In the comments responding to Hans Kung's (can't be having with umlauts; they roll off and cause unnecessary punctuation) article condemning Benny da Bavarian's intimate humdrummeries, I found this jewel:
stevehill
28 Oct 09, 12:46am (about 8 hours ago)
I don't mind admitting that I have in all seriousness suggested the Pope to the National Secular Society (of which I am a member) as a worthy contender for Secularist of the Year 2010.
Nobody can have done more to turn millions of people away from the superficial, and superstitious, attractions of mainstream religious faith.
He's a gift to us.
Now, while Mr. Hill may be wrong about the existence or non-existence of God, and while his broad swipe at faith speaks of a need to self-justify, his assessment of what Benny da Bavarian's real legacy will be is, I believe, entirely accurate.
That's sad.
I like the Roman Catholic Church. It's produced some wonderful people - even after they had a choice of whether to be RC or not! There's a lot of resentment, now, but it's misplaced - at least by non-RC. Benny da Bavarian is the problem. Yes, it goes right down to the core of the church, but only because of the parts he chooses to resurrect and hold up as incontrovertible. That happens with any autocracy - the head defines the body. Now, we know the uglier parts of RC ecclesiology and theology, but that is flexible - we have parts we ignore, too, we're just healthy enough to know we ignore it - and that flexibility is what allows Benny B. to use either the crook or the flail. He's chosen the flail, but he's old. Maybe next pope will be just as bad or worse, or, maybe, the College of Cardinals will look around at their rather shaky thrones and realize this isn't the good ol' days when RC's had to stay RC! Maybe, after a few years of orthodite Anglycannes, they'll begin to think, "What the hell were we thinking putting that guy in charge?!"
Remember, the RCC is a place for people that need it, too. Just like Anglicanism and Methodism and congregationalism and Orthodoxy. Just as it's dredged up Benny da Bavarian, it also gave us Francis, Therese, Thomas Merton, Mother Teresa, John XXIII. Pope Julius was a vicious warlord, but he commissioned one of the great spiritual masterpieces from Michaelangelo.
And, for some reason, the jubilation on both the RCC's and the orthodites' parts make me feel they need a slight warning, if they can see it:
No comments:
Post a Comment