. . posit an absolutist doctrine concerning eternal verities which they cannot prove.
. . insist the only true path to salvation for humankind is through their view.
. . believe it is their duty to make their belief the prevailing one.
. . condescend to, belittle and dehumanize those who disagree.
. . produce slick multimedia mass presentations which exclude opposing views or different interpretations.
. . rely on a group of overprivileged white guys and hipsters to deliver their message.
. . pump out and push the sales of their leading spokespeoples' writings.
. . tell themselves they are part of a special, superior group who are going to be better off than everyone else.
. . take great pleasure in the misfortunes of those who believe differently.
. . respond to opposing views with mockery, vicious slander and outright abuse rather than debate.
. . create a fear-based us/them dichotomy in which all "our" problems are "their" fault to mobilize their base.
. . provide no agenda for movement for any sort of improvement of humankind, only a movement against one segment of humanity.
. . use their chief apologists' theory of an inherent disorder (a selfish gene) to condemn others and yet excuse their own personal misdeeds.
. . claim that their writings are absolute proof that they are correct.
NOW, HOW IS THAT NOT AT ALL LIKE FUNDAMENTALIST RELIGION AGAIN?
Please, feel free to post this elsewhere. I doubt I'll get any real answers here.
7 comments:
Atheists don't wage wars for atheism and don't charge people for preaching. Atheists don't make people get out of bed to sing with them or wear weird clothes to do this. They don't excommunicate each other. You can say "I believe in God" and have a much better chance of being elected or appointed to high office (or any office in some places)than if you say "I don't believe in God. I think it's a false idea."
And atheists are much nicer in general to other atheists with whom they disagree on other issues than believers are.
Plus it doesn't cost anything to be an atheist. Atheists don't have a "central office" to support. You don't have to train to be an atheist. It fits into more lifestyles. You don't have to try and believe impossible things as an atheist.
I'm flattered you read this far back.
I welcome your comments, as you are an avowed atheist, and accept that this is your belief - however, it has not been my experience, at any time, with militant atheists.
Fanaticism is, itself, a sort of religion, an all-consuming, self-justifying obsession. I place christian fundamentalists and militant atheists in exactly the same camp, because they are.
The differences are mere surface. The underlying disorder of thought, emotion and maturity is the same - a seething intolerance and fear of anything that opposes its own view; a lack of adaptability; a selective use of underlying principles. There is the same bigoted rigidity of mind and abuse of those outside their camp. There is the same drawing of lines and inability to conceive of the good and harmony of a larger society - the same "ghettoism" that separates from others in a spectacularly self-destructive display of mock defiance.
In the end, such attitudes alienate those who would otherwise be allies in creating a better world, preferring a false sense of superiority - of "savedness" - as opposed to others who might taint them. Truthfully, the fanatic, whether religious believer or militant atheist, exists in a constant state of fear, self-doubt, and self-imposed misery, at the cost of their birthright as a thinking human being.
One other thought that occurred to me in this exchange of ideas:
Militant atheists are like fundamentalist christians in another sense; they are intolerant of atheists with other views. A militant atheist will not extend the recognition of someone's being a fellow atheist to someone who has no belief in any god, yet is tolerant and respectful to those who do have such beliefs. They are somehow seen as corrupted, or false atheists - so, militant atheism does have its own sort of excommunication, a declaration of apostasy.
Thank you for helping me to crystallize my thoughts on this subject!
Actually, I've known absolutely no atheists who don't recognize as atheists those who refuse to denounce believers. Doubtless you have other experiences.
I don't know about "wider society"; why would atheists, even fundamentalists, be indifferent to this? Some of the angriest atheists I know complain about religion, even "liberal" religion, as solipsistic and just another thing White middle class people like. By the way, Mainline Protestantism yields nothing to Atheism in being mostly Middle class, middle aged and middle brow White people. And we don't have the billions of dollars in assets Mainline Protestantism's churches have and do relatively little with. When your monks get their half million dollars for a sewage system for how many-15?20? monks-how many people who are truly poor could that have helped? Does swanning about in robes and incense help anybody or is it just another pre-Raphaellite affectation indulged in by a rapidly shrinking segment of the religious world?
Religious nuts and atheist nuts are both linked by fanaticism in many of the same ways that axe murderers and machine gun murderers are linked by insane contempt for life and lack of self-control, but the axe murderer has far fewer victims because the axe is incapable of the amount of destruction any person can cause with it. The same with atheism; it's intrinsically a less destructive a philosophy than one which demands total commitment and obedience from someone all-powerful and immortal who can and will punish you even after death if you disobey.
I understand your contempt for Christianity, believe it or not. I also appreciate - and I mean it sincerely - your attempting an actual dialogue here. It's really helpful to me.
Let me start by saying, I don't object to atheism. I simply don't. As with me, I'm sure you've had a different experience, but I know very few liberal Christians who would belittle and mock you for your well-considered disbelief in a higher being. What I've tried to convey - and in my regrettable, over-emotional reactions to you in the past, which I apologize for, have failed to convey - to you is that I don't, really don't, believe in God in the way you think I do. I get very impatient with those who treat our atheist allies as "pet atheists" who'll eventually come 'round to our view. Why the hell should they?! They're perfectly fine, and, in my view, decent people without it!
But, and this is important, I don't think anything is served by discussing religion itself because we are both coming from areas of absolute conviction and are likely to accomplish little but arguing, and there's been and is enough of that all around the world.
I think, too, we're talking at cross purposes, here. I'm not talking about "atheists," but a particular type of atheist. There are, as you put it, atheist nuts who rejoice in the deaths and misery of the religious just as much as religious nuts. Part of my belief of what God is precludes my feeling a need to convert you to anything but civility in discourse, which I have given absolutely no good witness to. I am a humanist in a slightly different way, in that I believe humans, all humans, are worthwhile and count far beyond beliefs and orders. The individual is nothing without community, but the community is also nothing without the individual.
It is important you understand, too, that I wouldn't make a wider appeal on a news blog or such for money for SSJE or myself, because the people who come here regularly are friends, at least in a general sense. I ask for money for SSJE the same way I'd ask for help from friends for other friends. The brothers there have helped me, I owe them, and would never say anyone else owes them anything. The half-million is more than I'll ever see in one place, but very little compared to what is available or needed. I can't convince you of the work that they do, or that helping individuals counts for much. You can, rightly, dismiss all that as anecdotal. We have differing philosophies, as well as beliefs.
For what it's worth, as much as I would regret the change - I hate change - I kind of hope religion as an institution does collapse. Then, those of us who believe will have to find out how to actually do it, not just claim it.
Oh, and sorry to be verbose - just delighted we're actually talking - but I do disagree that any belief system is "inherently" more or less harmful than others. Part of my humanistic ideal includes the idea that the harm or good of a system comes entirely from the individuals involved. Just as religion can tend to absolutist control, atheism can tend to nihilistic opportunism. It entirely depends on the people embracing it.
Post a Comment