Well-meaning people keep asking for a "new way forward" in Christianity, and then speak of covenants and some pseudo-mystical sense of unity, which is not at all mystical but political.
These are not new, but have been shown to fail time and again.
Why not try something we never truly have - the Via Media. Any serious Buddhist practitioner will tell you, the Middle Way is a profoundly absorbing and demanding practice, taking a lifetime of work.
We have not done that. What we've done is a sort of hacking down the middle, sifting to find the lowest common denominator, and attempting to settle into a narcotic parochialism that is easily ignorable and serves no one - the most revealing statement I've heard was from a well-educated, thoughtful cleric who argued that Rowan Williams must be doing the right thing because he was upsetting everyone and refusing to "lower himself" to explanations! That is baffling to me. If no one is served by the current practice, it is a bad practice. If no one will explain the position, it is a bad position. The idea that a church should "run along, tickety-boo" is a rather odd one. It's not a corporation, still less a machine. It is more than company, more than family. It's purpose - to my mind, it's clearly stated purpose - is to work to bring the Kingdom of God to Earth. That's work, and messy work.
The enemy of faith is not disbelief, but the laziness of the believers! There are atheists doing far more at this juncture to actuate the teachings of Jesus than entire sections of Christendom. The bad news for us is that, if we take this seriously, if we truly believe in Christ's mission, we have to live in a constant tension unlike any other "occupation" or mere vocation in human history. We have to step carefully, balancing reality and revelation at every point. We have to accept that we are imperfect and our judgment may be wrong. There is no - repeat NO - simple book of rules.
The news gets worse. There's no simple answer to the whole shootin' match. By that, I mean that we have to accept that there will be people who embrace the extremes - the extreme of church as social-service/social-action center with no reference to anything beyond physical form and need, and those who embrace the church solely as ark, floating in a chaotic sea that is this life until God does it all and makes a new world. They exist, and, given that we're speaking eternal truths, we can't really find a convincing argument against, just as we are unswayed by their arguments. For example, my thought tends to come in intuitive leaps, from which I have to reason back to explain. If I'm honest, then when countered with the suggestion that I reasoned the way I did from a pre-conceived prejudice, then I have to assent that is a possibility. Of course, so did the person making that counter to my argument. Again, there is really no such thing as pure objectivity for a human being. It's impossible. So, part of the difficulty of the Via Media is working with the messiness of allowing that those who I believe may be wrong believe that I am definitely wrong and must be stopped, and yet must allow them their space to believe - we're not speaking of action at this point, but belief.
Even worse news; I can go out far on a limb and say that, given the nature of eternal verities, I can make no real counter to other faiths! That is why my faith is my faith, and why true faith is messy because it accepts its completely subjective nature. The good part of that is that it allows me to see good and commonality in other faiths, even those whose structures teach that my faith is absolutely wrong, or faiths which my ecclesial structure teaches as absolutely wrong. Still, I have to admit that people who were very unhappy and far from God in Christianity, have found peace and compassion in Islam, Buddhism, Judaism, etc. Who am I to argue with results, even as I make room for those who would argue with results, even condemn them as diabolism?
Tuesday, September 29, 2009
Monday, September 28, 2009
The Two Faiths
The current arguments in Christianity seem to be hinging on who has faith and who doesn't - often expressed as an argument of faith vs. reason, or faith vs. superstition, or various other pejorative arguments.
I've made no secret of the fact that I believe the orthodite/fundamentalist/orthodox/reasserter group to be poorly-developed apes who would be much happier if put back in the wild without the burdens of civilized interaction. My only reservation on that point is that the great apes are often fairly gentle and sociable creatures who don't deserve that bomb dropped on them. This is my personal view, and I can't help it, especially given that it has been borne out at every turn. My less personal and more generally-applied concept of evolutionary thought and consciousness and the relatively static nature of the ability to expand thought has also received no substantial rebuttal.
So, full disclosure on my prejudice against one side of this ongoing debate. I label it prejudice because I wish to err on the side of generosity, and, thought not disproved, has not been conclusively proven either.
Unfortunately, a lack of rationality and real reflection is just as much a part of the so-called revisionist side. The dumbing-down of liturgy in the proposed Prayer Book revisions is a sign of this. The tendency to get bogged down in precious points of courtesy, or, worse, to undermine allies' arguments for the sheer joy of scoring a point - "Hur, hur . . . look how smart I am!" are definite traits in the liberal camp. The inability to distinguish between humor and insult, the inability to make fine judgments and a tendency toward the draconian, an inability to recognize the interdependence of individual and structure in a healthy way, etc. To some extent we are all guilty of it, but a great majority are almost always guilty of it, some of them people I respect and support in many ways.
