Saturday, May 26, 2007

Clumber Made Me Think About This

At Pentecost, the idea of glossolalia, or "speaking in tongues" comes up. Some particularly fundamentalist mindsets say that Pentecost is proof of speaking in tongues as a sign of holiness.

I call bullshit, excuse the expression.

In the Deep South, here, I've had occasion to witness several instances of speaking in tongues, and it's largely meaningless gibberish "Blablabla lalalalalala" is not uncommon. It's baby noises.
At Pentecost, the Disciples were given the gift of existing languages to bring the Gospel to the international makeup of a city poised at the crossroads of a world empire. It wasn't meaningless noise, and, if it had been, it's unlikely that it would have impressed - let alone converted - anybody. That's why Paul enjoined that no one speak in tongues - even "tongues of angels" - unless there was someone to translate. Like all worship, speaking in tongues is not a sign of personal holiness, but something to build up a holy body.

6 comments:

Anonymous said...

woof! well said!

Edward said...

My only first-hand experience with this comes from the Ethiopian charismatic congregation that uses my church's facilities. When they all get going it's mind-boggling and even a bit scary. I'm not sure I'd call it bullshit exactly, but I sure don't get it.

As I mentioned somewhere else, L.A., where I live, is one of those cultural crossroads, where on a given day you're likely to hear any number of languages. To me, the significant part of the Pentecost story is not so much the "speaking in tongues" per se as that everyone heard and understood which has implications beyond language.

MarkBrunson said...

I've seen two different kinds, really -- one is the babyspeak, which is rather comical to me, I'm sorry to say. The other is sort of a frenzied, ecstatic thing, which is, as you say, Ed, scary. I'd be more moved by it if I hadn't seen similar things in a few voodoo ceremonies (yes, being serious, and if you're interested, I'll tell sometime).

Edward said...

Actually, I would be curious to hear about the voodoo experience. After I left my comment, I started thinking that my Ethiopians are probably in part doing a cultural thing (not voodoo, of course, but I'm sure you follow my reasoning).

MarkBrunson said...

Ed,

I'm sorry to have gotten sidetracked and ignored your request.

In areas of the Deep South, a type of voodoo is still practiced, often by "good christians," called Obeah (also Voudoun in the former French colonies). Another sort, called Santeria is making headway because of Cuban immigration, but Obeah is the sort associated with Haiti, New Orleans, etc.
I've had acquaintances who practice and who've invited me, knowing my curiosity, to witness a ceremony. I was surprised that there is tradition of practitioners being "ridden" (we'd say posessed) by loa (gods) and speaking in tongues of loa. The preparation to this is generally a great deal of frenetic and emotionally-charged dancing and chanting, which, frankly, reminded me a great deal of what I'd seen in Pentecostal churches, and the loa speech was generally neither in English nor the Yoruba dialect (the saints of Obeah and Santeria are merely syncretised representations of the Yoruba gods)but an incomprehensible tongue. The difference between the Obeah ceremony and Pentecostalism was that I was told the loa do often speak comprehensibly and give sound advice and warning.

Edward said...

Fascinating! Thanks for the additional info.