Monday, August 3, 2009

Reflecting Upon It - I

I've really been trying to understand the divide in Christianity here, a "way forward" that is actually a way forward and not simply a way to establish a holding pattern.

Many workable ways have been suggested, but they all hinge on a peaceful coexistence which is simply not possible at this juncture. The blame is equally-distributed on both sides; whether we wish to see it or not, many on the progressive end of the pole are just as much committed to "Total Victory" as those on the conservative end. I've been perceived as one of those, because of my desire to excommunicate the far-right cheerleaders from TEC. This is not the case.

THE FIRST MISCONCEPTION

Dividing up into separate churches is bad!

No, it isn't.

It just isn't.

No one is dividing up the Body of Christ, as so many people graphically put it.

Despite the claims of the Orthodox or the Roman Catholic, no church is Church. We can excommunicate from an ecclesial body as discipline or to protect that body and its particular charism - usually a developed, rather than decided upon charism - but we can't "cast out" from the Church. The Church is the body of believers, doing their separate and communal -relatively-speaking - thing as God gives us to do. I may rail and rant against whomever I like, but only by destroying them and their God-given charism can I make a scar on the Body of Christ.

Remember, the Kingdom of Heaven is almost always compared in Jesus' parables with a growing thing. Thus, the Church is always a growing thing and never complete. There was one cell, then another, then another. We had been, during the Reformation particularly, in a cancerous state, not because of "cellular" proliferation, but because the "cells" were each trying to destroy one another. The race-memory of the horror of those days has led us to embrace a vision of a One World United Church conceived as a single ecclesial unit. The irony is that, as a result, the cancer's coming out of remission! This because we cannot be one unit without sacrificing all charism to a sort of bland, entirely-secular, entirely-ineffective structure. We are at war, in this misguided attempt at unification, because God won't let us homogenize into one thing. He has a function and plan that requires many doing many things. Why? You and I don't need to know, and cannot until it all comes together.

So, enough of this nonsense of all of us being of a piece "just like the good ol' days" before the Great Schism. It was never that way, and being that way is the disordered state. The order comes from each part of this Great, Growing, Increasingly-Complex Body of Christ doing its part, while allowing the others to do their own. We don't need to meddle in each others' internal functions, or "have our rightful say" about their way of doing things - the only "rightful" say comes from God.

Now, I'm aware that there are objections, "What about community? What about the 'family' of the Church? What about mutual accountability?"

Saying that these things are unanswered by separate structures is like saying there is no world community or economy or cooperation because we have different countries. There is no family of humanity because we are under different governments. We have no influence or accountability on any other nation.

Living things grow. Cells divide to do that.

4 comments:

June Butler said...

Mark, TEC is moving forward. The Anglican Church in Canada is moving forward. Finally the membership in the Church of England seems to be waking up to the dire situation in their church.

I don't see total victory as a worthy goal. I don't see excommunicating people as an answer to our troubles. We move forward deliberately, doing right as we see it, and those who want to stay will stay, and those who want to go will go, by their own choice, not by us cutting them out.

My thoughts on Part I.

MarkBrunson said...

I'm really not sure that we are far enough along to see if we are really moving forward. I think it's really too early to tell. The covenant would be a giant move backward, for instance.

I'm not advocating Total Victory; if that seems to be the case, I apologize. I don't advocate a Purge, but those who stay for the purposes of destruction from the inside - as opposed to the "loyal opposition" - should be considered for excommunication, at least.

My reasoning for this is that neither the group nor the individual is served by such agitation and malcontent. Both are better served by separation.

June Butler said...

Mark, people have to commit an excommunicatable offense before they can be asked to leave. It's not only about bad intentions and agitation.

As to the covenant, I agree. That would be a disaster. Ever since the word got out to the Anglican world, from the first mention of a covenant, I have been against it.

MarkBrunson said...

Surely, though, an attempt to destroy or derail the community - as in going to Anaheim to "blow things up" - and agitating to destroy or circumvent (not oppose)its decision-making course should be considered an excommunicatable offense?

I don't believe I've said that simple perception of another's intention should be the criterion. Nor should excommunication be easy or limited to a decision of one bishop or diocese.

Still, Church is available to all and part of an ideal condition - church, however, exists in the human state and requires both rules and discipline. Mercy and compassion are a necessity in interpreting that rule and discipline, but, unbalanced, they are just as dangerous as unbalanced severity.

Why does the idea of excommunication worry you so?