The third and fourth misconceptions are really the opposite side of the coin, one the inverse of the other.
Both come, hopefully enough, from a realization that whatever we are doing is clearly not working. The answers, though, are reactionary.
THE THIRD MISCONCEPTION
The only way we can save Christianity is by going back to the orthodoxy of the past!
This is obviously not true.
Why obvious?
If what we are doing is clearly not working, then, just as clearly, what we have done hasn't worked or we wouldn't have done something else. Don't believe me? The most conservative estimate puts Christianity - organized, institutionalized Christianity - at some 1,600 years of age. If it was working, we'd all be at Peace, or at least Christian, by now. Instead, we've had break after break, all very acrimonious and frequently bloody, rather than a wise tolerance and faith.
The past hasn't worked any better than the present, and it is both unwise and faithless to assume an end to revelation and guidance in the present age, as does our past-looking traditionalism. Indeed, the only "revelation" allowed in such a stagnant view is that which is absolutely verified by Scripture and Tradition, which is not revelation in any sense.
At the same time, ongoing revelation does not mean something "novel" or that God has "changed His mind," but that we are humble enough to realize that we - the corporate we all the way back to the original disciples and patriarchs of the OT - didn't comprehend completely.
THE FOURTH MISCONCEPTION
We have to abandon the past and create something entirely new!
While this seems, at first blush, a good idea, we can see that it's really just a repetition of the past. In fact, every schism or reformation or counter-reformation has been about "ditching the past." The result has been the same turmoil.
Humans crave entertainment and novelty. Mega-churches are able to mega-church because they offer novelty. When that wears off or is gotten with greater benefits at a lesser cost, the mega usually dies out.
Humans also crave being told what they want to hear, which is "Whatever you're doing right now, what you're comfortable with, that's just right!" Yet, we have evolved enough to have learned that such comfort is often not an indicator of growth or health. At the same time, the novelty - and yes, it is novelty - of fundamentalist puritanism makes the tragic error of overlooking actual harm and clinging to the "rule book" come hell or high water! Both are ways of finding that illusory comfort.
What is needed is work, and discernment. Which is why a truly effective church will always be a small one, because most people are going to be lured away by the easier lifestyle.
Between the two misconceptions, there lies the old thesis-antithesis-synthesis of Hegel (I think it was Hegel), but ours has to be something that is not automatic, a sort of autonomous function, but a sifting and discerning, both of past failures and successes and present demand and knowledge, enthused by an experimental, risk-allowing spirit.
Rather than thesis-antithesis-synthesis, we might think of a more active dynamic - from our perspective - of Adapt, Adopt and Improve.
Wednesday, August 5, 2009
Monday, August 3, 2009
Reflecting Upon It - II
As something of a corollary to the first,
THE SECOND MISCONCEPTION
Only one of us can possibly be right!
Again, no.
Life is expansion and contraction. To put it another way, Truth to a mind unready is as good as a lie.
There must be a place for those who cannot - simply cannot - move beyond a certain point in comfort level. The complexity of human nature gives us the many churches to accomplish this. There are places in which there is strict liturgical and dogmatic structure, a liberal dogma and complex liturgy, a free-form worship and strict dogma, etc. There are, also, areas in which dogma is strict or free, depending on the church; where there are significant differences from congregation to congregation in worship, or theology or both. Life is also complexity, diversity.
Death and stagnation - a mummified corpse - that's fairly simple and straightforward.
So, what can we do?
Though we are more doctrinaire, by nature, than the Buddhist religion, we can look to them for some example.
The most basic division, of which there are many, in Buddhism is between Hinayana and Mahayana. The "Little" or "Inferior" Vehicle and the "Great" or "Supreme" Vehicle. Obviously, the division had its contentiousness, as the polemic possibilities of the names imply, yet both schools still exist, and in harmony in many varying forms.
Simplifying it for Christian structure, Hinayana is "little" because it focuses on the Enlightenment/Salvation of the individual and transcendence, whereas Mahayana is "great" because is focuses on Universal Enlightenment/Salvation and immanence. NOTE: Again, this is meant to illuminate Christian constructs, not to comprehensively explain the two main schools of Buddhism.
