Tuesday, June 5, 2007

Cadfael

For those who are fans of Ellis Peters' Brother Cadfael series, do you ever find yourself wishing they'd undertake making the series into full-length films? I'm not denigrating Derek Jacobi's great work, I hope, but I would like to see a big-budget production that captures the books a bit more fully (I confess disappointment at some of the Cadfael series' writing).

Who would play whom?

Cadfael has been a bit difficult for me. At the start of the series of books, A Morbid Taste For Bones, Cadfael is 57. Both Anthony Hopkins and Derek Jacobi, both my natural choices, are well beyond that, now (and look it, I'm afraid).

Abbot Heribert is another who gives a bit of trouble, though I could imagine Peter O'Toole -- elderly, scholarly, a bit timid.

Immediately coming to mind for Prior Robert is Jeremy Irons -- tall, impressive, good-looking, well-spoken, though Jonathan Pryce would be a close second.

Abbot Radulfus, what can I say? I'm a huge fan of Alan Rickman. He is craggy enough, as well as being vigorous and conveying a great deal with voice and slight facial expression.

For Hugh Beringar, I can easily imagine Joseph Fiennes, but my first choice would have to be Christopher Eccleston.

For Brother Jerome, I thought of Simon Pegg, though he may be a bit young.

Brother Edmund, the infirmarer, Cadfael's close confidant, I could see in Roger Lloyd-Pack or Kevin McNally.

Two character, in a recent re-reading, immediately brought actors to mind, both sort of "yoked" in popular thought, as they are. Young "Brother" Meriet Aspley in The Devil's Novice could be quite ably played by Daniel Radcliffe, and the recurring character of Brother Mark would allow Tom "Draco Malfoy" Felton to show a bit of humanity and compassion.

Your thoughts, additions, favorite actors for favorite characters?

And who to play Cadfael?

2 comments:

Anonymous said...

I share your disappointment with some of the Cadfael adaptation scripts - and WHY were there THREE Hugh Berengars? Maybe there were more - I stopped counting at three.

I also would have loved to have seen more of Oliver - thought that was very good casting, although can't remember the actor's name...I've been slowly working my way through the series via Netflix.

Who to play Cadfael indeed? David Bamber perhaps - was Mr. Collins on the A&E Pride and Prejudice - has aged nicely and has something of the look of an old soldier. I keep thinking of all these wonderful English character actors whose names I don't know - will have to consult the IMDB data base.

We need to find something for Dougray Scott to do. Too old now for Hugh, I think, but still cute.

MarkBrunson said...

Yes. I could see David Bamber as Cadfael!

Dougray Scott would actually make a very good Brother Paul, the master of the schoolboys and novices. He's capable of conveying both warmth and severity, and Paul is described as being rather handsome and aristocratic-looking.