Bp. Pierre Whalon has written this essay on Anglicans Online.
Now, up to this point, I've always thought of Bp. Whalon as being a wonderful combination of level-headed and inclusive, but he's wholly fallen into the trap - largely a PR trap - that was set up at Lambeth by Deng Bul: It's all those nasty queers and their supporters' fault that Christians in Muslim countries have trouble.
An astounding claim, but even more astounding that it has been bought into by otherwise intelligent and sane people.
Now, I have no doubt that that is one of many excuses used by Islamic fundamentalists to justify abominable and barbaric acts, to lower themselves to the level of animals, but to think that removing every trace of "gay" from Christianity would make a bit of difference in that is, well, naive to the point of stupidity. They won't change their violence and brutishness because they are fundamentalists, just like Christian fundamentalists who won't change because it was never about anyone or anything but them.
Which is another remarkable bit of naivete in Bp. Whalon's essay: the assumption that one could say or do anything, upon any basis, which would change the fundamentalist mindset. It won't. This is not a point of debate, but proven again and again; just look at the total rejection of 40 years' worth of psychological and biological study by the pro-Proposition-8 fundamentalists here. Then, Bp. Whalon talks about having this conversation in public and transparently. WHAT HAVE WE BEEN DOING?! Even us dumb ol' laypeople can give you solid reasons, based on our reading of Scripture and understanding of Tradition with which we arrived at our conclusions -- usually more clearly than your average theologian . . . or bishop.
These conversations have been going on very transparently and very publicly for decades! Enough, Bp. Whalon. The only people claiming that it hasn't been discussed to death and needs better justification are those who simply say, "Nope. Uh-uh! Don't believe it!" What gobsmacked me was Bp. Whalon's dismissal of psychology and biology!
WHAT?!
What the devil - and I mean DEVIL - is going on in a mind like that? Has our episcopacy really been this infected by some contagious madness from the Reasserters? Has some evil force been given sway over our leadership? Or, is it just not PC enough, not media-friendly enough to say, out loud, "We sympathize with the problems in Sudan, etc., but we have a flock to care for here, as well, regardless of how white or middle-class they may be and we will live up to those committments?"
So, I've emailed Bp. Whalon, sent him a copy of my letter, and explained that I await his answer -- as do the people who may read my blog.
1 comment:
The thing is that while the rest of us had a listening process... decades ago... our sorry ass bishops were totally ignoring it. NOW, now that it's the final hour, now that they've got nowhere left to hide, going on forty years later, NOW they want to have a listening process.
Well, just personally, I've already heard every stupid, narrow-minded, twisted right out of the mouth of Satan thing that can be uttered. So, I'm not listening anymore. I'm not talking and I'm not listening. I'm just plain sick.
I used to think Bp. Whalon was reasonable. But stuff like this makes me wonder... I mean, did he think this through AT ALL?! It just defies belief that this is an educated Anglican.
Post a Comment