Tuesday, September 1, 2009

Some Examples

I've just been too tired and depressed to write much more on my half-formed theory, and appreciate the conversation that we've had so far. I'm working on more, hopefully clarifying and simplifying some of what I'm thinking.

I've found some examples of the things directing my thinking, though.

First, Grandmere Mimi took the bold step of going to Mary Landrieu's town-hall meeting on healthcare - she reports on her experience here and here.

Note in her descriptions the almost-unconscious use of non sequitir by the opponents to national healthcare, the repetition of lies and misinformation fed to them in the face of being told that these "facts" are lies. Note the simplistic inability to comprehend that they might be wrong or misinformed, the inability to comprehend that others don't see absolute truth in all they're saying. Note, also, that, in extremis, they resort to an almost animalistic violence, screaming, threatening, abusing. This is bizarre behavior. The fact that it can be pointed to so often is a vindication, rather than a refutation, of my position that this is an indication of a sort of mental dysfunction in a large group of human beings. We all feel fear, we all have anxiety in the face of change, all defend their positions - I'm doing it now! - but the simple fact is, we see that there are some simply incapable of rising above those feelings to a level of enlightened discourse.

Now, in this example, we have an interview with Nicky Gumbel, the founder of the somewhat-controversial Alpha Course. The interviewer is aggressive, without a doubt, but not, I believe, offensive (for those who doubt it, please look at other examples of British interviews). In response, Gumbel is evasive, to put it kindly. It is clear that his answers are meant to manipulate. It is equally clear that his answers are having no effect on the aggressive interviewer. Gumbel is an example of the clever agent of entropy - keeps dodging and weaving, aiming his message to minds that will be influenced by the basest of arguments. He is aiming it at those who are incapable of questioning, of rising above feelings - "See! He's a nice guy! He says so!" - to enlightened examination.

Finally, we have this article from Chief Rabbi Sir Jonathan Sacks. Sacks' commentary is always thoughtful, frequently challenging, sometimes annoyingly erudite. Specifically, I was moved by the example he gives of Rabbi Shimon Ha-Amsoni. I leave it to you to read the story. The entire article is a description of a wise - an enlightened - approach to knowledge, to our communal cooperation and decision-making, and the story of Rabbi Ha-Amsoni is the consummate example of the sort of evolution of consciousness I've been trying to explain - the ability to live with the experiment, and with the results.

Another example is found here. This is from the "loyal opposition" in relation to me as a Christian believer, yet he shows that ability to think "above," so to speak. He can look in a holistic fashion, outside of his own milieu, and see both the good and the bad, and to question his own approach. While he stays within his own basic convictions, this is not the weakness of intractability, but the strength of real belief. Note, also, his gracious response to some rather snide comments, showing a willingness to engage.

ADDENDUM:

Thanks to Rebecca Nail for bringing this to my attention. It's a fairly well-balanced take on the issue, I think.

4 comments:

June Butler said...

Mark, I certainly don't hate you for anything, luv. I shake my head nearly every day and wonder, "Who ARE these people? Where did they come from?

It IS possible to have civil discussions and disagree. Some folks just don't care to. My way or the highway, and f*ck you.

MarkBrunson said...

Thanks, Mimi!

I agree there are some it is possible to have civil disagreement with.

James and I were talking about that, that there are people in my own congregation and at my job whose views are diametrically opposed to mine, and yet we can respect each other. We both - and often they more than I - can live with "seeing how it turns out" when there is change.

There are others, however, who are incapable of this. I think we think that that is "how it should be" because they have been in the majority for a long time. We think that it's special people who can deal with the change. What I'm saying is that I think it's an evolutionary step - perhaps physical, I hope, though, one that is related to mutability in consciousness.

It's not a condemnation of "them" or elevation of "us." As you know, a year or so back, I was posting things titled "They're Just Bad People." Now, I don't think so - just . . . ill-equipped. I feel compassion for them, at worst, pity. I want to help them away from those manipulating them by telling them there are monsters in the closet and under the bed. I see people like Cheney, Akinola, Chavez as abusers - they demonstrate too much cleverness and urbanity to simply be incapable of comprehending what they're peddling. Them I leave to others. I can't help or comprehend them - those are the agents of entropy I find so baffling.

kim nail said...

there is a great video feature two of my fave brothers ..the vlogbrothers ...in which john compares the situation to the pig at a state fair who is too large to stand on his own...:)
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7Z_RVl-ph3s

Erika Baker said...

I've always been fascinated by how democracy works. If you analyse historical political trends, there appear to be genuine intellectual trends, attempts at structuring society according to persuasive principles which are later abandoned when it becomes clear that those principles cannot be implemented in practice.... there's a sense of real development.

And yet, underneath it all, there is always this unintelligent, belligerent "I'm right'ism" that doesn't even understand the arguments and is purely gut-based.

And I wonder whether, in the long run, there aren't as many idiots and hate mongers on both sides so they cancel each other out, statistically.

So that at the end of each election or other political process, you can yet again discern a rational trend, cause and effect, reason.

That's not to say that compassion always wins, but it is to suggest that, maybe, the actual results of our politics are not as random and emotive as we experience them in the heat of the debate.

If that's the case, then we need not fear the "evoltionary impaired", if that's what they are, as much as you seem to suggest.