Thursday, July 30, 2009

7/30/09

Another thing I'm struggling with:

Why bother with the church?

I'm not saying I'll leave. It wouldn't matter to a soul if I did, and I have reasons for staying - I believe in God, I love my fellow-parishioners and need them. Frankly, I neither need nor value orthodites, so why should I value or support a church that continually aids in their wickedness? I wonder if there is a point at which we will have to look around and admit that the ecclesial institution - as a whole enterprise - has failed, and what we call "churches" are destroying, rather than bringing the Kingdom. I wonder if we're at that point.

Maybe "church" should die and there can be Church, again.

Mimi once said that she didn't believe she was extraordinary, but she is, as are many of us in the progressive side of things. I'm sorry. I know how that will be taken by the orthodites, but I can't help the truth. We see things, apart from desire for security, apart from fear of difference, apart from the need to compartmentalize and "study" and destroy living differences and spirit, apart from - well - all the things that make churches, churches.

I believe that makes us an evolutionary vanguard - not special, but simply leading - and, perhaps, we need to make a new image of ekklesia.

1 comment:

Erika Baker said...

I have been struggling with this question for the last year or so, and depending on the day, I come to different conclusions each time.
I have stopped going to church, started going to church, stopped reading churchy blogs, started again, stopped commenting, started again….

Where I’m now is that I believe I am automatically part of church as long as I have faith. The church is the body of Christ, is the community of all believers. Everything is splitting into denominations, little sub-groups each with their own strengths and weaknesses, each with their own ego.
So in a very real way I cannot leave church.

I can stop going to church. But like you, I like my local church, I like the people in my congregation, I still like some of the ritual of worship, some of the liturgy, some of the singing.
And my real problem is with the institutional church and it’s noisy hierarchies. But although I engage loudly with what’s going on at that level on the blogs, I have to admit that it has absolutely no influence on my personal life. It did, at one point, but that point is long long past. Now, it cannot touch me.

So rather than ask “why go to church”, I try to ask what I achieve by not going. And locally, I achieve nothing other than judge people who don’t deserve the judgement, and by contributing to decreasing numbers, and yet another liberal leaving the ship, which makes it even more conservative heavy and likely to topple soon. And deprive myself of fellowship, of coming together in difference to stand united before God – all the things I claim I want from The Church.

Maybe we just have to free ourselves from the notion that “church” is a particular organisation focused on a particular building and a particular ritual. If we do that, then we see that church will not die, because God will still be in the hearts of all those who have left the official organisation.
What we’re doing is straddling the two.
And that’s not such a bad place to be.