So, given that there is as much responsibility on each side as there is culpability (and this is a personal stretch for me in positing this - I cannot trust the orthodites), I don't think it's anything as wildly conflicting as "faith vs. . . . " It's not an either/or proposition. Both sides are faith, and find their fatal flaws in the extremity of each: on one side, the faith that cold, scientific observation can save everything and bring The Kingdom, on the other side, the faith that one must wait for God to bring the Kingdom, accepting any "revealed truth" regardless of it's seeming irrelevance or inapplicability. BOTH are faiths. Both faiths reside in the action of God that promises a full restoration. Both lead, if unbalanced and placed in opposition, to fundamental and damaging errors - in regarding the two as absolute, indeed, the faith becomes absolutely based on error.
On the one hand, the error is the idea that any human, or group of humans, can make a truly objective judgment. It is simply impossible. Even if taking an observable event or the behavior of an observable object, the physical, mental, emotional aggregate that is the human experience invariably "taints the findings." The result is, frequently, evidenced as a tendency to the absolute primacy of the individual - whether friend or foe.
On the other hand, the error is the abdication of all responsibility and action to an unseen power in the belief that this somehow washes ones hands of any possible wrongdoing, regardless of the God-given powers of rational thought and the workings of conscience. It is often claimed to be rational as it was rationally-assented to, by which the assenter means he chose such a view. This, itself, shows the fundamental problem in that we all would, if it cost no real effort or sacrifice on our part, choose absolute certainty and a childish abrogation of responsibility. There was choice, but the same "choice" as is made between another hour of productive work or another slice of cheesecake. It's the "choice" of the Lotus Eater, frankly. The result, frequently, is evidenced as a tendency to submerge the individual into the group, giving up all responsibility or self-improvement.
I've made no secret of the fact that I believe the orthodite/fundamentalist/orthodox/reasserter group to be poorly-developed apes who would be much happier if put back in the wild without the burdens of civilized interaction. My only reservation on that point is that the great apes are often fairly gentle and sociable creatures who don't deserve that bomb dropped on them. This is my personal view, and I can't help it, especially given that it has been borne out at every turn. My less personal and more generally-applied concept of evolutionary thought and consciousness and the relatively static nature of the ability to expand thought has also received no substantial rebuttal.
So, full disclosure on my prejudice against one side of this ongoing debate. I label it prejudice because I wish to err on the side of generosity, and, thought not disproved, has not been conclusively proven either.
Unfortunately, a lack of rationality and real reflection is just as much a part of the so-called revisionist side. The dumbing-down of liturgy in the proposed Prayer Book revisions is a sign of this. The tendency to get bogged down in precious points of courtesy, or, worse, to undermine allies' arguments for the sheer joy of scoring a point - "Hur, hur . . . look how smart I am!" are definite traits in the liberal camp. The inability to distinguish between humor and insult, the inability to make fine judgments and a tendency toward the draconian, an inability to recognize the interdependence of individual and structure in a healthy way, etc. To some extent we are all guilty of it, but a great majority are almost always guilty of it, some of them people I respect and support in many ways.
So, given that there is as much responsibility on each side as there is culpability (and this is a personal stretch for me in positing this - I cannot trust the orthodites), I don't think it's anything as wildly conflicting as "faith vs. . . . " It's not an either/or proposition. Both sides are faith, and find their fatal flaws in the extremity of each: on one side, the faith that cold, scientific observation can save everything and bring The Kingdom, on the other side, the faith that one must wait for God to bring the Kingdom, accepting any "revealed truth" regardless of it's seeming irrelevance or inapplicability. BOTH are faiths. Both faiths reside in the action of God that promises a full restoration. Both lead, if unbalanced and placed in opposition, to fundamental and damaging errors - in regarding the two as absolute, indeed, the faith becomes absolutely based on error.
On the one hand, the error is the idea that any human, or group of humans, can make a truly objective judgment. It is simply impossible. Even if taking an observable event or the behavior of an observable object, the physical, mental, emotional aggregate that is the human experience invariably "taints the findings." The result is, frequently, evidenced as a tendency to the absolute primacy of the individual - whether friend or foe.
