Monday, August 17, 2009

So, Hate Me If You Want . . .

You'll be shocked, horrified, dismissive, perhaps feel smugly superior because of what I'm going to write here, but I have to get it out of my system, whether it's prophecy or poison.

It begins with evolution, and has the potential to spiral into a Nietzschean-Third-Reich nightmare. It may come from tiredness and a growing, and, I fear, terminal bitterness toward humanity and its inevitable destruction. It has elements of objective positivism, which makes me feel ill and dirty, because I loathe Ayn Rand and her attempt to codify adolescent selfishness into a philosophy.

Simply put, over the past 30 years of more-or-less attentive life, I've noticed a difference in people. I put this down to evolution. Some of us have been able to develop a broader, intuitive, and compassionately world-based vision, which eschews sectarianism, while not denying spirituality. We are of varying levels of intelligence, but all seem to be of a fairly high degree of creativity and vision. We tend to be called liberal - I prefer progressive.

Opposing us, calling themselves predominantly conservative, are those of a different evolutionary degree, stuck - by no fault of their own - in a view of the "mud" of the world, that life is nasty, brutish, and short and must be. Their view is that those who try to change the world for the better are trying to take something from them. In fact, it is a largely brutish and animalistic worldview predominant in sectarians and fundamentalists of all religions. Look at the past eight years of damage to a world super-power, selected and inflicted by the "people" themselves. Look at the present, with these people dashing themselves against the rocks to oppose universal healthcare, all on the basis of what, to any rational being, is a concoction of lies. This is not racial. Blacks, whites, orientals, latinos all fall into both levels of evolution. There are the twin poles of Desmond Tutu and Peter Akinola, Dalai Lama and Kim Jong Il, and on and on.

Evolution on the physical level is largely complete, at least at the level we can intellectually deal with. Mental and - for lack of a less nebulous term - spiritual evolution is next.

To state the unthinkable, we are the higher evolutionary level.

We don't like to think these things, much less say them. It's rude, it's exclusive, it's self-important. All these responses are part of the evolutionary development, but not all are useful in every situation. We have become surrounded by people whose view of the world is that it - and everyone in it - must be beaten into submission. They see no higher purpose or consciousness in others because they have none. They are an evolutionary dead end. They have prospered and expanded and become dominant because we, in our evolutionary development of compassion and non-violence, have allowed them to prosper and participate. This is not bad, but it has become unbalanced. We are in danger of being ridden right over. Many point to change, but this is an evolutionary knife-edge - we can easily be wiped out, and the violent mindset of those on the lower evolutionary edge makes that a very real threat. Evolution is growth and maturation; devolution is stagation and death. Mankind is in the balance.

40 comments:

Revd. Neal Terry said...

It may be both prophecy and poison. Evolutionary leaps are invariably evolutionary dead ends unless the prevailing conditions are right for it. Nonetheless I have some empathy for what you are saying.
Have you read Odd John by Olaf Stapledon? A useful allegory for your thoughts if not the ending you may wish for.

Wormwood's Doxy said...

I have a strong streak of pessimism, myself. There are days when I look at the progress we've made, and realize just how shaky it all is. How one big shock (economic, environmental, whatever) could send it all to ruin. How so much of our progress is dependent on people having the wherewithal to focus on something besides basic survival. I wonder what will happen when there is no more oil, and we have to go back to living in small, local communities because we have no other choice?

But then I ask myself: "What else can we do, but keep trying?"

We may end up being the evolutionary dead-end because we won't destroy those who would destroy us. But I'd rather be in that position than be the nasty-brutish-and short type. We can at least know that we tried--and, to me, that is worth doing.

(((Mark)))

MarkBrunson said...

Doxy,

I'm not certain I've quite explained myself.

It would be as impossible for you to become a nasty-brutish-short type, just as impossible as it would be for a Cro-Magnon to become a Neanderthal. You are of a different evolutionary order.

Destruction. To go back to the Neanderthal/Cro-Magnon analogy: those two lived together, we believe, for some thousands of years. Was it by interbreeding or direct conflict that one survived and thrived? Destruction is where I fear what I'm saying could lead. That is the objective-positivist strain in all of us, to take the easy answer. That, perhaps, is even more prevalent in us who see community and peace as the goal, as we don't believe life should be struggle, or that suffering is intrinsically good.

If you haven't already, look at Strangelove's reply to MadPriest on the Thought for the Day for the 18th. It blew my mind, because Strangelove posits the idea of evil people manipulating the fears of a group realizing their - forgive the coldness of the term - their obsolescence.

Advances in communication have given us unparalleled ability to share ideas. It has also given unparalleled ability to spread propaganda, and there are those who, for whatever reason, want humanity to fail. Strangelove brought me up short because, frankly, I keep forgetting the problem of evil, or entropy, as I prefer to think of it; the pull of the universe's energy toward chaos. In Strangelove's theory, I think we see the problem as one, not of destroying an enemy, but of reigning in those who are exploiting that lower evolutionary order - and yes, I feel dirty saying that - to their advantage. Look at Glenn Beck, Rupert Murdoch, etc. - they'd have to work for a living without fear to manipulate!

I don't want destruction, any more than a healthy adult wants a child destroyed. At the same time, we don't just tell the child, "Yeah. Well, if you think there are monsters under the bed, here's a gun." We don't let children vote. We try to guide and curb the more destructive, animalistic tendencies in children.

And children grow.

That's the thing, here, too. Previous evolutionary differences, being primarily physical, were necessarily static in the individual.

Is that necessarily the case where the evolutionary step is one of consciousness?

Erika Baker said...

Mark
"It would be as impossible for you to become a nasty-brutish-short type, just as impossible as it would be for a Cro-Magnon to become a Neanderthal."