We can, in this simplified model, see a direct, if imperfect, reflection of the two main divisions of Christianity. We complicate it with presenting issues that lead to division, but simply put, the division in Christianity is between those who (1) see the created Universe as fallen into darkness and irrevocably corrupted, necessitating a departure from the physical universe to find final happiness, which is necessarily an individual pursuit and (2) those who see the created Universe as tarnished and misguided, but inherently good as a Creation of God, and who believe the Kingdom of Heaven will come here, necessitating a group effort toward bringing that joy and fulfillment to all. The important point is, both groups have good basis for believing as they do and no more pressing evidence that they are completely right. I have been in both groups at various times of my life. It is a dichotomy in that, one cannot accept both utter fallenness and incurable ignorance and possible enlightenment and fulfillment in the same space. The harmony is that, both are apparently valid views and both provide a place for a particular way of interacting with our environment.
Avoiding blame or praise and forgiving my clumsy, often irreverent, expression, we see this in the differences between the evangelizing of both groups. The first group will seek to follow a set of pre- and proscriptions for life, viewing this life as sort of "the price of admission" to the Paradisal Afterlife. Part of that set of rules makes the spread of that salvation, hence the adherence to those rules, an important part of paying admission - thus, the almost-compulsive nature of the first group's insistence on following this or that set of laws and rules, perceived as aggressive and meddling, and their view of the second group as, perhaps, relativists and hedonists.
The second group sees growth and potential in this life and seeks God and fulfillment in God here. This group takes the concept of bringing the Kingdom as seriously as the first group does the concept of attaining the Kingdom. To this end, the second group focuses on ongoing revelation as a means to justice, on learning through experience as evidence of God, on personal conscience and societal concerns as evidence of Immanence and God's ongoing compassion and understanding. This group is often perceived as militant and altogether secular, while viewing the first group as rigidly, even wilfully and stupidly, doctrinaire, backwards and prejudiced.
The thing is, both are right in their own bailiwick and both are wrong. Both have failed and both have succeeded. There are good and bad in both.
Most importantly, both are necessary as there are, broadly, both types of people, and God informs both as both need.
THE SECOND MISCONCEPTION
Only one of us can possibly be right!
Again, no.
Life is expansion and contraction. To put it another way, Truth to a mind unready is as good as a lie.
There must be a place for those who cannot - simply cannot - move beyond a certain point in comfort level. The complexity of human nature gives us the many churches to accomplish this. There are places in which there is strict liturgical and dogmatic structure, a liberal dogma and complex liturgy, a free-form worship and strict dogma, etc. There are, also, areas in which dogma is strict or free, depending on the church; where there are significant differences from congregation to congregation in worship, or theology or both. Life is also complexity, diversity.
Death and stagnation - a mummified corpse - that's fairly simple and straightforward.
So, what can we do?
Though we are more doctrinaire, by nature, than the Buddhist religion, we can look to them for some example.
The most basic division, of which there are many, in Buddhism is between Hinayana and Mahayana. The "Little" or "Inferior" Vehicle and the "Great" or "Supreme" Vehicle. Obviously, the division had its contentiousness, as the polemic possibilities of the names imply, yet both schools still exist, and in harmony in many varying forms.
Simplifying it for Christian structure, Hinayana is "little" because it focuses on the Enlightenment/Salvation of the individual and transcendence, whereas Mahayana is "great" because is focuses on Universal Enlightenment/Salvation and immanence. NOTE: Again, this is meant to illuminate Christian constructs, not to comprehensively explain the two main schools of Buddhism.
We can, in this simplified model, see a direct, if imperfect, reflection of the two main divisions of Christianity. We complicate it with presenting issues that lead to division, but simply put, the division in Christianity is between those who (1) see the created Universe as fallen into darkness and irrevocably corrupted, necessitating a departure from the physical universe to find final happiness, which is necessarily an individual pursuit and (2) those who see the created Universe as tarnished and misguided, but inherently good as a Creation of God, and who believe the Kingdom of Heaven will come here, necessitating a group effort toward bringing that joy and fulfillment to all. The important point is, both groups have good basis for believing as they do and no more pressing evidence that they are completely right. I have been in both groups at various times of my life. It is a dichotomy in that, one cannot accept both utter fallenness and incurable ignorance and possible enlightenment and fulfillment in the same space. The harmony is that, both are apparently valid views and both provide a place for a particular way of interacting with our environment.
