From Susan Russell's blog comments:
What you and other proponents of same-sex marriage propose to do is to remove the objective foundation from the meaning of marriage. You may not have even considered that objective aspect of marriage important. You may have thought that male and female was merely custom, not a part of the essence of marriage. But marriage is a relationship based on both objective (male and female) and subjective (love) elements.
If you remove the objective aspect of marriage, what you have left is the subjective. Affectional preference is the determinant factor. When all you have left is the subjective, you have an extremely unstable foundation. Two women are sexually attracted to each other and have a deep love for one another. Why not marriage for them? But if you have made the subjective aspect – affectional preference – the basis for marriage, then what do you do about all the other affectional preferences that exist? Why is “two” the magic number? Why not three, four, or more? Why not father and daughter? Why not an adult male and an eight-year-old boy? Why not siblings? Why not the living and the dead? Why not affection for animals? If all you have to base marriage on is affectional preference, you have no reason to exclude any affectional preference?
By making the subjective element the sole element for marriage, you have destroyed the very idea of marriage. There are no longer any boundaries. A man or woman may say, “I cannot help it. The only place I find any sense of joy or fulfillment is in brief encounters. Why cannot I have a wife/husband for a week and then move on to someone new?”
You will not destroy my marriage of course. I know what marriage really is, and my wife and I are committed to that God-given ideal. But if, according to law, any and all relationships can be called marriage in the world my grandchildren grow up in, they will be surrounded by instability, and they will not know what it means to be committed to a person for life. They will be given the ideal by law (and quite likely by the educational system, if things continue as they have been going) that only affectional preference matters. And mere emotion, which is so variable, is no foundation for a life. We will have societal chaos that will make our current instability look like “the good old days.”
IGNORANCE
Spot the logical fallacy? Of course you do! Why it's the same gasping, wheezing, elaborately self-justifying fallacy of all slippery slope arguments.
So why can't the poster?
Because he doesn't want to.
1 comment:
Let's see...let's see...objective foundation for the meaning of marriage...let's think about this...
Well, if we look at marriage as a legal construct, then marriage is the way in which to individuals become a legally single entity, it also confers upon the couple certain rights in relationship to each other and the property they hold in common. In many societies, one person in the marriage would actually become the legal property of the other. Fun, huh?
Since marriage is a legal institution, we cannot really regulate it on a religious basis due to our legal separation of church and state. Also, since marriage is about taxation and property, and not children, we cannot really regulate due to its supposed affect on children, especially since not only is any influence of supposed harm of gay marriage is suspect at best, but also because married couples are in no way obligated to produce children. (Thereby denying the argument that marriage is for children).
However, what if marriage is a religious institution? If it is under threat, shouldn't the government step in to protect our beliefs that we hold oh so dear? Well, no, not really, and not just because of that thorny separation of church and state thing. The reason is because what other people do does not effect what a person believes in. For example, if you are against the death penalty, the fact that people are sentenced to death does not change what you believe in (crazy, huh?)
Also, if marriage is a religious institution, then all marriages are civil unions and regulating marriage is impossible (church and state again).
You know what is a legal institution? Marriage. Yep, it's legal, property and all. You know what isn't? Matrimony. Yep. Matrimony is the religious institution. People often confuse the two. Crazy, I know.
Okay, that is enough of my rant.
Post a Comment