Monday, September 28, 2009

The Two Faiths

The current arguments in Christianity seem to be hinging on who has faith and who doesn't - often expressed as an argument of faith vs. reason, or faith vs. superstition, or various other pejorative arguments.

I've made no secret of the fact that I believe the orthodite/fundamentalist/orthodox/reasserter group to be poorly-developed apes who would be much happier if put back in the wild without the burdens of civilized interaction. My only reservation on that point is that the great apes are often fairly gentle and sociable creatures who don't deserve that bomb dropped on them. This is my personal view, and I can't help it, especially given that it has been borne out at every turn. My less personal and more generally-applied concept of evolutionary thought and consciousness and the relatively static nature of the ability to expand thought has also received no substantial rebuttal.

So, full disclosure on my prejudice against one side of this ongoing debate. I label it prejudice because I wish to err on the side of generosity, and, thought not disproved, has not been conclusively proven either.

Unfortunately, a lack of rationality and real reflection is just as much a part of the so-called revisionist side. The dumbing-down of liturgy in the proposed Prayer Book revisions is a sign of this. The tendency to get bogged down in precious points of courtesy, or, worse, to undermine allies' arguments for the sheer joy of scoring a point - "Hur, hur . . . look how smart I am!" are definite traits in the liberal camp. The inability to distinguish between humor and insult, the inability to make fine judgments and a tendency toward the draconian, an inability to recognize the interdependence of individual and structure in a healthy way, etc. To some extent we are all guilty of it, but a great majority are almost always guilty of it, some of them people I respect and support in many ways.

So, given that there is as much responsibility on each side as there is culpability (and this is a personal stretch for me in positing this - I cannot trust the orthodites), I don't think it's anything as wildly conflicting as "faith vs. . . . " It's not an either/or proposition. Both sides are faith, and find their fatal flaws in the extremity of each: on one side, the faith that cold, scientific observation can save everything and bring The Kingdom, on the other side, the faith that one must wait for God to bring the Kingdom, accepting any "revealed truth" regardless of it's seeming irrelevance or inapplicability. BOTH are faiths. Both faiths reside in the action of God that promises a full restoration. Both lead, if unbalanced and placed in opposition, to fundamental and damaging errors - in regarding the two as absolute, indeed, the faith becomes absolutely based on error.

On the one hand, the error is the idea that any human, or group of humans, can make a truly objective judgment. It is simply impossible. Even if taking an observable event or the behavior of an observable object, the physical, mental, emotional aggregate that is the human experience invariably "taints the findings." The result is, frequently, evidenced as a tendency to the absolute primacy of the individual - whether friend or foe.

On the other hand, the error is the abdication of all responsibility and action to an unseen power in the belief that this somehow washes ones hands of any possible wrongdoing, regardless of the God-given powers of rational thought and the workings of conscience. It is often claimed to be rational as it was rationally-assented to, by which the assenter means he chose such a view. This, itself, shows the fundamental problem in that we all would, if it cost no real effort or sacrifice on our part, choose absolute certainty and a childish abrogation of responsibility. There was choice, but the same "choice" as is made between another hour of productive work or another slice of cheesecake. It's the "choice" of the Lotus Eater, frankly. The result, frequently, is evidenced as a tendency to submerge the individual into the group, giving up all responsibility or self-improvement.

No comments: