From Austin, TX, hotbed of liberal journalism.
and
From CNN, socialist/communist mouthpiece of the nation.
As regards the ongoing battles in the AC, which are as pointless and unnecessary as always, comes a bit of sanity from Frank Turner:
The Imagined Community of the Anglican Communion.
Note, it always seems to be clergy, in particular bishops, banging the "importance-of-the-Anglican-Communion" drum - maybe it's time to do what just about no other national church can do and clip the hell out of our bishops' wings. It's clear this is about personal interest, and bishops are just as susceptible to lobbying and toadyism as any other politician - take away that ability, and see how important they thing the AC really is.
On a more personal note:
I've realized, thanks to the contributions of a priest I've believed dedicated and rational and the actions of our clergy - particularly bishops - that, all this time, I've been fighting for a church that doesn't want to change, wants all its privileges and no risk and is, far from being a refuge for those who look for rationality and flexibility in religion, merely a refuge for the remainder of the Love Generation and the tail-end of yuppie "sensitivity" who'll scream from the rooftops for justice and love and righteousness for someone half a world away, a different color or different belief, and simply ignore the suffering of their neighbors, step over the bodies of those like them without so much as a backward glance. A friend of mine, James in fact - far from a conservative - has said to me, "Liberals are assholes." I've begun to think he's right.
You see, on a level, the orthodites are right: the Episcopal Church doesn't believe in what it's fighting for, or we would've thrown this Covenant back in Williams' face and told him, in so many words, to keep his hairy ass in his own church. We would've actually sent people - not money - in to help in Nigeria and Uganda, and without the damned politicking to make sure we don't step on purple toes. We would've said, loudly and clearly, that Akinola is a combination of voodoo witch-doctor and tribal war-chief and nothing like a bishop, without biting nails over the reaction of Canterbury.
The Episcopal Church does not believe in anything it's doing, and it's not just the bishops - as awful as they are.
Our clergy and lay-people will throw money and words to anything for justice - as long as it's fashionable and costs nothing more than that. As long as it doesn't hurt our PR. As long as we can be the "good guys," the "nice guys." You know, for all their wickedness, it doesn't shock me to hear from the Roman Catholics, or Baptists that one of theirs was killed or captured working in a dangerous area, for making the wrong noises before a dictator, but it would be a shock, an impossibility that you'd ever hear that of an Episcopalian. Episcopalians don't actually believe in anything, but what's fashionable and easy.
The refuge of the Love Generation and the remnants of socially-conscious yuppies.
And, it's just about put a stake through the heart of my belief in any damned thing, anymore. I've got more damned stress than most could handle just being me - our company cutting employees, hours, pay, clinical depression, health and housing problems - and, on top of that, to realize that Christianity is divided into those who believe and fight for wickedness and destruction, and those who believe in nothing costly at all and invest themselves in nothing at all. What God relies on that for His work? What good is that God? Could such a God exist, or, if He does, why should I worry whether someone so ineffectual disapproves of my actions?
These questions - particularly of the actual existence of God - are not ones I'm used to asking. I know God exists, because I feel Him, just like I can feel the presence of other people in my town without seeing them. So, I'm going to stay at St. Pat's, in the choir if they want, and keep on until this Covenant is voted in by GC, which it will be, and we no longer are even the weak-as-water Episcopalians we were, but some unrecognizable mini-Rome. Then, I'll leave, and see whether or not I still feel God at all. In the meantime, I can't keep fighting and involving myself in a church that, vampire-like, feeds off my energy and gives nothing back.
It's all up to you, if you feel the fight's worth it. I got no more investment. I can't, if I want to survive.
ADDENDUM:
Doxy rightly called me on my use of "Episcopalians" - particularly this quote:
Episcopalians don't actually believe in anything, but what's fashionable and easy.
This is not the right use of words - there are a strong, struggling minority of members in the Episcopal Church who work very hard and risk for what they believe.
Rather, it has become what TEC represents - it's what TEC, in its public face, IS. Now, you can take issue with that all you want. I won't argue anymore, I'm just dead inside. But, ask yourself, ask others, if it's not so. For that matter, ask others how much they actually know about us compared to RC's or Evangelicals. We aren't polite or restrained, just milquetoast and vacillating - that's the public reality.
And, now, something completely unrelated, because I give up and silly and cute is better than all the noise:
5 comments:
Episcopalians don't actually believe in anything, but what's fashionable and easy.
Thanks a lot, Mark.
One time I was attempting to do a paper on the Episcopal Church and the issue of homosexuals serving as clergy. In all of Atlanta, I could not find one clergy member who would say what they or the Episcopal Church believed, or would even have a discussion about the issue. All they gave was non-committal political answers that said nothing. None even attempted to engage me in discussion of the Bible and the views it could express concerning homosexuality so that I could come up with an answer. It was frustrating, because it is hard to write a paper about nothing. So I asked if the church had a statement of beliefs. To that end, every clergy member said, "the Ten Commandments". Now, I may be a little fuzzy on my Bible at times, but as far as I and the Internet know, it makes no mention of homosexuality. If the Ten Commandments are the only steadfast statement of beliefs in the Episcopal faith, as ALL, and I do mean ALL, of the clergy in Atlanta led me to believe, then homosexual clergy members should be a non-issue.