Avoiding blame or praise and forgiving my clumsy, often irreverent, expression, we see this in the differences between the evangelizing of both groups. The first group will seek to follow a set of pre- and proscriptions for life, viewing this life as sort of "the price of admission" to the Paradisal Afterlife. Part of that set of rules makes the spread of that salvation, hence the adherence to those rules, an important part of paying admission - thus, the almost-compulsive nature of the first group's insistence on following this or that set of laws and rules, perceived as aggressive and meddling, and their view of the second group as, perhaps, relativists and hedonists.
The second group sees growth and potential in this life and seeks God and fulfillment in God here. This group takes the concept of bringing the Kingdom as seriously as the first group does the concept of attaining the Kingdom. To this end, the second group focuses on ongoing revelation as a means to justice, on learning through experience as evidence of God, on personal conscience and societal concerns as evidence of Immanence and God's ongoing compassion and understanding. This group is often perceived as militant and altogether secular, while viewing the first group as rigidly, even wilfully and stupidly, doctrinaire, backwards and prejudiced.
The thing is, both are right in their own bailiwick and both are wrong. Both have failed and both have succeeded. There are good and bad in both.
Most importantly, both are necessary as there are, broadly, both types of people, and God informs both as both need.
Reflecting Upon It - I
I've really been trying to understand the divide in Christianity here, a "way forward" that is actually a way forward and not simply a way to establish a holding pattern.
Many workable ways have been suggested, but they all hinge on a peaceful coexistence which is simply not possible at this juncture. The blame is equally-distributed on both sides; whether we wish to see it or not, many on the progressive end of the pole are just as much committed to "Total Victory" as those on the conservative end. I've been perceived as one of those, because of my desire to excommunicate the far-right cheerleaders from TEC. This is not the case.
THE FIRST MISCONCEPTION
Dividing up into separate churches is bad!
No, it isn't.
It just isn't.
No one is dividing up the Body of Christ, as so many people graphically put it.
Despite the claims of the Orthodox or the Roman Catholic, no church is Church. We can excommunicate from an ecclesial body as discipline or to protect that body and its particular charism - usually a developed, rather than decided upon charism - but we can't "cast out" from the Church. The Church is the body of believers, doing their separate and communal -relatively-speaking - thing as God gives us to do. I may rail and rant against whomever I like, but only by destroying them and their God-given charism can I make a scar on the Body of Christ.
Remember, the Kingdom of Heaven is almost always compared in Jesus' parables with a growing thing. Thus, the Church is always a growing thing and never complete. There was one cell, then another, then another. We had been, during the Reformation particularly, in a cancerous state, not because of "cellular" proliferation, but because the "cells" were each trying to destroy one another. The race-memory of the horror of those days has led us to embrace a vision of a One World United Church conceived as a single ecclesial unit. The irony is that, as a result, the cancer's coming out of remission! This because we cannot be one unit without sacrificing all charism to a sort of bland, entirely-secular, entirely-ineffective structure. We are at war, in this misguided attempt at unification, because God won't let us homogenize into one thing. He has a function and plan that requires many doing many things. Why? You and I don't need to know, and cannot until it all comes together.
So, enough of this nonsense of all of us being of a piece "just like the good ol' days" before the Great Schism. It was never that way, and being that way is the disordered state. The order comes from each part of this Great, Growing, Increasingly-Complex Body of Christ doing its part, while allowing the others to do their own. We don't need to meddle in each others' internal functions, or "have our rightful say" about their way of doing things - the only "rightful" say comes from God.
Now, I'm aware that there are objections, "What about community? What about the 'family' of the Church? What about mutual accountability?"
Saying that these things are unanswered by separate structures is like saying there is no world community or economy or cooperation because we have different countries. There is no family of humanity because we are under different governments. We have no influence or accountability on any other nation.
Living things grow. Cells divide to do that.
Many workable ways have been suggested, but they all hinge on a peaceful coexistence which is simply not possible at this juncture. The blame is equally-distributed on both sides; whether we wish to see it or not, many on the progressive end of the pole are just as much committed to "Total Victory" as those on the conservative end. I've been perceived as one of those, because of my desire to excommunicate the far-right cheerleaders from TEC. This is not the case.
THE FIRST MISCONCEPTION
Dividing up into separate churches is bad!
No, it isn't.
It just isn't.
No one is dividing up the Body of Christ, as so many people graphically put it.
Despite the claims of the Orthodox or the Roman Catholic, no church is Church. We can excommunicate from an ecclesial body as discipline or to protect that body and its particular charism - usually a developed, rather than decided upon charism - but we can't "cast out" from the Church. The Church is the body of believers, doing their separate and communal -relatively-speaking - thing as God gives us to do. I may rail and rant against whomever I like, but only by destroying them and their God-given charism can I make a scar on the Body of Christ.
