Tuesday, November 18, 2008

The Past Week

Has been exhausting.

I can't say, in the wake of Prop 8, that I've been particularly impressed with either side, as a group.

On our side, there is this vengeful streak, saying to shame, target, boycott - make 'em pay!

There's nothing wrong with boycotts, if they are aimed at a worthy object. But, to organize and call for boycotts of companies because they didn't do enough, in your opinion, or because they employ people who contributed to Prop 8, that is the same tactics and same motivation of the Prop 8 blackmailers who threatened companies for not contributing to their campaign. Remember that? To try to drive people - individuals - from their jobs because they contributed, simply crying "Public record! Public record!" is a type of censorship. Sorry, but it is. Saying "Zero tolerance to bigotry!" is the exact same thing in a democratic republic as saying "Zero tolerance to tolerance!"

In a practical sense, it's a disaster to the movement to end Prop 8, and, perhaps to the struggle for gay acceptance. It divides resources and focus from those companies that - as companies - supported Prop 8, deflects attention away from the unconscionable manipulation of politics by the Latter Day Saints and the Roman Catholic bishops. You don't divide overstretched forces. It's unwise.

Also, practically, it's playing into the Pro-Prop-8 stereotype: you are trying to police thought and squash dissent. You are punishing people for having different views. You're giving parents every chance to carry and spread the bigotry to a new generation - "See, Son, you're Dad got fired because of the fags, just like . . . " "See, the fags will make everyone get on board with their agenda!" "See, the fags are evil! Without their mark you can't buy or sell!" and on and on.

Now, the Pro-Prop-8 gang:

First, their position is reprehensible. It has been arrived at by such contortions of thought, basic human goodwill, and, indeed, basic humanity that it is purely nauseating. The degree to which so many simply surrendered to groupthink in the guise of religious conviction or "My church told me to!" is worthy only of disgust.

Aren't you humans, anymore? Can't you arrive at your own conclusions? Did God simply waste His time making you to be a receptacle for every whim of vox populi, whether it goes by the name vote or the name religious hierarchy? Or, worse, waste His time by creating something just intelligent enough to create fantastic structures of self-deception to justify hate without the slightest introspection?

Shame. On. You.

The best I've gotten is from people who, while claiming "I know x number of gays, and I don't disrespect them!" also present claims about gay relationships, thought processes, motivations, beliefs, that, apart from being more than they could possibly know, are so far into fantasy that it makes it clear that they don't know any gays anymore than they know the person who stands behind them in the checkout line!

It's all based on fantasy, an "exoticising" of gays so that we have different motivations, desires, brain functions than you because we are attracted to a sex you aren't! It is bizarre, irresponsible, and sad.

Gays want to marry someone of the same sex for the exact same reasons you want to marry someone of the opposite sex. If you marry someone of the opposite sex simply for procreation, then you are using that person and unworthy of marriage!!!! END OF DISCUSSION!!!

Gays are sexually attracted to people of the same sex for the exact same reasons you are attracted to people of the opposite sex. If you force yourself to be attracted to someone because you are "supposed" to be, you are NOT attracted to that person!!!!END OF DISCUSSION!!!!

Gays mean the same thing in "committment" to a person of the same sex as you do to a person of the opposite sex. If your "committment" is based on mere external pressure, it is NOT a committment!!!! END. OF. DISCUSSION.

I have seen an otherwise intelligent person on Tobias' In A Godward Direction argue the "need" for an institution separate from marriage because gays expect different things, and "proving" this with some linguistic sleight-of-hand accompanied by an image of homosexuals and homosexuality with absolutely no basis in reality.

It's absolutely ridiculous, this manipulating yourself and others, being manipulated by self and others, all because you are too damned lazy to be responsible human beings!! It's not your leaders' fault . . . you put 'em there and that's what leaders do, they try to control . . . it's your fault for being so willing to be controlled.

No comments: