the kind of starry-eyed, busy "charity" that so enveloped ladies of the Victorian and Edwardian times. Give them something to feel important about, and they won't agitate for better treatment. Its busywork. On another level, our being "given a charge" feels almost as if we're being told we have to buy our plates at the family table.
Look, if you want to build schools, great, but don't go all gooey and hero-worshippy because it was KJS's idea. You could've done that on your own. Besides, there are kids in need right here, so why make a demand for something somewhere else? Why make a "charge" that is so damn easy to give to and so easy to feel good about?
I'm just not impressed, and rather depressed at how easily everybody seems to have simply bought into this project and the unquestioned goodness and holiness of "our Kate."
So, I'm definitely in the minority -- I neither particularly like nor trust KJS; I think the school-building is a bit of bread-and-circuses. All this makes me, apparently, selfish, bad and small. So be it. One poster said "It's not about YOU!" I know. Nor did I mention so. However, I also don't think it's about YOU feeling better about being treated second-class because you've been given a homework project. And that makes me awful, too.
So, I just don't feel welcome, any longer, on the blogs, and will keep away, but I will say:
Build the school, but don't stop there if you're serious about changing the world. Give everything. Don't let God use you, let Him use you up. And, for God's sake, stop acting like Katharine Schori gave you some great honor -- you're better than that, and it was your right, anyway.
12 comments:
Hey Mark, I don't know if I'm welcome here, or not, but I honestly did not take Harry's piece as some kind of blind adoration of ++Katharine -- on the contrary. It sounds to me like there are some sharp edges to Harry. Like when he said:
“Could you sleep at night.”
She smiled and said, “No. A couple of nights were really hard.”
I said, “Thank you for being willing to not be able to sleep for us.”
So in the end I saw irony in his response, not ultimately irony in the doing of the thing, but irony in saying, o.k., you tell me to build a school, well, by golly, I'm gonna do that because I know I am worthy, whether you dare to proclaim and back it or not, as well as whether the folks in Tanzania recognize it or not. That's why he's a hero to me -- not that he rolled over and said o.k., do what you want, and I'll just be a nice house boy and do your bidding until you get around to recognizing my full humanity -- instead, he questioned her, he did not let her off scot free, he forgave her without endorsing her actions, and he rose above it all.
Now, both as a non-GLBT and as an individual, I would not presume to suggest that his approach is right and your rejection of it is wrong. There is plenty of good reason for all members of TEC to despise the HoB's NOL statement and to want to take some action in protest or seriously consider abandoning the church entirely. I just happen to see Harry's response as a different kind of defiance and protest, and I read all the responses as being in support of Harry, not ++Katharine. At least that's the basis for my support. It's his turning the other cheek, not to be passive, but in the context of the kind of non-violent protest and defiance intended in its original historical context. That strikes me as extraordinarily difficult in its own way. But.... yes, I could be very wrong.
Klady,
The don't go where ya ain't wanted is about me. I simply don't find it wise to just "expect the best in people" and that makes me persona non grata.
As far as the view of KJS and the school, I hope you're right, but I'm simply afraid everyone is going to be disappointed. If, indeed, building the school is an act of defiance and protest, then it is about us, and, as such, will receive absolutely no payback. To wax poetic about the virtues of education is great, but, remember, Akinola is educated, and, at least partly, in the West. If it's being done for itself, why was it needed from KJS as a "charge" -- why hasn't she made this a concern of wider interest before.
We were given busywork.
The failing in New Orleans was not doing something the HoB couldn't do, but in failing to acknowledge that we're stuck in a backward and pointless place because of politics and ill-advised attempts at a reconciliation. They made no effort to acknowledge, officially, that this is untenable and unacceptable -- a "for now" would've made the "where we are" acceptable. Such lack of sensitivity and insight is simply shocking.
As I said, I'm all for building the school. I'll help, if I can, and spread the word.
But I still think it's busywork to keep us distracted.
Mark,
As far as I'm concerned, you're always welcome.
As a matter of fact, I think you might help folks stay grounded in reality.
Personally, I've grown weary of simply reacting to the supposed "news" lately. Even thought about shutting down the blog.
Then this "project" came along. Something new. Who knows where it will lead. But at least it is better than the constant reacting to the extremists, or so it seems to me.
I'll not forget what Bp. Katharine did at GC2006. But, I'll still work with her.
Is it busy work? Maybe. But then again, maybe not.
There's 2,000 in the community now. What if we find out that we actually can pull off such a project? What if the constant venting with words is transformed into real actions, of which building a school is just the first step?
Yea, I'm an incurable romantic optimist. Oh well. Takes all kinds, right?
YOU ARE NOT ALONE!
I didn't go all gooey over that little essay on people's toes either. It wasn't that charming. You are absolutely spot-on in your assessment. Katharine changed the subject. Good for her and the institution.
Linda Diane McMillan
Mark--I didn't chime in when all that started because I was away at an EFM training and had no Internet access---which may be the greatest blessing of the weekend, but I digress...
I share many of your feelings about KJS. I believe that many are giving her a pass because she's a woman---and I say that as a out-and-proud feminist. She has sold GLBTs out at every turn, and has had the gall to use all that crucifixion talk in the process. I keep thinking, "Is this the best we can do?" And then I remember Frank Griswold and am reminded not to expect much from any of them.
