Saturday, May 1, 2010

Wordswords

Ever since NT Wright announced he's officially stepping down from the episcopacy of Durham, I keep hearing it from both sides: " . . but he's a great theologian!"

So. What?

Telling me someone is a great theologian carries as much moral and spiritual weight in their capacity as a faithful follower of Christ as telling me ". . but he's a great lawyer!"

We wouldn't need lawyers if lawyers didn't make laws. We wouldn't need theologians if theologians didn't frame canons. Both groups needlessly obfuscate in order to perpetuate their field. However, that said, it is an imperfect world, we allowed them too firm a foothold and now we're stuck with them. Like the lawyer, the theologian isn't taught to find the truth, and certainly not to know God, but how to manipulate words to bolster a bias.

Theologians should not be given the deference they are! While I deplore the anti-intellectualism of the lowest type of right-wing christopolitical, I deplore our idolization of intellectualism, especially in the Anglican tradition, equally. The more they've published, the better bishop they'll be!

If I had my way, there'd be a complete ban on allowing academics and particularly published academics becoming bishops! Show me a bishop with proven pastoral, 1-on-1, abilities and I'll be impressed.

2 comments:

MadPriest said...

Wright is not a great theologian because he is a coward. He allows his thinking and research to take him so far but as soon as he comes to the point that the next logical step in his chain of thought would contradict his received churchmanship and prejudices he backs off.

MarkBrunson said...

You've no disagreement there, MP.

However, my point was that theologians in general are no use for actual, real-life operations in a church. They may be fine for arguing one doctrine over another, but have no purpose where the rubber hits the road. Even the ones who seem more holistic are not prepared to look beyond a set limit - in effect, all theologians are cowards.