On the other hand, the error is the abdication of all responsibility and action to an unseen power in the belief that this somehow washes ones hands of any possible wrongdoing, regardless of the God-given powers of rational thought and the workings of conscience. It is often claimed to be rational as it was rationally-assented to, by which the assenter means he chose such a view. This, itself, shows the fundamental problem in that we all would, if it cost no real effort or sacrifice on our part, choose absolute certainty and a childish abrogation of responsibility. There was choice, but the same "choice" as is made between another hour of productive work or another slice of cheesecake. It's the "choice" of the Lotus Eater, frankly. The result, frequently, is evidenced as a tendency to submerge the individual into the group, giving up all responsibility or self-improvement.
Thursday, September 24, 2009
What Do You People Want?!
Look, Orthodites -
You've managed to kill my hope, my faith in humanity, the church and, largely, in a personal god. I think you've pretty much done all the evil you were sent to do to me.
What more do you want? My blood? My life? You ain't gettin' it. I'm stronger than you. I'll outlast you. You are not worth anybody's tears.
I care about the individuals at my church, in my family, and in my circle of friends - that's the Body of Christ - you can have your petty empire of "church."
You've managed to kill my hope, my faith in humanity, the church and, largely, in a personal god. I think you've pretty much done all the evil you were sent to do to me.
What more do you want? My blood? My life? You ain't gettin' it. I'm stronger than you. I'll outlast you. You are not worth anybody's tears.
I care about the individuals at my church, in my family, and in my circle of friends - that's the Body of Christ - you can have your petty empire of "church."
Wednesday, September 23, 2009
9/23/09
I'm just so damned angry all the time.
I keep being told - oh, so kindly - that this is wrong. You shouldn't be angry. Get over it.
I began reading Thich Nhat Hanh's Anger: the advice there is "listen deeply."
Well, that's just great, but I have listened deeply.
There's a madman standing there, with his hand poised to push the button that will set off a bomb. I've listened to everything he has to say, I've spoken gently to him to reassure him that there is no government conspiracy/alien transmission/monsters in his skull/etc., and he's still going to push the button. So, what now? I have a duty to stop him, but all I can hear is everyone telling me, "No! Be kind! You gotta listen to him! Respect his crazy!!!!"
At some point, even for liberals, we have to realize that compromise and tolerance are simply a way of avoiding responsibility. There's no compassion in letting him push the button. The survivors, if any, are maimed forever. If you survive, if he survives, you're maimed, he's maimed, you both are left with the guilt and shame of what you did . . . or, in your case, didn't do. If you let him push the button, you will have the faces of the dead and the wounded in your nightmares, and you should - if you don't, there was neither compassion or generosity in your involvement to begin with.
Why are you afraid of calling insane insane? Why are you afraid of saying "We're right and you're wrong, and we just have to accept what reality is?"
I keep being told - oh, so kindly - that this is wrong. You shouldn't be angry. Get over it.
I began reading Thich Nhat Hanh's Anger: the advice there is "listen deeply."
Well, that's just great, but I have listened deeply.
There's a madman standing there, with his hand poised to push the button that will set off a bomb. I've listened to everything he has to say, I've spoken gently to him to reassure him that there is no government conspiracy/alien transmission/monsters in his skull/etc., and he's still going to push the button. So, what now? I have a duty to stop him, but all I can hear is everyone telling me, "No! Be kind! You gotta listen to him! Respect his crazy!!!!"
At some point, even for liberals, we have to realize that compromise and tolerance are simply a way of avoiding responsibility. There's no compassion in letting him push the button. The survivors, if any, are maimed forever. If you survive, if he survives, you're maimed, he's maimed, you both are left with the guilt and shame of what you did . . . or, in your case, didn't do. If you let him push the button, you will have the faces of the dead and the wounded in your nightmares, and you should - if you don't, there was neither compassion or generosity in your involvement to begin with.
Why are you afraid of calling insane insane? Why are you afraid of saying "We're right and you're wrong, and we just have to accept what reality is?"
Tuesday, September 22, 2009
Ex Nihilo . . . Nihilo.
I've spent a great deal of my life lying to myself about my worth and my ability. I'm really not intelligent, or insightful - save for an uncontrollable burst of realization about things that everybody already really knows. It's distressing to realize that, when I die, I will have changed nothing, meant nothing, and my death will mean nothing. Dust we art, and to dust we will return.
Even something simple, like Marcus Aurelius' instruction:
Say to yourself in the early morning: I shall meet today inquisitive, ungrateful, violent, treacherous, envious, uncharitable men. All these things have come upon them through ignorance of real good and ill.
