After the comments by the Archfuckwit, I go to Thinking Anglicans, which is usually measured in its tone, thanks to Simon Sarmiento's moderation, even on brutally-divisive points.
I find this:
The Vatican has criticised this killing as well. Watching Americans, especially young people who were children at 9/11 dancing in the streets tells us how far things have fallen in the U.S. Or maybe their violent nature is just more open now. It looked like any jubilant crowd in Tehran. But then again, the U.S. has murdered its enemies before and wrapped itself in a cloak of righteousness. To them, they are the only people who mater on the planet, so, to paraphrase Nixon (with Frost), if the U.S. does it, it is not illegal.
Posted by: Richard Grand on Thursday, 5 May 2011 at 10:03pm BST
and this little charmer from someone who likes to claim his liberal guilt for all the rest of us 'Murkans:
Many people are saying this sort of thing, and I wonder how they cannot reflect that the U.S. has caused the deaths of thousands of unarmed innocent civilians in many parts of the world, most recently and notably in Iraq and Afghanistan. And what of the deaths of armed nationals whose offense is opposing foreign occupation of their native lands?
If we're uncomfortable with the cold-blooded killing of a man (and his staff) in his own home, I wonder that we're not more uncomfortable with the impersonal slaughter of wedding parties, motor convoys, and apartment house residents in the Middle East by missiles dropped from drone aircraft remotely controlled from centers in Nevada -- all to eliminate people suspected of organizing opposition to foreign occupation (ours). Sorry about the women and children in the area. No offense intended. Sign here for burial expenses.
The U.S. empire has operated outside public view in large part -- who knows about the conquest of the Philippines or the murder of the opposition party by our dictator in Peru? Nowadays, we can see how the beast operates, and it's not a pretty sight. But it undergirds the U.S. standard of living. Where to start unraveling it? The ABC, and the church at large, might give it some thought, instead of continuing to operate as a department of Empire, and apologist for the powers-that-be.
Posted by: Murdoch Matthew on Friday, 6 May 2011 at 5:09am BST
Now, I don't mind claiming my part of the guilt pie, but I am tired of the hypocrisy that claims that somehow Americans are the worst, most horrible, most dreadful creatures to ever have lived. Why we invented genocide and imperialism and war and murder! Whatever evil there is, we've done it more, worse, longer than any of the sainted nations of Europe! I have no problem with saying we are just as bad, but no worse. And Mr. Matthew's comment up there isn't an "I'm sorry we've done that" but "Look at how awful they are!"
Does nobody get this? That is the problem. "They" and "Us" - no matter how terrible "they" may be, "they" wouldn't be "them" without "us" being "us." Life doesn't happen in a vacuum.
Why is there a W.? Partially because of me. Why is there a Tea Party? Partially because of me. Why is there a Taliban? Partially because of me. Why was there an Osama bin Laden? Partially because of me. Why was there a sad, unedifying end to Osama bin Laden? Partially because of me.
And you, and everybody else.
And the hypocritical refusal to own that, the urge to point fingers is NOT cathartic, NOT a good way to relieve tension, NOT sound psychological practice, it is the whole goddamned reason the music keeps playing the exact same apocalyptic tune over and over.
If I fall into the trap of "What about what they did?!" - which I did! - I am playing the same sad, tired game.
Isolationism - that's the way to go. Maybe, if everybody, every person, was sent to their corners for a few decades, then they'd learn there are still problems with no "Them" to blame it on. Maybe a little isolation would teach us to honor one another and value the whole damned human community.
2 comments:
I think people would still find a them. Every nation, every person, finds it easy to blame some group, marking them as "the other". In France, it is the Muslims. In Germany, the Turks (most of whom were born and grew up in Germany). Here, it is the teachers, the unions, the poor. There is always some other that we can place blame upon. Even when there is no one to blame but ourselves, we externalize it and say, "I'm sorry, I just haven't had a cigarette," or "I'm just having a bad day". Statements like that place the blame on an outside force, the desire to smoke, the bad day, but not ourselves. Never ourselves.
Does nobody get this? That is the problem. "They" and "Us" - no matter how terrible "they" may be, "they" wouldn't be "them" without "us" being "us."
YES!! This is so so important to keep saying again and again.
It's the hardest thing for people to get.
To me, it's the essence of "we're all sinners". It doesn't mean prious brow beating but it means realising that the divisions we create are responsible for all the problems in the world.
James Alison is spending a fair part of this efforts getting people to see that the only way forward is away from that poliarised thinking of Them and Us.
I'm SO glad you wrote this!
Post a Comment