Well-meaning people keep asking for a "new way forward" in Christianity, and then speak of covenants and some pseudo-mystical sense of unity, which is not at all mystical but political.
These are not new, but have been shown to fail time and again.
Why not try something we never truly have - the Via Media. Any serious Buddhist practitioner will tell you, the Middle Way is a profoundly absorbing and demanding practice, taking a lifetime of work.
We have not done that. What we've done is a sort of hacking down the middle, sifting to find the lowest common denominator, and attempting to settle into a narcotic parochialism that is easily ignorable and serves no one - the most revealing statement I've heard was from a well-educated, thoughtful cleric who argued that Rowan Williams must be doing the right thing because he was upsetting everyone and refusing to "lower himself" to explanations! That is baffling to me. If no one is served by the current practice, it is a bad practice. If no one will explain the position, it is a bad position. The idea that a church should "run along, tickety-boo" is a rather odd one. It's not a corporation, still less a machine. It is more than company, more than family. It's purpose - to my mind, it's clearly stated purpose - is to work to bring the Kingdom of God to Earth. That's work, and messy work.
The enemy of faith is not disbelief, but the laziness of the believers! There are atheists doing far more at this juncture to actuate the teachings of Jesus than entire sections of Christendom. The bad news for us is that, if we take this seriously, if we truly believe in Christ's mission, we have to live in a constant tension unlike any other "occupation" or mere vocation in human history. We have to step carefully, balancing reality and revelation at every point. We have to accept that we are imperfect and our judgment may be wrong. There is no - repeat NO - simple book of rules.
The news gets worse. There's no simple answer to the whole shootin' match. By that, I mean that we have to accept that there will be people who embrace the extremes - the extreme of church as social-service/social-action center with no reference to anything beyond physical form and need, and those who embrace the church solely as ark, floating in a chaotic sea that is this life until God does it all and makes a new world. They exist, and, given that we're speaking eternal truths, we can't really find a convincing argument against, just as we are unswayed by their arguments. For example, my thought tends to come in intuitive leaps, from which I have to reason back to explain. If I'm honest, then when countered with the suggestion that I reasoned the way I did from a pre-conceived prejudice, then I have to assent that is a possibility. Of course, so did the person making that counter to my argument. Again, there is really no such thing as pure objectivity for a human being. It's impossible. So, part of the difficulty of the Via Media is working with the messiness of allowing that those who I believe may be wrong believe that I am definitely wrong and must be stopped, and yet must allow them their space to believe - we're not speaking of action at this point, but belief.
Even worse news; I can go out far on a limb and say that, given the nature of eternal verities, I can make no real counter to other faiths! That is why my faith is my faith, and why true faith is messy because it accepts its completely subjective nature. The good part of that is that it allows me to see good and commonality in other faiths, even those whose structures teach that my faith is absolutely wrong, or faiths which my ecclesial structure teaches as absolutely wrong. Still, I have to admit that people who were very unhappy and far from God in Christianity, have found peace and compassion in Islam, Buddhism, Judaism, etc. Who am I to argue with results, even as I make room for those who would argue with results, even condemn them as diabolism?
No comments:
Post a Comment