Remember, the Kingdom of Heaven is almost always compared in Jesus' parables with a growing thing. Thus, the Church is always a growing thing and never complete. There was one cell, then another, then another. We had been, during the Reformation particularly, in a cancerous state, not because of "cellular" proliferation, but because the "cells" were each trying to destroy one another. The race-memory of the horror of those days has led us to embrace a vision of a One World United Church conceived as a single ecclesial unit. The irony is that, as a result, the cancer's coming out of remission! This because we cannot be one unit without sacrificing all charism to a sort of bland, entirely-secular, entirely-ineffective structure. We are at war, in this misguided attempt at unification, because God won't let us homogenize into one thing. He has a function and plan that requires many doing many things. Why? You and I don't need to know, and cannot until it all comes together.
So, enough of this nonsense of all of us being of a piece "just like the good ol' days" before the Great Schism. It was never that way, and being that way is the disordered state. The order comes from each part of this Great, Growing, Increasingly-Complex Body of Christ doing its part, while allowing the others to do their own. We don't need to meddle in each others' internal functions, or "have our rightful say" about their way of doing things - the only "rightful" say comes from God.
Now, I'm aware that there are objections, "What about community? What about the 'family' of the Church? What about mutual accountability?"
Saying that these things are unanswered by separate structures is like saying there is no world community or economy or cooperation because we have different countries. There is no family of humanity because we are under different governments. We have no influence or accountability on any other nation.
Living things grow. Cells divide to do that.
Belated
I've been meaning to post this for a while, but forgot, and forgot, and forgot.
THE SLATE FOR THE CANDIDATES FOR BISHOP OF THE EPISCOPAL DIOCESE OF GEORGIA
Quite a rogues' gallery, isn't it?
THE SLATE FOR THE CANDIDATES FOR BISHOP OF THE EPISCOPAL DIOCESE OF GEORGIA
Quite a rogues' gallery, isn't it?
Thursday, July 30, 2009
7/30/09
Another thing I'm struggling with:
Why bother with the church?
I'm not saying I'll leave. It wouldn't matter to a soul if I did, and I have reasons for staying - I believe in God, I love my fellow-parishioners and need them. Frankly, I neither need nor value orthodites, so why should I value or support a church that continually aids in their wickedness? I wonder if there is a point at which we will have to look around and admit that the ecclesial institution - as a whole enterprise - has failed, and what we call "churches" are destroying, rather than bringing the Kingdom. I wonder if we're at that point.
Maybe "church" should die and there can be Church, again.
Mimi once said that she didn't believe she was extraordinary, but she is, as are many of us in the progressive side of things. I'm sorry. I know how that will be taken by the orthodites, but I can't help the truth. We see things, apart from desire for security, apart from fear of difference, apart from the need to compartmentalize and "study" and destroy living differences and spirit, apart from - well - all the things that make churches, churches.
I believe that makes us an evolutionary vanguard - not special, but simply leading - and, perhaps, we need to make a new image of ekklesia.
Why bother with the church?
I'm not saying I'll leave. It wouldn't matter to a soul if I did, and I have reasons for staying - I believe in God, I love my fellow-parishioners and need them. Frankly, I neither need nor value orthodites, so why should I value or support a church that continually aids in their wickedness? I wonder if there is a point at which we will have to look around and admit that the ecclesial institution - as a whole enterprise - has failed, and what we call "churches" are destroying, rather than bringing the Kingdom. I wonder if we're at that point.
Maybe "church" should die and there can be Church, again.
Mimi once said that she didn't believe she was extraordinary, but she is, as are many of us in the progressive side of things. I'm sorry. I know how that will be taken by the orthodites, but I can't help the truth. We see things, apart from desire for security, apart from fear of difference, apart from the need to compartmentalize and "study" and destroy living differences and spirit, apart from - well - all the things that make churches, churches.
I believe that makes us an evolutionary vanguard - not special, but simply leading - and, perhaps, we need to make a new image of ekklesia.
Monday, July 27, 2009
Things I Struggle With . . .
I sent an email to one of our delegates, a man in my parish, a man for whom I have great respect and love. I won't print any of what was said, so, please, take all that I say here completely as my interpretation of the communication.