So no free will here?


"At the same time, we don't just tell the child, "Yeah. Well, if you think there are monsters under the bed, here's a gun." We don't let children vote. We try to guide and curb the more destructive, animalistic tendencies in children."

Or ways of influencing things after all?

MarkBrunson said...

So no free will here?

I don't know.

Do you know many people who've stepped down from homo sapiens to Cro-Magnon? Ask them if they'll keep going - maybe we can find the missing link, finally.

Or ways of influencing things after all?

Which is rather what I was asking when I wrote:

"That's the thing, here, too. Previous evolutionary differences, being primarily physical, were necessarily static in the individual.

Is that necessarily the case where the evolutionary step is one of consciousness?"


It's a real question.

I don't know; if the evolutionary step up we've taken is based on physiological differences in the brain, then, short of brain surgery, no. If it's a difference in thought, then certainly, and the difference is no difference at all, except in a higher form of vision. I don't subscribe to that because of the simple inability of those in a lower state to understand concepts outside of previous - traditional - parameters. They are not unintelligent in the basic sense, so there is something else.

A difference in consciousness? I don't think we understand consciousness well enough to answer that.

We can influence children, for instance, but some are just not able to grow up, regardless of the good example set. We still love and protect them, but the analogy is limited, as most people would not then take steps to limit the adult child's ability to influence the larger community.

MarkBrunson said...

I should also state that I'm not a transhumanist. I have very little faith in technology as the means to improvement. A created thing cannot improve its creator, inherently, though it could, theoretically, improve the structure and performance of the creator. We can see that computers and medical advancements make us more efficient and long-lived, but the same problems of quality of life remain.

I suppose I'm more in favor of the concept of "Omega Point" - though I don't pretend to have actually studied Teilhard de Chardin's work, and only marginally have some idea of the concept.

Wormwood's Doxy said...

It would be as impossible for you to become a nasty-brutish-short type, just as impossible as it would be for a Cro-Magnon to become a Neanderthal. You are of a different evolutionary order.

I like the sound of that... ;-)

I may have misunderstood your original post--but what I was trying to say is that I think there may be something to your assessment. There was a study recently that found political orientation is related to differences in how the brain processes information. It gave me a way to make sense of how people could hold on to views that seem so odd or wrong to me.

Whether that difference is evolutionary or not, I don't know. If it is, wouldn't you expect progressives to produce only progressive children? I think that it's highly likely that they would--but not a given. (I'm doing my part. My son is an passionate and articulate progressive. :-)

But my pessimism was actually about the fact that the "Cro-Magnons" in your scenario may well defeat the evolutionary trend (if there is one). By refusing to care for the earth, or their fellow human beings, these people may have irreparably poisoned the well. By the time they are done, evolution may well have come to an end for the human race, because there will be nothing left to evolve IN.

Song in my Heart said...

I'm not sure I buy this.

Even if we think we are more compassionate, somehow wiser, advanced, more 'evolved' than people we disagree with--even people who do horrific, violent things--they, too, are the beloved children of God.

I get very, very frustrated with my fellow human beings. I think humanity could do so very much better than it does. I despair that we are shouting at one another, hurting one another, killing one another. We can do better.

I think most of the negative behaviour is rooted in fear. Fear that there isn't enough food, money, water... fear that there isn't enough love. I'm not prepared to give up on people just because they are scared.

I don't know where the balance lies...I don't know how to protect myself from the harm that can be done by fearful people while still attempting to reach them, still attempting to meet people where they are and coax them along gently into hope. And I do worry, sometimes, that it is all futile, that my efforts are for naught, that I am pouring energy and love into a situation which will chew me up and spit me out and leave me even more useless. I do try to pick my battles... and maybe that's what vocation is about, in some ways: picking where to try to make a difference, knowing where to focus my efforts. Even then, it is dangerous, this business of living in the world with the rest of God's children, who might decide, have decided before, that it is a good idea to deny me food and water or to threaten me or to beat me or to sexually assault me, because they are so very frightened of not having enough, so scared of losing control, so very twisted into their own terrors that they cannot see any other way to live and they actually have no control at all.

But I was afraid and I was rescued and transformed by love. I didn't kill anyone; maybe I didn't even hurt anyone very badly compared to some. I just put a protective wall up between myself and the world so I wouldn't have to live in pain, and I found that it amounted to not really living at all, and so I put a wall around the wall and hid further from my fears. But someone was able to see through all my layers and walls and fears and love me anyway, humanly and imperfectly, and it changed me profoundly.

I'm still human. I still hurt, and love consoles me. I still make mistakes, and love brings my attention to some of them so that I can learn to do better. I still get scared, and love brings me back to an awareness of... of love. For all my failings and fallings and human imperfections there is still love there.

I don't think God gives up on any of us. I will take reasonable steps to protect myself and others from abuse, but I will try not to de-humanise my abusers. Knowing they are humans and beloved of God, painful as that might be, is part of what keeps me human. I may not be able to change or transform them, but I will not condemn them! That is not for me to do.

If I can help one person, even one, to be more loving and hopeful, to know that they, too, are children of God, then my efforts will have been worthwhile.

MarkBrunson said...

Doxy,

Indeed. That's where the threat to Humanity lay.

We're outnumbered, so easily ignored. We also - frankly - tend to be a bit lazy and oversensitive, as a group. :)

MarkBrunson said...

I'm not sure I buy this.

Even if we think we are more compassionate, somehow wiser, advanced, more 'evolved' than people we disagree with--even people who do horrific, violent things--they, too, are the beloved children of God.


Song,

I'm going to be honest with you because you deserve it.

This is a knee-jerk reaction. I've never denied that they are human, nor that God loves them.