I know the truth of it, yet am incapable of acting on it. I'm not even sure how. Compassion is the ideal, I'm sure of that. At the same time, I see no way to simply allow these "ignorant men" to continue on their path and in their actions. We have to be responsible for stopping them, especially in this time when even the most abysmal fool can cause global damage. It must be stopped. And yet, time and again, I'm told I'm wrong. It's intolerant. We have to be patient. But I can't accept this. Compassion demands action. I'm an unloving, unloveable person, so, maybe my whole purpose in this is to be the unpleasant voice of necessity, forgotten as soon as buried.
There is nothing but confusion to come out of all this, and, perhaps, the whole "point" is the final joke - a planet, peaceful, harmonious, now that the angry little apes are all dead. Maybe we were never the point. Love. Compassion. All these I believe in, and they've failed, failed, failed. The little "victories" can never stand in the face of the vast entropic chaos that whirls in and around us, the blind, idiot god, and there are two possibilities I see - we don't matter, or there is no god to matter to. I believe, still, in the Omega Point evolution - but I can no longer see its effectiveness when even those who've advanced resist it and rely on the old ways.
I'll die, leaving nothing. The grinder just keeps grinding.
Even something simple, like Marcus Aurelius' instruction:
Say to yourself in the early morning: I shall meet today inquisitive, ungrateful, violent, treacherous, envious, uncharitable men. All these things have come upon them through ignorance of real good and ill.
I know the truth of it, yet am incapable of acting on it. I'm not even sure how. Compassion is the ideal, I'm sure of that. At the same time, I see no way to simply allow these "ignorant men" to continue on their path and in their actions. We have to be responsible for stopping them, especially in this time when even the most abysmal fool can cause global damage. It must be stopped. And yet, time and again, I'm told I'm wrong. It's intolerant. We have to be patient. But I can't accept this. Compassion demands action. I'm an unloving, unloveable person, so, maybe my whole purpose in this is to be the unpleasant voice of necessity, forgotten as soon as buried.
There is nothing but confusion to come out of all this, and, perhaps, the whole "point" is the final joke - a planet, peaceful, harmonious, now that the angry little apes are all dead. Maybe we were never the point. Love. Compassion. All these I believe in, and they've failed, failed, failed. The little "victories" can never stand in the face of the vast entropic chaos that whirls in and around us, the blind, idiot god, and there are two possibilities I see - we don't matter, or there is no god to matter to. I believe, still, in the Omega Point evolution - but I can no longer see its effectiveness when even those who've advanced resist it and rely on the old ways.
I'll die, leaving nothing. The grinder just keeps grinding.
Thursday, September 17, 2009
East and West
My interest in Buddhism, exposure to the thinking of Tolle, Thich Nhat Hanh, Thomas Merton, and many others, my fascination with Oriental - particularly Japanese - culture and this article by Maria Reis Habito have led me back to a fundamental spiritual dissonance as a Christian looking from a 21st Century perspective into the deeper aspects of a contemplative spirituality.
The dissonance, or conflict, is expressed in Habito's article largely as a difference of East and West, and, in representative terms, this is accurate. But I see it as a fundamental tension in all cultures, it is simply that one is less likely to question the pre-eminence of one side or the other depending on one's cultural milieu. This leads to a repression of one or the other that is usually expressed in extreme, or unhealthy ways; in America, the need for collectivism leads to the herd mentality so skillfully misused by conservative pundits, in Japan, the need for individuality leads to the often (to us) bizarre fashion trends (side note: the same bizarre fashion trends in America are most often an effort to fit in!), to Yokohama biker gangs, and to suicide.
Like Buddha - and I feel Jesus, as well, had He been expressing Himself in a different set of cultural needs - I believe the healthy way is the middle way. Too much individuality, and all becomes completely rootless and relative; too much collectivism, the wonder and goodness of the individual that made the entire spiritual side relevant or meaningful is lost. The key, I think, has to be a healthy responsibility - a mutual responsibility. What I mean is this: a healthy individual must express himself with respect for the vast network of societal demands that give him identity, while the society must have respect for the sacredness of the individual characters that form that web.
Thoughts?
The dissonance, or conflict, is expressed in Habito's article largely as a difference of East and West, and, in representative terms, this is accurate. But I see it as a fundamental tension in all cultures, it is simply that one is less likely to question the pre-eminence of one side or the other depending on one's cultural milieu. This leads to a repression of one or the other that is usually expressed in extreme, or unhealthy ways; in America, the need for collectivism leads to the herd mentality so skillfully misused by conservative pundits, in Japan, the need for individuality leads to the often (to us) bizarre fashion trends (side note: the same bizarre fashion trends in America are most often an effort to fit in!), to Yokohama biker gangs, and to suicide.
