Monday, April 2, 2012

Lenten Exercise, Indeed!

Oh, and . . . . MAJOR SPOILERS!!!!!!!!





I've been setting my super-aspie sense to obsessing over one thing, as usual.

This past couple of weeks it's been comparing the various film versions of The Turn of the Screw.

Now, this is not - probably - the best pursuit for someone prone to suicidal depression.  I've always loved the story;  it's made people say "WTF just happened?" since 1895.  Is the governess a nutjob?  Is it a haunting?  Is Miles really a perfect little gentleman or a sociopathic monster-in-the-making?  What was Quint's "corruption?"  Was there any corruption?  Is the uncle the problem?  The governess?  The children? 

I have discovered three important things in this comparison:

First - A great many of these adaptations are not called The Turn of the Screw; e. g. - The Innocents, The Haunting of Helen Walker, Presence of Mind, In A Dark Place. 

Second - Most can't seem to manage the delicate balancing act of leaving the questions;  The Innocents is undoubtedly the best at that.  Personally, I believe that the children, especially Miles, were damaged goods at the hands of the sexually-omnivorous Quint, and the puritanical governess picked up on the "wrongness" and slowly went crazy trying to exorcise it, to the point of driving one child mad and the other to death.  However, I like making that decision, and seeing other possibilities.  The 1999 Jodhi May version is the most disappointingly direct, in many ways.  From the start, you're saying, "What a prig!  I wouldn't leave my kids in her hands!" 

Third - There are a surprising number of really good young actors out there, especially creepy, sleazy little boys. 

Valerie Bertinelli's version was surprisingly un-bad, despite the unexplained decision to make the governess American.  Leelee Sobieski's version was un-surprisingly bad - I call it The Turn of the Screwhead.  The worst is the 1992 version with Patsy Kensit - the governess is cold and un-engaging, but, worse, little Miles is just poorly-acted.  Not the kid's fault - it's a hell of a role for a pre-pubescent.
I  champion the '59 tv version - of which I've only seen this bit - because it has Ingrid Bergman(yay) and Miles might live in that version.  I don't like it when kids die in a story.  Doesn't make it a bad story, just makes me sappy.

So, enjoy a distillation of my 2 week dystopia.








(For fans of Bram Stoker's Dracula - See! Lucy didn't die. She just moved to Spain and became a governess!)



No comments: