My interest in Buddhism, exposure to the thinking of Tolle, Thich Nhat Hanh, Thomas Merton, and many others, my fascination with Oriental - particularly Japanese - culture and this article by Maria Reis Habito have led me back to a fundamental spiritual dissonance as a Christian looking from a 21st Century perspective into the deeper aspects of a contemplative spirituality.
The dissonance, or conflict, is expressed in Habito's article largely as a difference of East and West, and, in representative terms, this is accurate. But I see it as a fundamental tension in all cultures, it is simply that one is less likely to question the pre-eminence of one side or the other depending on one's cultural milieu. This leads to a repression of one or the other that is usually expressed in extreme, or unhealthy ways; in America, the need for collectivism leads to the herd mentality so skillfully misused by conservative pundits, in Japan, the need for individuality leads to the often (to us) bizarre fashion trends (side note: the same bizarre fashion trends in America are most often an effort to fit in!), to Yokohama biker gangs, and to suicide.
Like Buddha - and I feel Jesus, as well, had He been expressing Himself in a different set of cultural needs - I believe the healthy way is the middle way. Too much individuality, and all becomes completely rootless and relative; too much collectivism, the wonder and goodness of the individual that made the entire spiritual side relevant or meaningful is lost. The key, I think, has to be a healthy responsibility - a mutual responsibility. What I mean is this: a healthy individual must express himself with respect for the vast network of societal demands that give him identity, while the society must have respect for the sacredness of the individual characters that form that web.
Thoughts?
No comments:
Post a Comment