Wednesday, August 20, 2008

An Answer

Dear Mr Brunson,


Thank you very much for your note. I am sorry that I have disappointed you.


As you know, The Episcopal Church has not justified our position in any official statement. The traditional teaching on sex in marriage, for instance, remains unchanged. There are no official rites of same-sex blessings, which means there is no official teaching concerning them. The HOB has never discussed homosexuality in any theological form, other than the reactionary meeting of Port St. Lucie 1977. Each diocese has its own policy, as you know, which means of course that gay clergy cannot exercise ministry in certain areas. Which is ridiculous--who am I as bishop to have "my policy" on such an important matter? And yet I get letters routinely, asking what it is. (Answer: I want only good priests, come whence they may, be who they are.)


The point I am trying to make is that there needs to be a willingness from the whole Communion to find a way forward, or else we will simply be flinging slogans at each other for the next 100 years. Part of that work starts at home, and we need to do it with regard to our own context first. Much of it needs to be done elsewhere, beginning with the Archbishop of Canterbury. But the overall perspective must be global, if indeed justice for gay people is to be had. Furthermore, there needs to be more than mere justice--there needs to be love, as we have been commanded.


Perhaps we will simply stay where we are as a Communion--with justice for none and even less love. But that is unacceptable, for all kinds of reasons, and I intend to continue to speak out as I have been doing.


With respect to the open letter to the House of Bishops, I can assure you that none of your bishops wishes to act outside our polity--except those wishing to affiliate with other provinces, of course.


With gratitude for your efforts,


Yours in Christ,


Pierre Whalon






Le 20 août 08 à 06:12, Mark Brunson a écrit :


Rt. Reverend, Sir,

It was with *profoundest* disappointment that I read your recent essay entitled 'On Polygamy, Homosexuality, and Generosity' published on Anglicans Online Essays.

I'm a celibate homosexual, sir, and I simply cannot comprehend what it is you think you are doing - all of you in the episcopacy - to your homosexual brothers and sisters in Christ. I'm celibate by choice and *by gift*, sir, not by some misguided notion of 'generosity,' because it was God's generosity that gave us our sexuality. It was God's choice, as well, that non-celibate gays be called to the ordained clergy . . . unless you are willing to state, publicly, that our discernment to the ordained clergy is so fatally flawed that it would completely override God's Will in the whole affair.

In short, Rt. Reverend sir, I would like to know, frankly and fully, where the generosity lay in the moratorium on ordination of gays. It seems to be the bishops calling for this, and, I want to know, just what it is YOU are being so generous with. What do you lose? Will you renounce your orders in solidarity with your gay brethren? Will you become more active - dare we use the word 'bold' - in promoting this equality? What will you risk, sir? Where is *your* generosity in all this?

What I see, and what most of us are seeing, right now, is a group of privileged and pastorally-distant people laying burdens on gays and gay-supportive clergy and laypeople until they break! Yes, sir, this is what you are doing.

Do you honestly think that the people we're talking about will accept *any* theologicaly justification, regardless of Scriptural reference? You're right, it has been justified Scripturally -- and very publicly, and very transparently and we have been ignored, dismissed, vilified. You want justification? You want an understanding of theology? Ask the people in the pews who really live this. Stop excluding the gay people you talk about and claiming its someone else's fault. Be a leader, sir, or simply admit we queers don't matter to you.

I have attached a copy of a letter I've sent to several members of our House of Bishops, and I would like you to read it. We've done you the courtesy of hearing you out, and I would ask you do the same.

I await, as will those who see this letter on my blog, your reply.

Yours In Christ,

Mark Brunson


Here is Bp. Whalon's answer to my first email. He has since answered a second.

What I hear is a sensible, decent man with a complete disconnect.

He is working very hard to relocate some thousands of Iraqi refugees in France, after the US refused them. He is concerned with us (and, by the way, though I included my email on the letter, he's the only bishop that's responded to me) and our struggle. No doubt, he is "in the trenches," involved in a massive and dramatic undertaking.

And that's the point.

Massive and dramatic undertakings are just as outside the reality of TEC's day-to-day life as lived in its laypeople and parish clergy as the assertion that bishops can't be asked to make an either/or decision. The real world isn't divided into those who need help and those who don't . . . we all need help, and when we need it, all help is desperately needed. We don't have victims and saviors, we're all victims and helping one another. What this disconnect ignores is that the desperate person running and hiding for their life in the Sudan or Iraq cannot receive the help they need if the people they are looking to don't feel secure themselves -- if we feel our lives don't matter, our opinion doesn't matter, then why would we feel our help matters? There's also the reality that we are fallible human beings, and it's very hard to work up compassion and sympathy for those who, in turn, show none. This is the disconnect. Our bishops seem to live in a Platonic world, surrounded by ideals, rather than recognizing the world around them -- a world that is about to really shock them.

Here's the thing, are we wealthier, per capita, than people elsewhere? Yes. But we don't live elsewhere . . . we Americans, we Westerners, live here. We aren't wealthy here, where we really live, and that's the reality. Are we in constant danger of having our houses pulled down, or the government coming in and shooting us or dispossessing us because of our sexuality or religion? No. Yet we wouldn't be able to survive those hardships, because they are not our reality, and our reality is that we are just as devastated when we lose our friendships, family, jobs, voice . . . group humanity. Poverty is poverty and loss of humanity is loss of humanity. And loss of life. How many of my friends or acquaintances have I seen who, having heard time and again they are sinful beasts or their pain just isn't that important, have lost hope and lived for drugs, parties, sex and wound up dead, or worse? One would be too many.

You can't save the World, but you can save one person, and they another and another. But no one will be saved if that first. one. person. is not saved, however petty their concerns may seem in light of others. If this communion is really about relationality, then that's the lesson we have to learn. One to one is the only real relationality.

1 comment:

fs said...

Wow, this is great, Mark! Bishop Whalon responded with great honesty and openness to your letter; he took your thoughts very seriously. I'm so glad you wrote it and got such a thoughtful reply. You're putting one of your greatest strengths -- writing -- to good use in the world. Congratulations! I'm proud of you.

Also, I agree completely with your thoughts at the end of your post. Yes, all people feel pain and discouragement, and the world is most certainly not divided into victims and saviors, but somehow we Christians try to see it that way. If we listened better to Jesus, we'd know that everyone deserves compassion. Life may be a pleasure and a joy at times, but it sure ain't easy for most of us, whether we're givers or takers.

I'm sorry I don't get around much in the blogosphere, because there's so much going on, as your blog attests. Am a bit too tired to read more but will try to get back here tomorrow and catch up. Hope all's been generally with well with you, Mark.

Again, congratulations on a great letter that seemed to touch a chord.