Friday, May 4, 2007

In a Rare Serious Development . . .

I've been thinking that we ought to let the conservatives continue on their path without interference or mockery. We in the progressive side of Christianity need to remember that the concept that something standing or falling on merit of being of-, or not-of-God doesn't simply apply to us. Perhaps, God is expanding to make a place for those not able to keep up with us.

That doesn't mean though, that we can afford to hand over property to said conservatives. What they have never really understood, I think, is that we don't consider them merely "meanies" or "backwards" -- we progressives see them as causing active harm, often because we've been on the receiving end of that harm. The narrow conservative view -- that espoused publicly by the great talking-heads of the conservative side -- is exactly what led me, even in childhood, to regard religion as irrelevant, even harmful. Such a conservative religion would've driven me to regard God as either monster or fable, if He hadn't, by His Grace, kept me aware of His Presence and Love. It was that "orthodoxy" that drove me from religious faith, and convinced me that I could never be a Christian, and must hide from God's Love. This conservatism is poison to some souls. It was only a liberal Christianity which helped me to integrate my sexuality, exercise it responsibly, and realize my personal limitations as to misuse of sexuality. Outside of that, I had been lost. With only a conservative Christianity to turn to, I would've been lost. It is this, as well as actual physical and emotional harm we progressives cannot give assent to, cannot aid, and must fight within our own denominational ties. But we can let the conservatives go their own way without rancor.

Again, communion is not through a church's institutional structure, but through God. Juridical considerations aside, we are in communion with any other Christian who seeks to serve God. Perhaps that communion extends even beyond Christianity. I have no problem "letting go" of the "schismatics." They are well without us as we are without them, and no one is out of communion in the only important sense. Concerns about public image for "the Church" meaning "our church" are rather silly for a religion whose founder chose to be publicly condemned as a criminal -- a failed one, at that, since He was condemned.

But, I still stand on my faith. I believe that the most extreme of the conservative thought and practice in this will not survive -- it is a stagnant and bloodless thing. For us, to drag ourselves down to the level of the worst of the "orthodox" (T19, StandFirm, Virtue, etc.) is to fail in living to our calling to welcome and nurture the outcast, to pick up the pieces of those that, in this fallen world, the "orthodox" must damage. Fight the battle so that we do not aid their harm? Certainly! Then, in God's own serenity, let them go.

1 comment:

June Butler said...

Three thoughts here:

We must not be fearful.

We should leave off name-calling. If the "other side" does it, well, let them.

And we must guard against becoming that which we fight. We can stand up for what's right in a Christ-like manner.

Like you, I'm not suggesting that we allow those who want out to run off with property, because those of us who wish to remain loyal the the Episcopal Church have rights, too.

It's God's church in the end. It's the broken Body of Christ. Christ's body has been broken many times in the history of Christianity, but God will make it whole.