You have an observable tendency to dislike hearing that you have superior qualities - largely, I think, because "superior" has come to have such unpleasant moral connotations, i.e. "a superior race," "a superior religion," etc. - but you do. Now, you can deny that and pretend that it's just a muddle, but I don't buy that.

It's not compassion to refuse to even consider that we may have the greater responsibility to lead, just as it isn't altruism to deny that you have abilities and qualities others lack. This is where potential meets disaster. If we take it to mean that we have greater privilege, greater right to exist, then it becomes exactly the nightmare I'm speaking of.

MarkBrunson said...

Let me also be clear that, even if this isn't an evolutionary, but a difference of moral vision - which, again, I don't see evidenced - we still have a duty to either step up and take the leadership role, or, if that cannot be done within our moral safeguards, to find a way to distance and protect ourselves from what is a clearly destructive worldview. That isn't a question of tolerance or difference of opinion or bigotry, but simply a question of protecting the human race.

I don't buy into the "Ubermensch" idea that we are not answerable to normal morality. Most of us have seemingly in-built revulsion to violence and killing, while recognizing them as a part of our interior makeup and dealing with it. In that sense, perhaps, we are beyond societal morality which embraces both those things while denying they actually exist - the whole idea of "necessary evil" seems less feasible when we go so gleefully to executions and wars.

Song in my Heart said...

Mark,

I think we absolutely have a responsibility to take up a leadership role. But I don't know that thinking about this problem in evolutionary terms is helpful to that; it seems to imply that people cannot be transformed, that people won't change their behaviour. Transformation and change may indeed be rare but I do believe they can happen. I believe that partly because of my own experiences.

When I am confronted with people who are so fearful and disconnected that they intentionally harm others my main reaction is along the lines of "There, but for the grace of God, go I." Many of my so-called superior qualities would be destructive if not for the compassion I've been shown; some of them are a direct result of having experienced abuse, and some are the direct result of having experienced love.

I feel like any measure of trying to protect myself is temporary and short-lived compared to the more important task of living life in such a way that people might be changed, trying to speak and act in ways that help others to see truth and know love. I do attempt to practise that in my daily life: these are not just the lazy words of good intent that are so easy to put on the internet. It isn't easy and I do make mistakes but I am trying.

I don't deny that there is a serious problem, but I don't see any other way to make headway with it. Intellectual arguments are not going to conquer fear. Force is not going to conquer hate. Damage limitation is necessary but it is not enough.

What are your suggestions?

MarkBrunson said...

If you feel it is unhelpful to discuss it evolutionary terms, then please feel free not to. However, if it is the truth, not discussing it won't help.

If what you believe to be your superior qualities would become destructive, then those are not your superior qualities, among which is the compassion. Compassion may be misused, however, as justification for inaction.

The important thing, I believe, is to take away the ability of those stirring up the fear and hatred and reinforcing that worldview. If that cannot be done, then separation from the main group to let them destroy only themselves may be the only option, if we wish to survive.

In truth, I don't believe that their basic worldview can be changed. We can only soothe them and lead, or, if prevented by those preaching entropy, leave them to their own carnage.

Song in my Heart said...

However, if it is the truth, not discussing it won't help.


Hence my willingness to comment here.

If what you believe to be your superior qualities would become destructive, then those are not your superior qualities, among which is the compassion. Compassion may be misused, however, as justification for inaction.

So what is the difference between your evolutionarily-advanced superior beings and a grunt like me who just tries to do what is right? Am I to be condemned along with the Cro-Magnons because I try and sometimes fail? Is the change I feel I have experienced some grand error of perception on my part?

I do not think that I use compassion as a justification for inaction. More often than not it is compassion that stirs me to action.

The important thing, I believe, is to take away the ability of those stirring up the fear and hatred and reinforcing that worldview.

How do you propose to do this?

If that cannot be done, then separation from the main group to let them destroy only themselves may be the only option, if we wish to survive.

I don't think we are given that option. Interconnectedness doesn't go away just because we don't like it; we share a physical environment with people who would destroy the world. There isn't an escape hatch. How would you separate "us" (whoever you deem that to be) from the consequences of the actions of "them"?

In truth, I don't believe that their basic worldview can be changed.

I do. And I don't think there's much hope for any of us if it can't.

That isn't to say I think everyone will magically change overnight or that such change is easy or that I, personally, can reach everyone I try to, or even that I get to see the evidence of my efforts. But as someone who has been changed, as someone who has grown, I testify that it can happen.

Revd. Neal Terry said...

If that cannot be done, then separation from the main group to let them destroy only themselves may be the only option, if we wish to survive. Mark, you have already read Odd John, or you should do!

'Superior' is not amoral, is relativistic, and in your argument theoretically presented but practically excused.

You posit that 'if that cannot be done' then there is only one option. First, it is being done, and continues to be done by people like you and I who take the battle forward whatever the personal heartache and cost...and second there is nowhere to withdraw to. Their carnage would also become yours.

MarkBrunson said...

So what is the difference between your evolutionarily-advanced superior beings and a grunt like me who just tries to do what is right? Am I to be condemned along with the Cro-Magnons because I try and sometimes fail? Is the change I feel I have experienced some grand error of perception on my part?

I think you believe I'm using Cro-Magnon as a pejorative. I'm not. The people we're talking about here, the ones who seem incapable of rising above fear and selfishness are homo sapiens, just as are we, unless science is able to actually make an evolutionary classification. I present all this as my theory, not as fact!

You are not an accident. You are a miracle, just as all evolution is. You know, as I do, that there are many, many others who've been through experiences and conditions similar to yours who have not embraced either compassion or a greater communal vision. That . . . is no accident.