As I've said on other blogs, I was angry, hurt, outraged and disappointed by the failure of our delegation to support D025 and 056. I expressed this to him clearly, and, he assured me, articulately. His response was thoughtful and clear, and reaffirmed my own confidence in him, as well as the people of my diocese. I understand that we are trying to maintain a neutral stance in the midst of all this, and I'm aware of my own idealism and mystical approach which makes me impatient with such a stance.
However, there is still a disconnect that leads to a real concern both for my actions and TEC's outlook. First, this gentleman assured me, repeatedly, of his acceptance of GLBT's, including stories of family members and his own willingness, if such a shift in policy were made, to bless the union of a gay family member (this member of my parish is also a postulant to Holy Orders). However, that's not what this is about. I struggle with sexuality; not with being gay, but with being a sexual being. I could care less, to be brutally blunt, about other peoples' romantic relationships. Marriage is a completely private affair, to my mind, and of little interest. I dislike married clergy, detest a married episcopate, and believe that, in secular terms, no married couple - even with children - should receive state breaks or benefits not extended to each individual. I don't hate marriage - - I could never work up that much feeling about it.
I thought I had made clear that "gay" is not what any of this is about. If that were it, I'd care less. The justice aspect is my immediate concern, with justice for the individual being the greatest part of that. To lay suffering and misery, disdain and hate on another on the basis of no more than "tradition" or even outright superstition is wrong. Even if you claim that you believe the tradition and scripture to be absolutely correct, so what? Without objective evidence, you have no right to enforce your beliefs. I've set that out in my argument in a thread below - - belief counts only so far as it can be proven, especially when that belief operates as proscription. I believe marriage and romantic relationships are futile, perhaps destructive and I believe that children can be produced without such entanglements and raised successfully in a group/societal environment. If my belief, through argument or luck, becomes the majority one, should that alone ensure its enforcement? This is the crux. To deny others' own experience of themselves is to arrogate unbelievable power to oneself. I don't deny that the orthodites experience God as fearful, vengeful, irrational, distant, that they experience homosexuality as personally harmful. Again, so what? They can believe that. I won't make them sleep with others of their sex, or deny them romantic/sexual expression outside of same-sexual relationships. I won't deny them the right to believe God is what they view, even it's truth . . . for them. God relates as we need Him, and they need an inscrutable parent/policeman/watchdog. The conflict lay in their trying to make themselves special by taking God's power to themselves, to define their beliefs and experiences as universal. If you must maintain purity, withdraw and do so, but don't require the world around to conform to your desires.
This is my concern. Not "teh gay." Sex is . . . maintenance. The issue is who is God; I'm not, but neither are they, and taking that upon themselves is something I must oppose, for their good as for mine, so I struggle with issues that, as presenting issues, are of little concern. I struggle with the idea that we too have become entirely too immersed with the "presenting issue." Perhaps my identity as a gay man, or that part that I identify with as gay, is too caught up in it to present the real dangers and point of the struggle. I frankly don't know what God thinks of homosexuality - I simply know what He thinks of me, including my own sexuality, and what He shows me in the steady gay relationships I've come to see around me.
I also struggle - mightily - with the Anglican Communion, another major concern in my communication with my friend. I keep being told of its value. How much it allows us to do. Of its necessity at all costs. That by submitting to injustice for us in the First World we can slowly undo injustice in the Third World. I hate the Anglican Communion. Hate it. Despise it. Will dance on its grave. I believe it to be, not just useless, but a destructive demon of vanity and sloth. Yet, it's hard to see if that's right, or the supporters are.
AC's been around longer than me and has brilliant minds and open hearts in support of it. Yet, when I ask "HOW? How is the AC so important? What can it do that we cannot if we start to make new associations?" all I get is - as with ++Whalon - anecdotes about works that, quite honestly, could've been done as, if not more, effectively by a secular social-action network. Or, I'm told about "friendships" and connections made, as if that were some sort of magical formula, or even real. Clearly, those "friendships" have proven false or based on convenience in many cases. I suspect a sort of American imperialism in it, benevolently-conceived, but imperialistic, nonetheless, which says, "By God, they will love us! We will stay right there in their faces til they see we're right and they're wrong!" This I see combined with a wilfull ignorance of being used, abused and manipulated by these "friends," which is based in Pride - OUR Pride, refusing to believe we could've been fooled, wrong about our noble, liberal ideals and our application of them to people who have proven unworthy. I hear, most plaintively, that we can make it better by swallowing our pride and accepting the AC's declarations on our actions, their sanctions, their disdain. But no one can tell me how!
