One of the things I hear, and have heard repeatedly, from reasserters is the need for a more fundamentalist type of worship. I've heard this on BNet, from various reasserter blogs, etc. There is the story of the Florida church in which certain elements wanted a "Can I get a AMEN!" type preacher, getting the vestry to oust the priest and replace him with the (unordained) youth minister. There are complaints that reasserters should be able to take "their" church when they leave. On Beliefnet, one reasserter complains constantly of our rigidity in worship and implies that, because our music reflects a solemn liturgical mood, rather than a frenetic, free-form worship style, we are racist.
Why did these people join a church that is hierarchical and liturgical. Why not be Baptist, or Pentecostal, or whatever? Why not start your own congregationalist sect and dress up and play liturgy, if you find it so important, and the rest so disposable.
What makes your personal preference so important?
5 comments:
I think, especially here in the South, there are a lot of folks from a fundamentalist background who join TEC because it offers something different than the same old, same old Southern Baptist service. Then, however, intentionally or inadvertently they set about making it more and more like what they are used to.
Personally, I love the traditional Episcopal liturgy, hymns, etc. I don't like when churches tinker with that because it's what brings me closer to God. It is beautiful and comforting to me. I'm open minded enough to accept new forms of worship, but I don't want the fundamentalist theology to creep in along with it.
More "charismatic" services, IMHO, are believed by some to be "worship" because they elicit an emotional response, which, of course, is not necessarily a bad thing, unless it is the goal.
The reason I have grown to love liturgical worship, and am often times moved by it, is because it causes us, by its word and form, to remember that true worship really has very little to do with us and our wants and everything to do with God.
Kevin:
Keeping in mind your comment, "which, of course, is not necessarily a bad thing," I'm recalling a comment once made by a theology prof at seminary who referred to all this as "masturbatory religion." Not wishing to be so in-your-face, I usually use the expression, "feel good religion" and did so in my comment at Clumber's.
I've had friends who've been through this and honestly confessed that they were acting out what was expected of them at the moment... at least in the beginning - until they began to get addicted to the good feel and then entered into that place quite willingly.
Mark:
Hard to know what to make of all this. Like you, I tend to be skeptical. But I'm not one to dismiss all non-rational experiences. I've had some "experiences" of my own (definitely not glossalalia but certainly what the secular world might call "paranormal"), so I try to remain open-minded about it.
What really disturbs me is the often-accompanying attitude of: "I've got something which you don't have, and I'm a better Christian than you because of it." Sounds like heresy to me.
Well, I don't want it to be thought that I am calling anyone's religious conviction bullshit, but, rather, the argument that glossalalia as practiced in modern Pentecostalism is somehow biblically-based. There's simply no evidence of that, and seems no more than a way, as you've said, David, to appear "more holy" than other Christians. Sort of, "Daddy loves me best!"
Mark, that was my parish in Florida. Fortunately, the fundamentalists did not oust the priest. Rather, the vestry fired Brother Amen and invited the fundamentalists to go someplace they might feel more comfortable.
Post a Comment