And I do wish you'd stop reading into me some nefarious purpose with words like "Am I to be condemned along with the Cro-Magnons . . . " - I find it very frustrating, because I've tried very hard to show that what I'm saying can be used to condemn and dehumanize, and that's not what I'm trying to do. Each of us is in this world because God wants us to be here.
It is patently obvious, however, that some are unable embrace anything more than a parochial vision - UNABLE, not unwilling. Add to this that there are very clever people who see no further than their own pocketbooks or sense of power who manipulate this fear callously. This is that force of entropy, of tendency to chaos and disintegration. Whether its a conscious evil or simply endemic to the more aggressive urges of the human psyche - mine, yours and ours included - I can't say.

How do you propose to do this?

Well, I don't know. If I'm just in it alone, I would say what I'm positing has very little value and will simply fade and die. If not, there are far brighter people than I who can figure that out with us.

Interconnectedness doesn't go away just because we don't like it; we share a physical environment with people who would destroy the world.

Then, we must either stop them or prepare to die. Survival is not a lead-pipe cinch, as I'm sure you're aware. Destruction of Humanity, though, won't mean destruction of the world. God created one once, He can create another.

The problem is, some of us seem to be able to see the insanity of this destruction, and others simply cannot. Remember the M.A.D. "deterrent?"

Separating ourselves from them will not save the world, true, but can give us some peace before death. All that we have now is constant conflict.

MarkBrunson said...

'Superior' is not amoral, is relativistic, and in your argument theoretically presented but practically excused.

Please unpack this for me. I'm not very bright, I'm afraid!

If what I'm doing here is merely an exercise in self-justification and self-excuse, then I need to stop, but it is difficult for anyone to see one's own view objectively. It's like trying to take a snapshot of the universe.

First, it is being done, and continues to be done by people like you and I who take the battle forward whatever the personal heartache and cost...

Yes, but will it be done in time?

. . and second there is nowhere to withdraw to. Their carnage would also become yours.

Withdraw was a bad word. Detach might be better. Think of it as a spiritual practice, composing the death haiku, writing the will, working through the stages of grief, that sort of thing.

MarkBrunson said...

It occurred to me that the "town hall meeting" about health care is a perfect example, particularly the one in which Barney Frank gave his tart answer to a woman gabbling about "nazi policy."

Several of us said, "But he didn't explain to her! If he'd just explain, he could've reached her!"

This . . . is absolutely wrong. His response was the correct one. The more subjectively offensive, but also correct one, would've been to tell her that she had no understanding of this, that she was letting hysteria carry her away, and to go take a time out while more enlightened minds discussed it. His way treated her like an adult and assumed that she had enough intelligence to be ashamed, humiliated by calling her on her behavior.

Explaining would never have reached a mind like that, because it had been preyed upon and worked up to a level of delusional hysteria by sound bites about "death panels" and "socialism." In that state, she and those like her lose all ability to discern, to think in terms beyond self-preservation and phobias.

Look at the people like her in the meetings: they are truly anguished, deeply afraid, because they don't have the wherewithal to comprehend what they are told and what is real. The problem isn't those people, who work, love and suffer just like us, or even the lack of awareness and communal concern that they have not been capable of developing - it is in those who manipulate and deceive them. Compare their anguish to the smooth, polished smugness of those politicians and media moguls making the pitches to them. We see it clearly. They can't. The problem is in those manipulators who, far from clever or intelligent, are merely cunning. Given the consciousness-level of those they prey upon, they may be directly compared to serial child molesters.

Song in my Heart said...

Mark,

You know, as I do, that there are many, many others who've been through experiences and conditions similar to yours who have not embraced either compassion or a greater communal vision.

I would add the word "yet" to the end of that sentence.

And I do wish you'd stop reading into me some nefarious purpose with words like "Am I to be condemned along with the Cro-Magnons . . . " - I find it very frustrating, because I've tried very hard to show that what I'm saying can be used to condemn and dehumanize, and that's not what I'm trying to do.

I'm sorry if I've been unclear.

To me, assuming that a large portion of humanity is incapable of change is a condemnation. Assuming that those who have not yet changed will destroy themselves and us before even trying to change is a condemnation. And given how easily I could still be lumped in with that group I tend to get rather defensive about it.

It is patently obvious, however, that some are unable embrace anything more than a parochial vision - UNABLE, not unwilling.

How can you tell? I mean, it's possible, reasonable, even likely, but I'd say this is still very theoretical. And even if some can change and some cannot, how can you tell the difference? That is a major practical barrier to any sort of imposed disempowerment.

As a society we already attempt to limit the power of those who would do harm. We have courts, prisons, fines, and some semblance of a rule of law. I don't think that the systems we use are perfect and I know that they are in need of reform... but they do exist. And I don't think they are solving the problem you set, or the problems they are designed to solve. That said, I haven't worked closely with anyone involved in the criminal justice system, and I know the media bias runs to telling us how horrible things are rather than the less "newsworthy" stories of lives turned around. So maybe even there, good work is happening and we don't even realise it.

Destruction of Humanity, though, won't mean destruction of the world. God created one once, He can create another.

I live in this world. I work and play and cry and laugh and love in this world. Trying to love this world, trying to spread God's love in this world, is what I am for. Nothing is expendable, nothing is excluded from that, not a person or a country or a universe or a beetle or the leaf it eats. Other worlds may theoretically exist but I have no experience of them and my eggs are, necessarily, all in this one basket.

Separating ourselves from them will not save the world, true, but can give us some peace before death.

Speaking for myself, I don't think I would be at peace with having given up. I have to keep trying.

