Reading my Terry Pratchett Discworld novels again, I am struck by the fact that we Christians really do need atheists - at least, we progressive Christians do. Here, I'm not talking about "atheists" like our trolls in the blogosphere, bitter, self-obsessed people who, not having gotten what they thought they should out of life, have decided that there is no God, or life would be fair - i. e., give them what they want. Nor "atheists" like Dawkins, who use a rally to "rationalism and scientific fact" as a way to advance personal wealth and power. No, true atheists who, like Pratchett, like our IT, don't feel the need to deride, ridicule and despise others, even when they don't comprehend our faith.
Why we need them is because they keep us grounded. Again, for instance, I read Pratchett's satirical take on theism in Discworld's gods - either bizarre, mercurial micro-managers, or distant creatures who play with lives when they are bored, or chuck down a bit of lightning when their reality is questioned. Now, like most progressive Christians, I chuckled at how accurately he portrays "them" - you know, those backwards, ignorant, fundamentalists! I mean, no progressive Christian would actually imagine God as some anthropomorphic super-being, acting like a human, talking like a human, rigidly stuck to traditional words and actions. Even Jesus we understand to be both God and Man.
Which hit me. We may not consciously believe it, but the way we talk about God shows we unconsciously believe it. To hear even the most progressive of us in-the-trench progressive Christians, our God sounds about as existentially-relevant as a doorstop. We talk as if it were a human being over there somewhere, and make sure we stick to the authorized-version when it comes to theological terminology. We go on the defensive when our "orthodoxy" is challenged, trying to show how we really do believe exactly the same as some biblical literalist, rather than proudly saying "You're right. When I say the Nicene Creed I don't mean or think the same thing as you, and I'm rather pleased about that." Which gives away the fact that, deep down, maybe, unconscious as it may be, we do believe in some vengeful Olympian. I certainly had to realize that that is a part of my unconscious make-up, and had to come to grips with defining what God has come to me in my own lifetime's experience, rather than just general vagueness. There's nothing wrong with the vagueness, the via negativa approach, because, after all, we can't say what God is or isn't. But it's like the English teachers and our art teachers told us: You've got to be able to follow the rules before you can break them. To live without some personal definition of God is to live afloat in faith, no anchor. Having the "limits," the "rules," one can stretch beyond them. It's no wonder atheists, even friendly ones, look at us with amazed condescension, when we can't tell them what we profess to believe, but evidence what we claim we don't!
That forced me to consider. I do, indeed, believe in God. I call It God because that is my cultural milieu, my frame of reference. I believe an extant intelligence made the universe(s) and maintains it. I believe that it is both intelligent and alive, and compassionate, loving. I don't believe that it is a sky fairy or flying spaghetti monster or purple unicorn (which, for what it's worth, are all provocatively insulting to my mind - if you want to call me a fucking idiot, just do so without all the coyness). In fact, it is neither a life, nor intelligence that we can comprehend, and can only apprehend in a limited and subjective sense, hence the need for a community of faith in which we can arrive at enough of a common understanding to treat one another with reverence. In a practical sense, God is not a material being. God is consciousness. In another sense, consciousness is all there is, and the consciousness pulls energy into material form. God is our consciousness, as well, with a thin overlay of ego we call ourselves. To that end, God is intensely personal, evidenced in the person of Jesus. God is also entirely impersonal - if God loves all Creation, He doesn't play favorites, which must, necessarily, seem like apathy. Miracles are what we see, and are no less miracles for being explainable, because those miracles serve the purpose of leading us to something else, depending on the circumstances. The key word in my understanding of God is "ineffable" and that's key to my understanding of God as existential. We punish ourselves, often nonsensically, without the need for a cosmic slap of the hand. Bad people "get away" with things, yes, but create a badness around them. Why? Because God is our ground of being and ultimate reality - lie-to-child version, He made us that way. He doesn't need lightning bolts.
There's a lot more to it, which I may hold forth on at length, sometime, but the main thing is, without a real atheist's challenge - the filial challenge of "You aren't making a lot of sense!" - I wouldn't even know myself what I believe.
7 comments:
I don't quite recognise myself in your description. I have never in my life taken the Nicene creed literally or believed in a vengeful God and I don't think I've ever pretended that I did.
Religious concepts are our attempts at putting that into words which cannot be spoken - they are not truth in themselves. If they no longer work, ditch them.
As long as you keep moving closer into God, it doesn't matter what words you or anyone else uses.
