This is the message I've composed in response to FS's request/question.
Though I list no names, if I am going to claim the backing of others, I would like your comments and corrections on this very rough draft, which I've composed, mostly on the fly. There are parts I've felt are too soft, others too harsh, but we're never the best critic of our own work.
This has been written at the request of others, who, seeing my concerns on my blog, felt that these concerns needed to be shared with our own ecclesial leadership. Though I cannot claim to speak for a majority or even many, I believe that there are some righteous concerns to be addressed to our bishops. To that end, I am sending this letter to a few of The Episcopal Church’s bishops, in the hopes that it will generate at least some response, perhaps discussion in the larger national church, and might be shared amongst the bishops in our church.
First, let me say that many of us feel that the recent Lambeth Conference has underscored, and brought to a head, many basic problems in our church as it relates to the Anglican Communion, and as it relates to the egalitarian nature of our own church. What has now become clear is that our bishops are in an untenable position, requiring maintenance of both the unity of the Anglican Communion and the unity of the Episcopal Church. Quite simply put, this is no longer possible.
The punitive and biased words and actions of the Archbishop of Canterbury, Rowan Williams, make it clear that he has neither respect nor patience for our democratic process in the American church. To this end, he proposes a curial model for the Anglican Communion which will place The Episcopal Church under the control, however indirectly, of bodies outside our provincial polity and essentially hostile to that polity. To opt for such a curial – or, as the Archbishop would have it, “covenantal” model – would be a betrayal of The Episcopal Church and those for whom you are accountable and to whom you are accountable.
Let me explain what I mean by this accountability. We are all – by choice – members of a church that operates on a hierarchical model. To this end, it is recognized that a bishop has a particular charism and a mandate to leadership. Without this realization, we would simply be one among many republican representative models readily available in the secular world. We accept that Grace is given in an outpouring to allow this leadership function. However, this is not leadership as is envisioned in the entirely authoritarian structure of the Middle Ages, nor that provided by the models of, say, the Church of England, in which a higher political authority is entirely responsible for the appointment of such a figure. The model envisioned in The Episcopal Church and set forth clearly in the ordination service, is rather one of a leader elevated from among the people, set apart, but not above. The ordination service reiterates this in the use of expressions such as “fellow presbyters,” “your people,” and, even asking the congregation “Is it your will that we ordain . . . ?” The bishop is a leader, but in the sense of a sibling, not a parent, understood to be equally fallible and equally in need of seeking counsel, and is enjoined to seek counsel from his/her “fellow presbyters” – priests, and all are, by virtue of baptism, called to the royal priesthood. In short, this form of episcopacy is not the mere managerial model offered by other churches, but a pastoral position which requires mutual accountability and humility – a reciprocity that requires both bishop and people – a people sanctified in baptism as priests themselves - recognize their interdependence, mutual accountability and mutual fallibility, and seek one another’s counsel.
The “covenantal” model that we are seeing is anathema to this very understanding! A primatial council, with the authority to set the bar of acceptability, which requires episcopal councils to decide membership is necessarily exclusive of the laity, priesthood, and diaconate, and, as such, hostile toward our polity and our charism. If you hand off this power to direct our church to a council of those disinterested and incapable of making truly pastoral decisions, you will, in your quest for unity, sacrifice The Episcopal Church, your diocese, the very people who trusted and elevated you. You will have sold your ecclesial heritage for a mess of pottage. Even were you to lose but a handful of individuals from TEC, and, quite possibly, from the very Church of Christ itself, that will be the breaking of The Episcopal Church. As it is, you surely realize that you will lose far more than that handful, and will inevitably drive a wedge between you and the very people of The Episcopal Church. The question is a painful one for you, and I regret you have to ask it, but, simply put, will you serve the idea of the Anglican Communion, or will you serve the people to whom you vowed service, those who trusted you to lead and, more, to help them?
This Lambeth Conference has also made clear to us something which is painful to say, perhaps dangerous to say, but which must be said, clearly, lovingly, and with the voice of prophetic witness: At this conference, you have grievously wounded and failed those who were entrusted to you.
You were called, in your ordination, to “. . boldly proclaim and interpret the Gospel of Christ, enlightening minds and stirring up the conscience of your people . . .” In what way can you be said to have boldly given forth the Good News as received and interpreted by you, or The Episcopal Church, at this conference by acting the hangdog over our desire for justice and inclusion? When you left your brother bishop, Gene Robinson, outside the gates, you left out, not just gays and lesbians, but the very church you represented – all of your brothers and sisters. When you sat in silence as our vision and our understanding was reviled and misrepresented, even by the Archbishop of Canterbury himself, do you not realize that your bloodless and passionless regard for your people deprived you of the right to claim prophetic or apostolic authority? In what way did you “support all baptized people in their gifts and ministries” by downplaying the works and gifts of others, the zeal and compassion shown by those entrusted to you? How were you “merciful to all, show[ing] compassion to the poor and strangers, and defend[ing] those who have no helper” by offering the sacrifice of the marginalized in secret counsel? Your desire – however earnest and well-intentioned – of cutting off the laity, priesthood and diaconate from your deliberations and discussions were, in the end, disastrous. It allowed the media to run wild, it generated “rumors of war” that would have been humorous, were it not that each and every one has left a scar or open wound on a soul somewhere.