I'm not a big fan of Dr. Phil, but, let's be honest, there's a lot to be said for the simple question, "How's that been workin' for ya?" Things are worse, not better, for our penitence and shame, our degrading ourselves and our witness.
But, I struggle. Can it make it better if we just bow out? It feels wrong. Cowardly. Craven. Soft. Faithless. But, I'm aware of my own stiff neck. So, how can our humiliation help the "less fortunate?" Show me. I'll resist, but knowing that - I'll accept. Prove it. Prove we need the AC. I'm not gainsaying, but really struggling.
So, those who favor the AC over TEC's actions, please! tell me why we must stay, but be prepared to defend. Drivebys are not helpful. Vacuous statements of goodwill are pointless. Show me.
I'm struggling. Doing the same thing over and over expecting different results is craziness. But . . . which of us is crazy?
As I've said on other blogs, I was angry, hurt, outraged and disappointed by the failure of our delegation to support D025 and 056. I expressed this to him clearly, and, he assured me, articulately. His response was thoughtful and clear, and reaffirmed my own confidence in him, as well as the people of my diocese. I understand that we are trying to maintain a neutral stance in the midst of all this, and I'm aware of my own idealism and mystical approach which makes me impatient with such a stance.
However, there is still a disconnect that leads to a real concern both for my actions and TEC's outlook. First, this gentleman assured me, repeatedly, of his acceptance of GLBT's, including stories of family members and his own willingness, if such a shift in policy were made, to bless the union of a gay family member (this member of my parish is also a postulant to Holy Orders). However, that's not what this is about. I struggle with sexuality; not with being gay, but with being a sexual being. I could care less, to be brutally blunt, about other peoples' romantic relationships. Marriage is a completely private affair, to my mind, and of little interest. I dislike married clergy, detest a married episcopate, and believe that, in secular terms, no married couple - even with children - should receive state breaks or benefits not extended to each individual. I don't hate marriage - - I could never work up that much feeling about it.
I thought I had made clear that "gay" is not what any of this is about. If that were it, I'd care less. The justice aspect is my immediate concern, with justice for the individual being the greatest part of that. To lay suffering and misery, disdain and hate on another on the basis of no more than "tradition" or even outright superstition is wrong. Even if you claim that you believe the tradition and scripture to be absolutely correct, so what? Without objective evidence, you have no right to enforce your beliefs. I've set that out in my argument in a thread below - - belief counts only so far as it can be proven, especially when that belief operates as proscription. I believe marriage and romantic relationships are futile, perhaps destructive and I believe that children can be produced without such entanglements and raised successfully in a group/societal environment. If my belief, through argument or luck, becomes the majority one, should that alone ensure its enforcement? This is the crux. To deny others' own experience of themselves is to arrogate unbelievable power to oneself. I don't deny that the orthodites experience God as fearful, vengeful, irrational, distant, that they experience homosexuality as personally harmful. Again, so what? They can believe that. I won't make them sleep with others of their sex, or deny them romantic/sexual expression outside of same-sexual relationships. I won't deny them the right to believe God is what they view, even it's truth . . . for them. God relates as we need Him, and they need an inscrutable parent/policeman/watchdog. The conflict lay in their trying to make themselves special by taking God's power to themselves, to define their beliefs and experiences as universal. If you must maintain purity, withdraw and do so, but don't require the world around to conform to your desires.
This is my concern. Not "teh gay." Sex is . . . maintenance. The issue is who is God; I'm not, but neither are they, and taking that upon themselves is something I must oppose, for their good as for mine, so I struggle with issues that, as presenting issues, are of little concern. I struggle with the idea that we too have become entirely too immersed with the "presenting issue." Perhaps my identity as a gay man, or that part that I identify with as gay, is too caught up in it to present the real dangers and point of the struggle. I frankly don't know what God thinks of homosexuality - I simply know what He thinks of me, including my own sexuality, and what He shows me in the steady gay relationships I've come to see around me.
I also struggle - mightily - with the Anglican Communion, another major concern in my communication with my friend. I keep being told of its value. How much it allows us to do. Of its necessity at all costs. That by submitting to injustice for us in the First World we can slowly undo injustice in the Third World. I hate the Anglican Communion. Hate it. Despise it. Will dance on its grave. I believe it to be, not just useless, but a destructive demon of vanity and sloth. Yet, it's hard to see if that's right, or the supporters are.