And I think there are quite a lot of us out there - unlike me, many simply don't get involved in slogging it out in the comment sections of Christian blogs, because the discussion is rarely conducive to maturing our faith.
I suspect the same can be said of thoughtful atheists like that wonderful IT and many of my agnostic and atheist friends.
If you feel secure in your faith/atheism you don't need to spend time convincing others that they're wrong....
I have only started commenting on blogs after I discovered the extent of discrimmination against lgbt people in the church. That battle is worth getting involved in.
Once it's over, I shall slink back into my pew and be like everyone else - living out my faith as best as I can, together with all my church friends who may believe or not believe all manner of things no-one normally ever talks about.
I don't quite recognise myself in your description.
Then, what I've written wouldn't necessarily have been written to apply to you.
However, if it were there, and you did recognize it, then we wouldn't need the atheists in the way I've posited.
As for the blogs, that's not really what I'm writing about, however, the blogs are a type of immediately-applicable social interaction, and so used as an example, only an example, given that its public nature wouldn't violate any degree of more private social interaction.
Here's my God, my Trinity:
Spirit of Life
Spirit of Intelligence
Spirit of Love.
No out there being; all intrinsic in every living creature.
I will still fall on my knees and pray like a child when distressed, but I ask for direction and insight and the strength to move on. More often than not it comes. IT keeps me going.
Thank for sharing that, LIT.
Thank you very much.
Mark
I think I mentioned the blogs because the kind of comments you make: "We may not consciously believe it, but the way we talk about God shows we unconsciously believe it.To hear even the most progressive of us in-the-trench progressive Christians, our God sounds about as existentially-relevant as a doorstop" are thoughts I only ever come across on blogs.
I'm not like that and in the real world, none of my liberal friends hold views like that. So I don't know who this "We" is you're talking about.
But if I just read the blogs, I could easily believe that you were right.
So if I'm wrong and if your thinking is based on a broad experience of Christians in all walks of life, then I apologise.
I suppose I'm really trying to say that the situation is far less hopeless than it can appear.
And that intelligent people are intelligent whether they're people of any faith or none.
Well, Erika, I don't know that I've presented a hopeless situation. If you saw that, that was not the intention.
I would argue with the idea that the ideas you run into on the blogs are not ideas from "real life." Perhaps I'm mistaken and other people have blog-self and real-self, but the ideas I present are ones that come from reality become I am part of reality. Your experience of others may be different.
It is possible that it is a cultural difference. You are in Bristol, I'm in south Georgia. One of the handicaps of better communication is we feel that we all really are one world. We're not, thank God. Also, unfortunately, I can only see from the perspective of my culture, just like you.
I do believe, based on a fairly wide swath of experience, both mine and others', that people don't do a lot of self-examining. Humans tend to be extremely outward-looking, failing to recognize that there is a difference between consciously having a position and the depths of belief. I may have made an error in relying on my experience, or my experience of others' experience, but that is human - we are within our own skins and rely on what we and our friends and contacts experience, then extrapolate from that.
It may be that you and your friends and associates are different. That's why I attempt not to use terms like "everybody" "nobody" etc. I say "we" because, like any publicly-presented proposition, I'm speaking to those who can recognize themselves in what I'm saying. Simple as that. I also tend away from simply presenting any thoughts that pop up - argument for arguments' sake, or to prove how clever I am is pointless, though I have fallen into those lesser hells.
My intent was not to speak against liberal Christianity, but for an underdog - the patient, tolerant atheist who is buffeted on both sides, their bewildered Christian friends and the militant, bitter atheist who are so much the face of atheism, because hate sells so well. I meant merely to show what a positive influence they have been for many, yes, including me. I won't apologize for using my own perspective, simply because I've never met the creature "objectivity." I think that objectivity is a flying spaghetti monster.
Mark
Oh yes, there are flying spaghetti monsters!
And I'm sorry if you feel attacked - this is not about being right or wrong, or even apologising for views! And it's certainly not personal!
Like you, I don't believe that people have blog selves and real selves. What I do believe is that a certain kind of person engages on the blogs. We're all characterised by having strong views and wanting to talk about them.
But so many of the people I know don't feel the need to talk. They accept women priests, so to them, that's a non issue. And they accept lgbt people, so they focus their energies on local needs or other charitable work and leave the debate to the debaters.
Whether they believe in a vengeful God or not - who can say! Most of us outside the blog world don't tend to talk about our faith in such detail. Well... they don't in reserved British congregations:-)
As for speaking for the underdog - oh yes, I'm with you!!
Post a Comment