I can detach myself from the results--I can try in the knowledge that I might fail, I can love in the knowledge that even if I do reach people it may never be apparent or obvious to me--but if I decide not to try then I may as well go right back to only thinking of my own pain and fear and letting my life collapse in on itself in an ever-tightening spiral as I try to avoid discomfort.

MarkBrunson said...

I live in this world. I work and play and cry and laugh and love in this world. Trying to love this world, trying to spread God's love in this world, is what I am for. Nothing is expendable, nothing is excluded from that, not a person or a country or a universe or a beetle or the leaf it eats. Other worlds may theoretically exist but I have no experience of them and my eggs are, necessarily, all in this one basket.

So?

That's you. It's not about you or me. One day, you and all that you love are going to die. This is a fact, not speculation. You speak as if destruction of humanity - which is what every individual's death amounts to - is the end. If you truly believe that, then there is a significant ground of difference in approach, as I don't believe anything ends or is lost.

Speaking for myself, I don't think I would be at peace with having given up. I have to keep trying.

Again - personal choice, that's you.

How can you tell? I mean, it's possible, reasonable, even likely, but I'd say this is still very theoretical.

Yes. Which I have said, I believe.

It seems the most favorable theory, though, and I've seen nothing to convince me otherwise. Simply saying "they might" is of little use when faced with what is. Love them all you want. Love is good. Harnessing love will, as Teilhard de Chardin said, be the second discovery of the making of fire. Yet, while you're waiting for them to be loved into completion, they are destroying the world you say you're so invested in.

To me, I can take or leave it. It's a beautiful world, and good, but, all that was created by God is beautiful and good, so, wherever I wind up, despite ego's fears and complaints, will be beautiful and good. But, if you want to save this world, you can't keep relying on past methods. There isn't time.

To me, assuming that a large portion of humanity is incapable of change is a condemnation. Assuming that those who have not yet changed will destroy themselves and us before even trying to change is a condemnation. And given how easily I could still be lumped in with that group I tend to get rather defensive about it.

You can't get younger. You can't escape physical death. You can't take back your past. I guess that that is condemnation, as well. If my theoretical position is correct - if, mind you - then it's as given as any of those facts. As for the other - well, Song, they aren't changing and we know that we are dying. It's lovely that you really, really believe that they will change and realize they're killing everything. I really, really don't. So, I'm not sure there's much to convince each other of, here. The important thing is we are both working toward the good of humanity, and they are simply not.

Song in my Heart said...

You speak as if destruction of humanity - which is what every individual's death amounts to - is the end. If you truly believe that, then there is a significant ground of difference in approach, as I don't believe anything ends or is lost.

Then why does it matter to you that some people are so bent on destroying the world and each other? Why write the post in the first place?

But, if you want to save this world, you can't keep relying on past methods. There isn't time.

I quite agree, though I think we might define 'past methods' differently. Historically people have tried all sorts of tricks to control one another or to protect themselves. There are very few examples of people using love to change the world. Maybe that's because it just gets out-competed by might and force, but maybe it's because we haven't given love a chance to work.

It seems the most favorable theory, though, and I've seen nothing to convince me otherwise. Simply saying "they might" is of little use when faced with what is.

Whereas the "what is" of my life is that I have seen others transformed and I have been transformed myself--imperfectly and in fits and starts, but looking back even a year I can see growth. I thought I was beyond hope, and I was wrong. I have never been so deliriously happy to be wrong in my entire life.

And that wouldn't have happened if people had all said, "Oh, her? She won't change, even if she wants to she can't. We'll just look after ourselves, try to stay comfortable and safe while the world falls apart."

I don't know how to state this in terms that will make logical sense...

I think that your premise, that people do not or cannot change, is incorrect. I think it is incorrect because I have been transformed by love. I cannot guarantee that any individual will change. I cannot guarantee that enough people will change in time for us not to destroy one another. I just know that in at least one case, lovingkindness has made a difference: and that is enough for me to hope.

MarkBrunson said...

Then why does it matter to you that some people are so bent on destroying the world and each other? Why write the post in the first place?

I don't want to get married and don't live in California. Should I not have cared or written about the Prop8 malignancy? My life isn't threatened, should I not care what happens in Sudan or Nigeria? It matters to me because others matter to me.

There are very few examples of people using love to change the world.

Which rather proves than disproves my concern about the prevalence of the other sorts.

I think that your premise, that people do not or cannot change, is incorrect.

Had that been the full point of my premise, you would be correct about that premise. My premise was that some, perhaps most, cannot change.

You still seem to be laboring under and assumption that I want "them" destroyed or subjugated. I don't. We must build a society together. As you've pointed out, the old methods have been violence and subjugation and have not worked - which, if you'll look back, is basically the same thing I've said.

I'm sorry this post has been such a trial for you. I see that it has stirred deep and profound distress for you, but I certainly don't want gulags or concentration camps, nor a society of "under-dwellers" who work to support the elite.

My hypothesis is simply based on observation, just as is yours; my observation is that, increasingly, people do change. At the same time, many more do not, will not, and, say themselves, cannot under the most ideal conditions. The ability to that change is the difference.

Again, not being aware of this is what allows manipulation the unscrupulous and short-sighted.

Song in my Heart said...


Had that been the full point of my premise, you would be correct about that premise. My premise was that some, perhaps most, cannot change.


I do not think you have enough supporting evidence for this premise to use it as the basis for action.

I also do not think that the opposite premise--that everyone can and will change--is a suitable premise to use as the basis for action.

I wholeheartedly agree that many (though not all) people do not change but I don't think this is the same as cannot.

We must build a society together.

Agreed, again--but I do not see how it will be possible to build a society together while also assuming that much of the world is incapable of doing better, incapable of loving their neighbour... trying to protect "us" from "them".