AC's been around longer than me and has brilliant minds and open hearts in support of it. Yet, when I ask "HOW? How is the AC so important? What can it do that we cannot if we start to make new associations?" all I get is - as with ++Whalon - anecdotes about works that, quite honestly, could've been done as, if not more, effectively by a secular social-action network. Or, I'm told about "friendships" and connections made, as if that were some sort of magical formula, or even real. Clearly, those "friendships" have proven false or based on convenience in many cases. I suspect a sort of American imperialism in it, benevolently-conceived, but imperialistic, nonetheless, which says, "By God, they will love us! We will stay right there in their faces til they see we're right and they're wrong!" This I see combined with a wilfull ignorance of being used, abused and manipulated by these "friends," which is based in Pride - OUR Pride, refusing to believe we could've been fooled, wrong about our noble, liberal ideals and our application of them to people who have proven unworthy. I hear, most plaintively, that we can make it better by swallowing our pride and accepting the AC's declarations on our actions, their sanctions, their disdain. But no one can tell me how!
I'm not a big fan of Dr. Phil, but, let's be honest, there's a lot to be said for the simple question, "How's that been workin' for ya?" Things are worse, not better, for our penitence and shame, our degrading ourselves and our witness.
But, I struggle. Can it make it better if we just bow out? It feels wrong. Cowardly. Craven. Soft. Faithless. But, I'm aware of my own stiff neck. So, how can our humiliation help the "less fortunate?" Show me. I'll resist, but knowing that - I'll accept. Prove it. Prove we need the AC. I'm not gainsaying, but really struggling.
So, those who favor the AC over TEC's actions, please! tell me why we must stay, but be prepared to defend. Drivebys are not helpful. Vacuous statements of goodwill are pointless. Show me.
I'm struggling. Doing the same thing over and over expecting different results is craziness. But . . . which of us is crazy?
"Thank you very much! Thank you very much! . . "

For any of us who remember the Albert Finney film Scrooge, you know the context of the song.
I sing it, today, to Ebenezer Williams of Canterbury.
He has given us a great gift in his reflections which may be found here with further comment on Thinking Anglicans here.
This is the part I'm most grateful for (emphases mine):
I sing it, today, to Ebenezer Williams of Canterbury.
He has given us a great gift in his reflections which may be found here with further comment on Thinking Anglicans here.
This is the part I'm most grateful for (emphases mine):
". . a person living in such a union is in the same case as a heterosexual
person living in a sexual relationship outside the marriage bond; whatever the human respect and pastoral sensitivity such persons
must be given, their chosen lifestyle is not one that the Church's teaching sanctions, and thus it is hard to see how they can act in the
necessarily representative role that the ordained ministry, especially the
episcopate, requires....So long as the Church Catholic, or even the
Communion as a whole does not bless same-sex unions, a person living in such a union cannot without serious incongruity have a representative function in a Church whose public teaching is at odds with their lifestyle..."
Get that folks?
Now, Rowan says "We might have to treat them like humans, but the fags chose to be fags, so we don't have to treat them as full humans. The Bible says so! Just look!
"Not only that, but we have to hold ourselves accountable to THE CHURCH, especially those parts we left because we figured they were wrong. And, even if you don't accept that, you can't do anything that the whole church doesn't do because, of course, the Communion is actually a CHURCH, which is my CHURCH, and I say what flies, and what flies is appeasing the lowest common denominator!"
If you're getting a more charitable reading out of this, please, check with your doctor about medication.
So, I am thankful.
Even alleged centrists will have to accept that Rowan has completely betrayed their trust. Even die-hard "communionists" will have to accept that there is no Anglican Communion - at least, without jettisoning Cantuar. All there is otherwise, is a miniature Rome, being groomed to allow Rowan to bring a suitable sacrifice when he kneels before Peter's throne, or the iconostasis, or whichever church he's been a sleeper-cell for for so long.
Even those who believed - and I was one of them - that he really-deep-in-his-heart understood and supported LGBT's and was simply trying to make peace in the family, even those folks have got to say, now, "We were wrong. He considers us just as 'unclean' as the orthodites!"
Thank you, Rowan, for finally taking the mask off.
Hopefully, it wasn't too late.
Oh, and I frackin' . . . well, you know.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)