This is how the current situation appears to us, and, frankly, you show no signs of confiding further in us, nor of seeking counsel from us. So, the question is now how – or if – you will be faithful to your vows as bishops in this, The Episcopal Church.
I – we – thank you for your time and your consideration. Keep in mind that these things are written from wounded and yearning hearts which love you, oh, so dearly, and which wait to see if they are a part of their own church, or merely unnoticed grist in the ecclesial mill.
Your response will ring through generations to come.
Yours In Christ,
Mark ******(personal info removed on advice)
11 comments:
Mark that it a remarkable, powerful letter, well said. There is a great deal to take in and I agree with what you say. The only immediate question I have is who you are going to send it to? I ask because your charge that the bishops (and I count my own in England - what am I saying, my diocesan bishop is Rowan!) sold us down the river is not quite fairly levelled at all of them. For instance bishops Andrus, Bruno and Ely, to mention just three, do seem to have tried more than you give them credit for. As for the text I would want a little more time to think!
I think you have made your point perfectly. Don't change a thing.
Thank you, Greg.
Truthfully, I only see myself addressing the American House of Bishops. I really can't make claims to an autocephalous nature for TEC, then claim accountability from CofE bishops who, canonically, at least, are not accountable to me. That is why I made specific mention of "our polity" as opposed to those in which bishops are appointed by the state, or chosen only by clergy.
Now, MadPriest seems to believe this indicates a drive, on my part, toward isolationism. I want to clarify that that is not what I'm saying. While I believe we should give whatever assistance and support we can - and I certainly will do so for you, Greg - to those in other churches, I'm not sure we wouldn't be giving in to exactly the sort of imperialism we've been accused of if we stand outside, risking nothing, and yelling for "you over there" to become like "us over here." It is vital that CofE and other churches realize that their own members are not in synch with this "covenant" and will not agree with it.
Having said that, I realize that there is danger for CofE priests speaking out, and I can't compare the relatively minor risks I take in this. But - and this is vital - we cannot change the CofE, nor any other church from outside. The unfortunate actions of our fellow Americans will make it all too easy to dismiss us as seeking to Americanize you. Your liberalism must be a distinctly British liberalism in order for it to work. Without that, even if we could impose our will on CofE (and would we be the same people if we did?), you would've simply traded one master for another.
Realizing our relative comfort and security in TEC, though, I think we should take active and bold steps for others to speak out in other churches - create a mission, not as outpost, but to provide protection. Mark Harris has a wonderful model for a provisional communion built on such needs and common mission here, if you haven't already seen it.
Ideally, we will be one communion again, one day, but we must find a way for individual dioceses and parishes to join with us for strength, and what minor political protections and pressure we can bring.
Sorry for the long-winded answer, Greg, but I want you to understand that, though this letter looks to American bishops, I look beyond that to a wider view.
Thank you, James, for that, though I suspect you are being a bit biased! :)
BTW, Greg, that letter, having been written - again, on the fly - last Friday, I take your point about bishops who've spoken quite boldly in public about their absolute dedication to continuing justice, and intend to add a section recognizing and lauding those who've taken such steps.
I depend on you and others like me to keep me apprised, as my time on the web is so limited and there is simply to much to assimilate for one person.
For those who haven't spoken out, however, I believe the hackneyed motto "silence equals assent."
Mark, I take your point absolutely in respect of each of our churches needing to be changedd from within - as Grandmere Mimi would say, we are a communion of churches, not one single church! Having said that, I draw great strength from knowing that there are others, like yourself, working for the same thing in our communion, albeit in a different part of the vinyard. Thanks for the link to Mark Harris's proposal too. I really like what he suggests and it will be interesting to take it up over here, just to see what the reaction is.
Biased or not, this letter is obviously well thought out and something that has been on your mind and needed to get out for quite some time.
Now, stop worrying about it and send it already.
Mark, it's a good letter. It speaks what is on your mind and in your heart. You should send it.
I don't feel that I should suggest changes in the letter, except if I see mistakes in phrasing, grammar, or spelling. However, yours is well written. I see no such problems. You speak from your heart. Send the letter.
Mark, I agree with Mimi. When I first read it, I was a little troubled by the statement: "At this conference, you have grievously wounded and failed those who were entrusted to you." I think many of our bishops made heroic efforts not to do that. But, on reflection, I feel they each individually bear responsibility for a collective failure.
So I add my voice -- send the letter.
It's a very good letter, Mark. The long paragraph toward the end is a complete knockout.
There is something in your writing style, your "voice," that carries voices of the past -- classics -- within it. It's most unusual, very compelling, and quite wonderful.
The bishops need to read it, need to discuss it among themselves.
And I agree with you that the Yanks and the Brits are two different breeds. You're talking to the Yanks.
(But in deference to the Brits, let me add,
God save the Queen,
she ain't no human being, but we love her!)
As I noted to James in another thread, I am sending a letter to the Diocesan Bishop in two dioceses in each province.
It's taken longer than I expected, but that may be a good thing, as it will be harder to write off the letter as a knee-jerk reaction immediately after Lambeth, and, indeed, I have revisited and revised since.
Thank you all for your support and encouragement!
Post a Comment