As previously noted I don't know where the balance lies between keeping myself safe and reaching out. But I do think reaching out some of the time is necessary to build a better world, and I am aware that it will bear risks and if I think only of keeping myself safe I will probably not reach anyone.

I'm sorry this post has been such a trial for you.

I'm not!

Thank you for your patience in the face of my stubbornness.

I think we agree on most of the important issues. But there is a difference between accepting the reality that many people don't change and extrapolating that to asserting that they cannot. I do find that distressing, partly because of my own experiences and knowing the difference to me when someone else believed in me. It distresses me because although I can see I have changed, I also believe I have a very long way to go: I am still learning what it is to be human, I am still learning what it is to be compassionate, and I hope I will continue to learn for the rest of my life here. But I think it also distresses me because it denies hope to those who may appear static or may be stuck, and draws a sort of arbitrary line in the sand in a way that I'm not sure humans are qualified to do.

I happen to believe (in a sort of "hoping in great faith" way) that God draws all to Godself in the end, though not necessarily on this planet and in this life. I believe in universal salvation, limitless mercy, unconditional love.

I cannot comment on the mechanics of this and, as previously discussed, I care about this world and the people in it, and I only have data from this world to work with. And I am committed to trying to make this world better.

It would be madness, to my mind, to act as though all people will change or become more compassionate or undergo some sort of transformation during my lifetime. I recognise that we must act as if things and people won't change much; we must take concrete steps to protect ourselves from concrete dangers if we want to continue living in the concrete world long enough to make it better.

But to me it feels like a sort of dereliction of duty, a rejection of the universality of God's love, to treat anyone as if they cannot change, to say any person or group of people is beyond grace.

MarkBrunson said...

Song, at least, if you're gonna get offended, get offended by what I actually said.

But to me it feels like a sort of dereliction of duty, a rejection of the universality of God's love, to treat anyone as if they cannot change, to say any person or group of people is beyond grace.

I. Have. Not. Said. That.

Okay?

I don't know how to make this any clearer. I am not condemning these people, and, frankly, am tired of repeating that.

First, I'm not talking metaphysical problems here, but the difficulties in this world on a secular, observable level. What God chooses to do with them is up to Him. While it is true I try to guide myself by Christian principal, I'm not asking the eternal verities here. It's not a theological point.

I - personally - accept reincarnation as a very real possibility. I can't say I believe in it, but I think it very possible, so nothing is lost. There's as far as am willing to commit to a judgment on the afterlife and the nature of any individual soul. It's not the Church's position, it's not most of my fellow Christians' position, it's mine.

However, if we're to comment on the nature of God's interaction with humanity, I think it equally a dereliction of duty to assume that justice is divorced from Grace in this world. You seem to want to treat this world as if it were already transformed, and it isn't. If you want some spiritual justification for my point of view -

If anyone will not welcome you or listen to your words, shake the dust off your feet when you leave that home or town. - Matthew 10:14

Do not suppose that I have come to bring peace to the earth. I did not come to bring peace, but a sword. - Matthew 10:34

He has blinded their eyes and deadened their hearts, so they can neither see with their eyes, nor understand with their hearts, nor turn—and I would heal them. - John 12:40

Now, see, I'm not talking about bringing a "sword" in the sense of violence. I believe that a sword cuts truth from delusion. But, it's still true, still very obvious, that many, or most, cannot change. Sorry, I know you don't like that, but it's true. Look at the last eight years. Look at Prop8. Look at the healthcare debate. For God's sake, look at television! It's not the fault of those who are like that. There's nothing the matter with their being like that - it is those who callously manipulate them.

The other answer is that they are just sons-of-bitches who don't want to change, and be damned to 'em anyway.

They may change, as I noted in questioning the difference between a purely physical and a mental evolution, they can certainly live with us in peace, but - sorry, but this is how I see it - all this touchy/feely garbage is not ever going to help, largely because it's hiding from reality.

Note the link Doxy sent. It's not conclusive, and I'm not trying to present a new gospel, but it is suggestive.

Song in my Heart said...

I'm more baffled than offended, honestly.

... I think perhaps we have very different ideas about the manifestation of grace. Mine is not limited to something that might happen after this life, and so your repeated assertions that there is no hope of change in this life (for some people) seem like a denial of the possibility of grace, a prediction of how far God is willing to go--especially when applied to specific people or groups. To me, there is a big difference between "we may as well act as if some people can't change, since we don't know when or how they will" and "some people are incapable of change" -- even if the functional response to both is indistinguishable at this point.

Take away distinctions like time and I think we are on much the same page.

However, if we're to comment on the nature of God's interaction with humanity, I think it equally a dereliction of duty to assume that justice is divorced from Grace in this world. You seem to want to treat this world as if it were already transformed, and it isn't.

Not quite. I take the view that judgement is not the prerogative of humans. I certainly don't think that means we don't need to do damage limitation, as I think I've said (in one way or another) several times in these comments. And that does mean we need to think about what a just society would look like, and work to bring that about.

sorry, but this is how I see it - all this touchy/feely garbage is not ever going to help, largely because it's hiding from reality.

I think it can help when it is the basis of loving action in the world. I don't think it is always an avoidance of reality to attempt to bring love to a situation. I would almost certainly not be alive today otherwise; I was rescued because of what you seem to classify as "touchy/feely garbage". When I talk about loving the world I am not talking about putting on rose-tinted glasses and running from the problems. The sort of love I am writing of brings at least as much sorrow as joy, and very often compels me to action.

MarkBrunson said...

Okay, last attempt.

It's not about theology.

It's not about what happened to or benefited you.