Mind you, I am not saying that the Ten Commandments are the only place where the beliefs are found, but that this was what was expressed to me by the clergy. Most said when I asked them about an article or statement of the beliefs of the church, a number of them said, and I quote, "The Ten Commandments. Everything else is between you and God." And yes, that was the exact quote of several clergy members verbatim.
I think this is something that truly demonstrates the lack of a spine in the modern church. People look to the church for moral guidance and to be a light in the wilderness. I know I may put a number of people off when I say this, but I do not think that "I don't know" is an acceptable answer when someone asks whether something is right or wrong. True, right and wrong can be argued, but saying nothing is worse. Doing that is letting down the people who come to you for guidance. If you don't want to give an answer and it is your job as a servant of the people to guide them, then at least you should be willing to discuss the issue and help the person find an answer.
But I guess I shouldn't be surprised by a church that is proud that it refused to take a stand during the American Civil War on the issue of slavery, preventing a split. It must feel good to the church to pat itself on the back and say, "Hooray! We did nothing!"
Doxy,
I'm tired, and I'm not going to justify myself, so I'll just apologize. I wrote in anger and I was imprecise in my language; of course there are those who believe, struggle and sacrifice. They are very few, comparatively, and I've been privileged to know many of those, including you, Mimi, Mark Harris, Terry Martin, Susan, etc.
If this destroys our friendship, that I feel this is what the representative function of TEC has become, then I can only say from my side that I will never stop being your friend.
Understand, this wasn't a parting shot to the rest of TEC - I'm hanging in there - I just wanted to give one last wake-up call. I don't have much more time to do it. I'm dying from all this and have to leave it behind. A seldom-read blog will become a wasteland of silly pop psychology and pop culture, and I will have contributed less than the nothing I already have, so I had to give one last cry. Unfortunately, as I feared, it's only the already-committed who'll get angry enough to "show me."
Again, I'm sorry Doxy.
Mark--I don't give up on friendships because I get pissed off. If I did, I wouldn't have any friends left! ;-)
You and I struggle with the same issue, I think---we keep asking, "How, in the name of God, can people who CLAIM to be Christian refuse to do what is right?!?!?" (Or worse, actively participate in doing what we KNOW to be wrong.)
I get so angry and disgusted sometimes because it seems to me that people are willfully blind--or just plain cowardly and/or selfish. And that happens in many areas of my life--GLBT issues, healthcare reform, etc.
Many days, I want to kick in the doors and do a serious beat-down on people, all in the name of justice.
But my beloved Dear Friend has begun to have an influence on me. He is an ISFJ to my ENFP. He is a consensus-builder. He feels every bit as strongly as I do about the ultimate goal and the rightness of it, but, in his ministry, he has found that "When you win an argument, you lose."
He does not tell people what to think. J. Klempf would probably have found Dear Friend a disappointment had he interviewed him. And that's not because Dear Friend doesn't know what HE believes, but because he thinks it is clerical abuse to tell people what to think.
I know of desperate women who were told by clergy to stay with their abusive husbands because "divorce is a sin." I know of women who made the mistake of confessing they had an abortion to a clergy member. They got a lecture on "right and wrong" all right...some of them never set foot in a church again.
Since you and I have both been on the receiving end of being ordered to believe X, Y, and Z, I hope you can understand why some clergy--like my beloved--resist the temptation. I'm sure that some clergy DON'T believe much, or are cowards---but others are simply trying not to become demigods to their parishioners.
As much as I hate to admit it, clergy and bishops have different burdens than you and I do. (And even I have begun to feel the "burden" of being a clergy wife...) They DO have an obligation to try and keep everyone at the table. Whether that's ultimately possible is beside the point. They are shepherds to ALL the flock--saints and sinners, liberals and conservatives, gay and straight.
I could never be a priest because I would not be a good shepherd. I see how hard it is for Dear Friend--who is a good, loving man who feels his calling very deeply. He would perform a same-sex marriage tomorrow if he could--even though he knows he would lose church members for doing it. He's not a coward--while he's waiting for the wheels of change to turn in the diocese, he's doing classes on Faith and Homosexuality. He frequently mentions from the pulpit his joy over TEC's recent move toward full equality. He's the one who suggested putting our statement about our support for same-sex marriage and full inclusion in our wedding bulletin. He coauthored the resolution that passed at diocesan convention two years ago that stated our support for GLBTs, both clergy and lay.
But would he get up and tell people, "You are being unChristian by refusing to accept GLBTs in the church or by opposing same-sex marriage"? No--he wouldn't. Because, as he says "There is no 'Christian opinion' on ANYTHING. There are Christians who have opinions." He has learned that people change, if they do, mostly by interacting with people they love and trust. He is loved and trusted--and I have seen people change their minds (or at least become more willing to listen) because of that.
To J.K.'s point about the clergy's responsibility to engage in dialogue with people to help them find answers to their questions and problems, I agree--and so would Dear Friend.
Pax,
Doxy
Doxy,
First, a correction - it's Kempf, not Klempf. J Kempf is the James I often speak of, my best friend IRL. He is far more outspoken than I.
I think what he and I are both disappointed in is that there is a difference between telling people what to think and taking up the responsibility of leadership. Part of that responsibility - especially in the clergy - is that of prophetic leadership, including saying, "This is right, and this is wrong."
In the end, though, I just can't do all this anymore.
Post a Comment