I don't know how to feel about the project. I think Harry is an amazing man, and I have reason to know about the dire need for education (particularly for girls) in that part of the world. I do worry that it's just another way for rich, white Westerners to feel good about themselves---but if kids get educated in the process, I'm not sure that's a bad thing.
What I *do* know is that your voice is an important one and I hope you don't stay away. I've said all along that I want a church with a diversity of voices and opinions--unlike the Talibanglicans who want a church in one-part harmony. If you can do so without harming your spiritual or mental health, I think it's important that you call 'em like you see 'em.
Pax,
Doxy
Mark, I understand your feelings, but have a very different (and non-gooey or starry-eyed) take on the matter at hand. Having been to a third-world country, even for the brief amount of time I was there, I understand why our involvement there is very much needed. They need our witness, and we need theirs. There will be difficulties along the way, and misunderstandings, but perhaps also moments where we can learn from each other. It won't be easy. Everthing in Africa is on "Africa time", which means it takes 10 times as long as you think it will to get anything done. Perhaps there's a lesson in that.
I don't have any feelings about KJS one way or the other. I don't think this is busy work, though -- far from it. I look at it sort of like Jesus washing his Disciples' feet. We need the perspective of the people in Tanzania, just as they desperately need our perspective, in order to better understand one another. And what better way to fellowship together than to gather around what is most important -- children -- and do some good for them?
I don't think your different perspective on this should make you feel unwelcome, however. I value everyone's opinion -- we need your thoughts as well as the more "starry-eyed" folks. I hope you won't absent yourself for too long. :)
Once again:
I have no problem with the project, or helping Tanganyika (if we're not going to help people on our doorstep), nor do I deny the need for education (though, I'm not sure what good it'll do if there is little infrastructure for providing better jobs, if, indeed, Tanganyika is that poor). I've said I will try to help by connecting people with the resources - if I can ever get a central contact for such people. I have very little money, and I'm sure as hell not going to Africa - I don't even go as far as Atlanta without a pressing emergency.
As I've said, I think KJS provided busywork, a placebo, in order to divert attention. To put it bluntly, when the school is built - as I have every faith it will be - Schori will say "Look what a good thing I gave the gay community to do, and aren't you proud?!" to the glbt's and to everyone else she'll say, "Look what a good thing I got the gay community to do!"
I'm not a pessimist - if I were, I would have nothing to do with the school and would be encouraging others to abandon it, too - but I am a social realist. In poor countries, a general education is secondary to specific training to make a viable economy and the infrastructure to support it. In any institution, those who are in power, especially through election, are going to use any opportunity to advance their own public image ahead of any - even a dearly held - cause.
Suzer,
Nobody is saying that Africa doesn't need schools. Your having been there does not make that any clearer than it was before. I am clear on that.
The thing is that Africa is not the subject, schools are not the subject, homosexuals are not the subject. Homophobia is what's on the table and Katharine won't acknowledge it.
If God calls you to build a school in the far off wherever then you go right on ahead and God love you for doing it. But, there are others who feel that God has called them to be a full and equal members of the Episcopal Church and I don't think they are going anywhere until that happens. Nor should they. It's an important stand to take, not just for GLBTQ Christians but for anyone else who may be marginalized. This business of pushing the edge is what has kept the church alive, it's where the energy is. Cut that off and you've lost the soul of Anglicanism.
Why should people put the welfare of their families and their children on hold while they build a school in the far off world? That's just dumb. You say that children are the most important thing yet you seem not to care for the welfare of the children in gay and lesbian families at all! Gay and lesbian families need protection here and they need it now. Where is Katharine on that? Where are you?
Linda Diane McMillan
Wow. Linda, I certainly did not mean to hit a nerve. My blog is private, which makes it impossible for you to know me. I am a lesbian in a committed relationship, and have been a full supporter of GLBT equality within and without the church. I've worked both with an African mission (in a country that is anti-gay) and with Soulforce.
I'm not suggesting anyone put their or their family's welfare on hold. Just the opposite. It may do us and our families some good to help with this project. I think the goal is much more long term than anyone can see.
In my work in Sierra Leone, I made some friends. These friends understand my desire to improve lives, both here and in S.L. When it came to pass that I told a couple of my S.L. friends that I am a lesbian, they were gracious in their understanding. They did not reject me. It may have created some understanding, that they will pass along to their friends and families. They may not understand completely, but their world view and what they've been taught is completely different than mine. Once a personal relationship is created, a process of love and tolerance begins -- you might be surprised.
There's a bigger picture here. We need to not become so inwardly focused (and believe me, I'm guilty of that every single day) that we lose sight of the impact our witness can make through a project like this. And the impact their witness can have on us. By no means would I suggest we drop fighting for GLBT rights here. I would suggest we can do both -- work within our church, work within the world.
Susan
Mark, why do you make the leap from disagreeing with some folks on a blog to thinking you don't belong there? It ain't necessarily so, my friend.
Because you work on building a school, doesn't mean that you give up on the fight for LGTB rights. As for the motives of other people, sometimes it's better not to go there.
We can't do all the good works in the world that need doing, so we pick one or two where we can make a difference.
God bless you, Mark.
Mark, why do you make the leap from disagreeing with some folks on a blog to thinking you don't belong there? It ain't necessarily so, my friend.
Dammit woman! I never said I wasn't overly sensitive! ;)
Mark, when you write: "Give them something to feel important about, and they won't agitate for better treatment."
...I have to say a huge AMEN to that.
I've long been convinced that this has been the case for the last 20 years. I'll have to explain more later.
Post a Comment