It's the only Sunday that is really devoted to Church doctrine rather than scriptural concept or event. Fr. Jim is highly intelligent and well-educated, and expounds theology very well. Yet, in the end, as with most theology, the doctrine of the Trinity leaves me with this thought:
And this is important to me because . . . ?
4 comments:
I agree.
It seems to me that the Doctrine of the Trinity was something invented by the Church in order not to contradict the doctrine that there was only one god. But why should that be so important? Would anything change if God was not one but was multiple. The Bible presents us with all sorts of manifestations of God - Wisdom, the Angel of God, the Breathe and Wind of God, The Son and Word, the Spirit, the Father and that baffling God as a community that we come across in Genesis.
The reason why the doctrine of the Trinity doesn't make sense to us is because it doesn't make sense - but everyone is far too scared to even begin admitting this and then asking real questions.
More than scared, I think, but cowed. "We are the theologians! Question not, mortal!"
Theology, in general, is simply a way of muddying God's clarity, in my view. It is undoubtedly necessary to combat subtle heresy, and, moreso, to keep bishops out of the important work of church, but has little merit in the parish.
There's a would-be moderate chirping on Thinking Anglicans about "doing the theology! doing the theology!" as necessary for TEC in pursuing a course of righteousness. Absolute crap! Theology, if it is useful, only comes as a clarification to what's right, not as the antecedent to God's action.
At least, according to all but professional theologians.
God is Love, Lover, and Beloved.
That's the best I can do, Mark.
You might want to look at this discussion. I don't think it sheds much light either.
Well, it's not so much that I don't understand the Trinity - Macquarrie explained it well enough - it's just that I'm not sure why it's important, outside of refuting certain heresies of the early church.
Post a Comment