It's about what seems obvious to me. There is no moral judgment involved. A child is largely a vicious and amoral creature until that better part of them is trained up. If the child can't be trained to that, it's not a bad child, just a child that has different needs and from which society needs more or less protection.

I don't believe Grace is limited to another world either. But, that is irrelevant because this isn't about theology. The eternal soul is not the issue, here. I think it would however, as a Christian, be incredibly arrogant to infer that "grace" means that someone will inevitably come to share my point of view.

That's as simply as I can explain it.

Some people can overcome personal fear to embrace a larger societal view and matrix, some people cannot, and other people, whose view tends toward a selfish/chaotic view, manipulate those who cannot.

Song in my Heart said...

What seems obvious to you is at direct odds with what I think has happened (and continues to happen) to me.

In trying to reconcile the two I question whether what seems obvious to you is really accurate, and I question whether I correctly understand my own experience.

Theology may not be relevant to what seems obvious to you but it is important to my understanding of my own experience.

I think it would however, as a Christian, be incredibly arrogant to infer that "grace" means that someone will inevitably come to share my point of view.

Fair enough, though I didn't say that, and am saddened that my words may have implied it.

But then it's also arrogant to think that I know what "good" is at all, to think that I could possibly discern right action. But in the real world I have to choose something (and yes, even doing nothing is a choice).

I do the best I can, even while knowing that I will never have enough information to do the right thing every time.

---

Mark, thanks again for your kind patience in this discussion. I am, at best, a difficult student.

I'm sorry if what I have said has caused you distress and frustration; it has not been my intention to bring any pain or to say anything hurtful. I suspect we have been talking at cross-purposes much of the time, in large part due to my own defensiveness and my lack of skill with language. I'd love to figure out what exactly it is that I don't understand, but this discussion is not the place for it.

I will continue to mull over what you have said. But quietly.

David G. said...

He Died For "EVERYONE"!!!

David G. said...

Satan, works much like God does,..in mysterious ways.

You Know and I know, ...that what Granny said 50 years ago doesn't apply to NOW???

But still the INCOMPETENCE!!!

J Kempf said...

When did anyone say that Jesus did not die for everyone? I'm really curious about that. Such statements about this post make no damn sense. What is being said here is that some people are ruled by fear; fear of change; fear that they may not get theirs; fear of others; fear of authority; fear of everything. Strangely enough, science has shown that those people who are more fearful and anxious strong lean towards conservative politics. Those who are not ruled by fear strongly lean towards liberal politics, which includes taking care of others, especially those less fortunate, putting the needs of others before your own, and being your brother's keeper. Last time I checked, Jesus was for all of those things.

Science also shows that those ruled by fear are extremely unlikely to change. It is not really about what they believe, but about how their brain works. It has become fundamental to their perception of self and the world. How that came about, either through nature or nurture, I cannot say.

More evolved does not mean better, what is means is "changed more". That is all evolution is, change. What is being argued is what is at stake in discussions of politics, faith, or whatever else, is whether humankind takes the path of fear, or takes the path of compassion.

Religion was not really part of the argument presented, though I feel that it is a pretty safe bet that Jesus is pro-compassion.

Also, what is being said here is that compassion is better than fear, ergo those who are compassionate are better than those who are fearful. I can go with that statement as well. Compassion is better, and I believe that compassionate people are better people and closer to God than those who are afraid of the world around them.

Is this pride? Maybe. Hubris? Definitely not. There is nothing wrong with acknowledging that you are better than certain people. I believe myself to be a better person than a anti-abortion activist who bombs a doctor at his home in the name of God. I feel very confident of that statement.

Am I better than those people who would spread lies rather than see people less fortunate than them get healthcare, for fear that they would somehow lose out on their own care? Yes, I believe I am. People have a real need for healthcare and I feel as though it is my duty to see that they are provided for. I believe that God wants us to take care of one another, and healthcare is a part of that.

Now, at no point did I say that anyone should be hurt, or that anyone should be ground under my liberal bootheel, or that God did not love anyone. What I am saying is that some people are ruled by love, while others are ruled by fear, and since God is love, the people who are ruled by love are ruled by God. There is nothing wrong with acknowledging that.

So, love people, even those who are are ruled by fear, just don't expect them to care, and don't expect them to change.

MarkBrunson said...

brian - or brad - or fred- or at,

If you have anything substantive to contribute to the conversation, I'll consider publishing it, but simply rattling on about inaccuracy without even anecdotal evidence, as well as attacks on me personally based on your subjective emotional reaction are not part of this conversation. I struggled with posting it as evidence of my thesis, but decided it would merely smear muck on an otherwise useful conversation. I've saved it so that, when you are forgotten here, I can use it as an anonymous evidence of the inability of some to grasp anything outside an animalistic tendency to mere selfishness.

God go with you.

MarkBrunson said...

Song,

If I've been patient, it's because others were first patient with me.

I'm not trying to posit "what is good," rather point up what is bad. Perhaps the ability of the entropically-biased people to cause damage would be considerably reduced if their pay and power were reduced. I don't propose - insofar as I'd propose anything - a corresponding "power grab" by a liberal cabal. Indeed, I've seen liberals who are just as capable of rabble-rousing as any conservative, though the conservative message makes such manipulation easier. It's a bit hard to say, "I command you to think freely!" :)

Before the jadedness of the post-Nixon era, I think the liberal rabble rousers really reached their height. Let's be honest, Abbie Hoffman, Timothy Leary, Baghwan Sri Rajneesh(sic), the Weather Underground were really about personal power, personal goals, and personal pleasure.

MarkBrunson said...

themethatisme,

I've read the plot outline for Odd John and it sounds both disturbing and fascinating.

Once I've finished with my current obsession over the game Destroy All Humans!2 (do keep in mind I never really claimed myself as one of the higher evolutionary expression!) I'll have more time to read and will try to find a copy.

MarkBrunson said...

James,

Thank you, though I suspect you are biased! :D

MarkBrunson said...

David,

About four o'clock, but I don't think I'm gonna make it to the party.

J Kempf said...

I probably do have a bias, but only because you and I have spent many late nights over coffee pondering over our random thoughts.

Remember Star Trek?

Unknown said...

I don't hate anybody.
What I was trying to say was that a lot of people in mainline churches are wondering what to do now that their churches (indeed all protestant churches)have become a minority (the Pew Forum did a study on this a few years ago; I believe Newsweek quoted it)aren't in the majority anymore.
What do you do when you want to do something for other people-but they are angry with you and there are more of them and they're going to do the opposite of what you think is the best for themselves?
On separation, there have been numerous studies (the Barna foundation and the Ford Foundation did two)on internal immigration, e.g. white people leaving California for the Rocky Mountain states; people from greater New York moving to Vermont; people from Boston suburbs moving farther out to southern New Hampshire.
This is a form of self-segregation. I don't know if it's good, bad or indifferent, but it's been going on for awhile now, even (or especially)with people on the political left. Compare the politics of New Hampshire, for example: the south with new migrants with more education is now much more liberal than the poorer north with is still hardscrabble farms and ski resorts. There are a lot of class issues, even with people like those on the left who want to help those left behind economically like the dairy farmers.

MarkBrunson said...

brian,

Thank you for clarifying. I see from your thoughtful response, you are not the persistent troll we've had problems with in the past.

It's good you don't hate anyone. I wouldn't expect that you did.

Your concerns are valid. I don't believe I've argued that they are not. I don't recall conversing with you before, so it may be that you're operating from assumptions about me, my purpose, or my claimed level of expertise. The others who've commented here are old friends - at least as far as online folks are friends - and one real-life friend. They know me, and, honestly, that was who I expected to respond. If you are new, welcome, if not, forgive my failing memory!

I'm not a social engineer. I know enough history to know that Five Year Plans and Final Solutions bring horror, not utopia. I try to argue from compassion, and am aware that the words I'm using here are deeply connotative. I'm sorry, I can think of no better words to use, though. All I can do is ask that you separate the emotional response to the words from the words themselves.

Those who know me here also know that I tend toward the broad view. I'm simply not bright enough to come up with the detailed plans. If there is any worth in the view that I'm presenting, then it must be a cooperative effort. That's also why I've tried to avoid terms like "evil" preferring the more neutral "entropy," as the cooperative nature of the effort can lead to extreme abuse - Marx had ideas, Stalin implemented them. (To clarify, I don't subscribe to either Marxist or Stalinist philosophies, they are simply a convenient example).

Finally, most importantly, the folks who know me know that I'm presenting my ideas as my ideas - I'm willing to be persuaded otherwise. That willingness to persuasion is a part of the theoretical groundwork that is still seminal in my thought around this whole theory.

So, not a theologian, not a social scientist. What good am I? Philosopher, maybe. Though most would say that's about as useful as . . . well, it involves a bullfrog.

continued . . .

MarkBrunson said...

. . now

Your concern about "white flight" is an interesting one. Song, Erika and themethatisme have caused me to reevaluate my original thoughts on separation, realizing it was childish reactionism - "Fine! I'll take my ball and leave!" - but, I think we have to be prepared for, not separation, but, let's say, detachment. I'm saying this with full awareness of the pitfalls actuated by the hippie movements, by tuning in, turning on and dropping out. There has to be social involvement, and that compassion has to extend to those who do oppose what we're trying to do. The anger is natural, human, and expected, but, if we abandon compassion in the face of it as "expediency," or "pragmatism," or even "ruthless efficiency," then we've lost exactly that best part that ever gave us the responsibility to lead others into a better world.

Again, the problem is not those who are unwilling to move beyond what was - a bigger problem is avoiding novelty for its own sake - but those who manipulate that fear, that atavism, to their personal benefit. I can understand fear and loathing! I wasn't kidding with themethatisme when I said I wasn't sure if I were more or less evolved!

It is not, primarily, a class issue to me, though it does seem to me that those who do this dangerous manipulating are likely to be the very wealthy. At the risk of going into the religio-ethical mode, wealth tends to breed exclusive concern for the accumulation of wealth, as power does for power. I've known many people who were quite poor, poorly-educated and poorly-paid who were brilliant, flexible and dynamic thinkers and planners. I've known many wealthy people, too, who had wide-open natures and a generously-giving hand with an eye to the welfare of the whole community. Perhaps the holistic vision is what I'm talking about, as opposed to the parochial.

If you've read my "War and Peace" this far, you deserve rest, brian!

Thank you for coming back and engaging. Challenge me and my thought, and I'll try not to be a savage! :) All this may be absolute and pure grade-A horseshit, but I won't know without others.

God be with you.

MarkBrunson said...

I can say that I can no longer stand by and try to engage in rational "debate" with so-called ministers who preach the fundamentalist screed. My personal conviction as a Christian finds their dead message absolutely repugnant and death-giving, and their callous manipulation of their "flock" is a betrayal of trust so deep that it cannot be fathomed.

For me, one of the ways that I can combat the entropic movement is to publicly call out these people. I've been too soft in trying to dispute them - those they are purposefully misleading don't understand that . . . what they will understand is the wake-up call - false shepherd! false prophet! deceiver! thief in the sheep-fold!

Once the entropic spell is revealed, then we can explain why it is a nightmare, not God, but "debating" these so-called ministers is merely giving form to their miasma of fear. These "ministers" may be beyond reaching, as they have embraced this entropic direction as their life, but we can break their hold.