Wednesday, August 5, 2009

Reflecting Upon It - III

The third and fourth misconceptions are really the opposite side of the coin, one the inverse of the other.

Both come, hopefully enough, from a realization that whatever we are doing is clearly not working. The answers, though, are reactionary.

THE THIRD MISCONCEPTION

The only way we can save Christianity is by going back to the orthodoxy of the past!

This is obviously not true.

Why obvious?

If what we are doing is clearly not working, then, just as clearly, what we have done hasn't worked or we wouldn't have done something else. Don't believe me? The most conservative estimate puts Christianity - organized, institutionalized Christianity - at some 1,600 years of age. If it was working, we'd all be at Peace, or at least Christian, by now. Instead, we've had break after break, all very acrimonious and frequently bloody, rather than a wise tolerance and faith.

The past hasn't worked any better than the present, and it is both unwise and faithless to assume an end to revelation and guidance in the present age, as does our past-looking traditionalism. Indeed, the only "revelation" allowed in such a stagnant view is that which is absolutely verified by Scripture and Tradition, which is not revelation in any sense.

At the same time, ongoing revelation does not mean something "novel" or that God has "changed His mind," but that we are humble enough to realize that we - the corporate we all the way back to the original disciples and patriarchs of the OT - didn't comprehend completely.

THE FOURTH MISCONCEPTION

We have to abandon the past and create something entirely new!

While this seems, at first blush, a good idea, we can see that it's really just a repetition of the past. In fact, every schism or reformation or counter-reformation has been about "ditching the past." The result has been the same turmoil.

Humans crave entertainment and novelty. Mega-churches are able to mega-church because they offer novelty. When that wears off or is gotten with greater benefits at a lesser cost, the mega usually dies out.

Humans also crave being told what they want to hear, which is "Whatever you're doing right now, what you're comfortable with, that's just right!" Yet, we have evolved enough to have learned that such comfort is often not an indicator of growth or health. At the same time, the novelty - and yes, it is novelty - of fundamentalist puritanism makes the tragic error of overlooking actual harm and clinging to the "rule book" come hell or high water! Both are ways of finding that illusory comfort.

What is needed is work, and discernment. Which is why a truly effective church will always be a small one, because most people are going to be lured away by the easier lifestyle.

Between the two misconceptions, there lies the old thesis-antithesis-synthesis of Hegel (I think it was Hegel), but ours has to be something that is not automatic, a sort of autonomous function, but a sifting and discerning, both of past failures and successes and present demand and knowledge, enthused by an experimental, risk-allowing spirit.

Rather than thesis-antithesis-synthesis, we might think of a more active dynamic - from our perspective - of Adapt, Adopt and Improve.

No comments: