I sent an email to one of our delegates, a man in my parish, a man for whom I have great respect and love. I won't print any of what was said, so, please, take all that I say here completely as my interpretation of the communication.
As I've said on other blogs, I was angry, hurt, outraged and disappointed by the failure of our delegation to support D025 and 056. I expressed this to him clearly, and, he assured me, articulately. His response was thoughtful and clear, and reaffirmed my own confidence in him, as well as the people of my diocese. I understand that we are trying to maintain a neutral stance in the midst of all this, and I'm aware of my own idealism and mystical approach which makes me impatient with such a stance.
However, there is still a disconnect that leads to a real concern both for my actions and TEC's outlook. First, this gentleman assured me, repeatedly, of his acceptance of GLBT's, including stories of family members and his own willingness, if such a shift in policy were made, to bless the union of a gay family member (this member of my parish is also a postulant to Holy Orders). However, that's not what this is about. I struggle with sexuality; not with being gay, but with being a sexual being. I could care less, to be brutally blunt, about other peoples' romantic relationships. Marriage is a completely private affair, to my mind, and of little interest. I dislike married clergy, detest a married episcopate, and believe that, in secular terms, no married couple - even with children - should receive state breaks or benefits not extended to each individual. I don't hate marriage - - I could never work up that much feeling about it.
I thought I had made clear that "gay" is not what any of this is about. If that were it, I'd care less. The justice aspect is my immediate concern, with justice for the individual being the greatest part of that. To lay suffering and misery, disdain and hate on another on the basis of no more than "tradition" or even outright superstition is wrong. Even if you claim that you believe the tradition and scripture to be absolutely correct, so what? Without objective evidence, you have no right to enforce your beliefs. I've set that out in my argument in a thread below - - belief counts only so far as it can be proven, especially when that belief operates as proscription. I believe marriage and romantic relationships are futile, perhaps destructive and I believe that children can be produced without such entanglements and raised successfully in a group/societal environment. If my belief, through argument or luck, becomes the majority one, should that alone ensure its enforcement? This is the crux. To deny others' own experience of themselves is to arrogate unbelievable power to oneself. I don't deny that the orthodites experience God as fearful, vengeful, irrational, distant, that they experience homosexuality as personally harmful. Again, so what? They can believe that. I won't make them sleep with others of their sex, or deny them romantic/sexual expression outside of same-sexual relationships. I won't deny them the right to believe God is what they view, even it's truth . . . for them. God relates as we need Him, and they need an inscrutable parent/policeman/watchdog. The conflict lay in their trying to make themselves special by taking God's power to themselves, to define their beliefs and experiences as universal. If you must maintain purity, withdraw and do so, but don't require the world around to conform to your desires.
This is my concern. Not "teh gay." Sex is . . . maintenance. The issue is who is God; I'm not, but neither are they, and taking that upon themselves is something I must oppose, for their good as for mine, so I struggle with issues that, as presenting issues, are of little concern. I struggle with the idea that we too have become entirely too immersed with the "presenting issue." Perhaps my identity as a gay man, or that part that I identify with as gay, is too caught up in it to present the real dangers and point of the struggle. I frankly don't know what God thinks of homosexuality - I simply know what He thinks of me, including my own sexuality, and what He shows me in the steady gay relationships I've come to see around me.
I also struggle - mightily - with the Anglican Communion, another major concern in my communication with my friend. I keep being told of its value. How much it allows us to do. Of its necessity at all costs. That by submitting to injustice for us in the First World we can slowly undo injustice in the Third World. I hate the Anglican Communion. Hate it. Despise it. Will dance on its grave. I believe it to be, not just useless, but a destructive demon of vanity and sloth. Yet, it's hard to see if that's right, or the supporters are.
AC's been around longer than me and has brilliant minds and open hearts in support of it. Yet, when I ask "HOW? How is the AC so important? What can it do that we cannot if we start to make new associations?" all I get is - as with ++Whalon - anecdotes about works that, quite honestly, could've been done as, if not more, effectively by a secular social-action network. Or, I'm told about "friendships" and connections made, as if that were some sort of magical formula, or even real. Clearly, those "friendships" have proven false or based on convenience in many cases. I suspect a sort of American imperialism in it, benevolently-conceived, but imperialistic, nonetheless, which says, "By God, they will love us! We will stay right there in their faces til they see we're right and they're wrong!" This I see combined with a wilfull ignorance of being used, abused and manipulated by these "friends," which is based in Pride - OUR Pride, refusing to believe we could've been fooled, wrong about our noble, liberal ideals and our application of them to people who have proven unworthy. I hear, most plaintively, that we can make it better by swallowing our pride and accepting the AC's declarations on our actions, their sanctions, their disdain. But no one can tell me how!
I'm not a big fan of Dr. Phil, but, let's be honest, there's a lot to be said for the simple question, "How's that been workin' for ya?" Things are worse, not better, for our penitence and shame, our degrading ourselves and our witness.
But, I struggle. Can it make it better if we just bow out? It feels wrong. Cowardly. Craven. Soft. Faithless. But, I'm aware of my own stiff neck. So, how can our humiliation help the "less fortunate?" Show me. I'll resist, but knowing that - I'll accept. Prove it. Prove we need the AC. I'm not gainsaying, but really struggling.
So, those who favor the AC over TEC's actions, please! tell me why we must stay, but be prepared to defend. Drivebys are not helpful. Vacuous statements of goodwill are pointless. Show me.
I'm struggling. Doing the same thing over and over expecting different results is craziness. But . . . which of us is crazy?
3 comments:
"Show me" is hard. Because we haven't done it differently yet, it's impossible to show with an absolutely scientifically evidence based method that the AC is important or not, that TEC is important or not, that any church or denomination is important or not.
And you can only ever objectively see what has been done, not what could have been done, or what could be achieved now.
So just as you are unable to show me what TEC WILL do outside the AC, I cannot show you what would have been different had there been no AC.
The real question is not what “we” need, but where God is. Is he truly guiding TEC? Then TEC will have to have the courage of its convictions and go ahead regardless of the consequences. Is he truly trying to stop TEC so the rest of the AC can catch up? Then TEC will have to slow down and see if the others do, indeed, eventually catch up.
But that question cannot be answered empirically either - it comes down to faith.
My personal advice to you in TEC would be to get the hell out of the AC and to become a beacon for a Christianity where human rights are not seen as a rather nasty secular invention removed from God’s will. You’ve read the science, you’ve done the theology, you’ve listened to the individuals and observed the fruits of their lives – whatever was it for, if you now allow those who have resolutely refused to even look at any of this to determine your actions?
The God I believe in is more interested in love, compassion, justice and faith than in some spurious ecclesiastical unity for the sake of….. of what, precisely?
But I could, of course, be completely wrong.
I think these are important questions. I'm not really sure what the Anglican Communion is for, either. I won't claim to have done the research.
I think the answer to that might have a lot to do with answering the next question of how to deal with differences in interpretation from one part of the world to another.
I do wonder about how this fits with article XXXIV.
I think the important thing is, while the benefits can't be shown, the damage done by remaining in the AC is readily demonstrable.
It's time to jettison from this sinking ship!
Post a Comment