Like Buddha - and I feel Jesus, as well, had He been expressing Himself in a different set of cultural needs - I believe the healthy way is the middle way. Too much individuality, and all becomes completely rootless and relative; too much collectivism, the wonder and goodness of the individual that made the entire spiritual side relevant or meaningful is lost. The key, I think, has to be a healthy responsibility - a mutual responsibility. What I mean is this: a healthy individual must express himself with respect for the vast network of societal demands that give him identity, while the society must have respect for the sacredness of the individual characters that form that web.
Thoughts?
Wednesday, September 16, 2009
WANTED





For:
Crimes Against Humanity
Incitement to murder
Incitement to riot
Attempted Subversion of the Goverment
Treason
Fraud
Domestic (psychological) Terrorism
For God alone my soul in silence waits; *
from him comes my salvation.
He alone is my rock and my salvation, *
my stronghold, so that I shall not be greatly shaken.
How long will you assail me to crush me,
all of you together, *
as if you were a leaning fence, a toppling wall?
They seek only to bring me down from my place of honor; *
lies are their chief delight.
They bless with their lips, *
but in their hearts they curse.
For God alone my soul in silence waits; *
truly, my hope is in him.
He alone is my rock and my salvation, *
my stronghold, so that I shall not be shaken.
In God is my safety and my honor; *
God is my strong rock and my refuge.
Put your trust in him always, O people, *
pour out your hearts before him, for God is our refuge.
Those of high degree are but a fleeting breath, *
even those of low estate cannot be trusted.
On the scales they are lighter than a breath, *
all of them together.
Put no trust in extortion;
in robbery take no empty pride; *
though wealth increase, set not your heart upon it.
God has spoken once, twice have I heard it, *
that power belongs to God.
Steadfast love is yours, O Lord, *
for you repay everyone according to his deeds.
from him comes my salvation.
He alone is my rock and my salvation, *
my stronghold, so that I shall not be greatly shaken.
How long will you assail me to crush me,
all of you together, *
as if you were a leaning fence, a toppling wall?
They seek only to bring me down from my place of honor; *
lies are their chief delight.
They bless with their lips, *
but in their hearts they curse.
For God alone my soul in silence waits; *
truly, my hope is in him.
He alone is my rock and my salvation, *
my stronghold, so that I shall not be shaken.
In God is my safety and my honor; *
God is my strong rock and my refuge.
Put your trust in him always, O people, *
pour out your hearts before him, for God is our refuge.
Those of high degree are but a fleeting breath, *
even those of low estate cannot be trusted.
On the scales they are lighter than a breath, *
all of them together.
Put no trust in extortion;
in robbery take no empty pride; *
though wealth increase, set not your heart upon it.
God has spoken once, twice have I heard it, *
that power belongs to God.
Steadfast love is yours, O Lord, *
for you repay everyone according to his deeds.
*******************
Hear my voice, O God, when I complain; *
protect my life from fear of the enemy.
Hide me from the conspiracy of the wicked, *
from the mob of evildoers.
They sharpen their tongue like a sword, *
and aim their bitter words like arrows,
That they may shoot down the blameless from ambush; *
they shoot without warning and are not afraid.
They hold fast to their evil course; *
they plan how they may hide their snares.
They say, "Who will see us?
who will find out our crimes? *
we have thought out a perfect plot."
The human mind and heart are a mystery; *
but God will loose an arrow at them,
and suddenly they will be wounded.
He will make them trip over their tongues, *
and all who see them will shake their heads.
Everyone will stand in awe and declare God's deeds; *
they will recognize his works.
The righteous will rejoice in the LORD and put their trust in him, *
and all who are true of heart will glory.
Hear my voice, O God, when I complain; *
protect my life from fear of the enemy.
Hide me from the conspiracy of the wicked, *
from the mob of evildoers.
They sharpen their tongue like a sword, *
and aim their bitter words like arrows,
That they may shoot down the blameless from ambush; *
they shoot without warning and are not afraid.
They hold fast to their evil course; *
they plan how they may hide their snares.
They say, "Who will see us?
who will find out our crimes? *
we have thought out a perfect plot."
The human mind and heart are a mystery; *
but God will loose an arrow at them,
and suddenly they will be wounded.
He will make them trip over their tongues, *
and all who see them will shake their heads.
Everyone will stand in awe and declare God's deeds; *
they will recognize his works.
The righteous will rejoice in the LORD and put their trust in him, *
and all who are true of heart will glory.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)