He is worthy.
From Ann by way of Grandmere Mimi, a pastoral letter from Bp. Scott Benhase.
I reprint in full:
21 April 2010
To the People of the Diocese of Georgia:
A few of our colleagues in the Diocese asked me if I gave my consent to the Reverend Canon Mary Glasspool's election as Bishop Suffragan of Los Angeles. I did. While it is not usual for bishops to report on individual consents, I realize that for some people this is different, so I will try to explain how I came to give my consent. I cannot do so in a sound bite or even in a few sentences. Thus, you might wish to read this when you are not in a hurry.
1. Prior to my election as the 10th Bishop of Georgia, my theology and practice on the full inclusion of gays and lesbians in the life of the Church was well-known. I do not understand homosexuality to be a barrier to any of the four orders of ministry in the Church. I have been quite clear in that theology and practice. So, my consent to Canon Glasspool's election was consistent with what you had already known about me.
2. I would not have given my consent if I knew of any theology or practice of Canon Glasspool that was contrary to the Doctrine and Discipline of the Episcopal Church. Canon Glasspool has been a faithful priest of the Church for decades leading parishes to a renewed sense of their baptismal identity and purpose. More recently, she has served quite effectively as Canon to the Ordinary in the Diocese of Maryland. From my perspective, we need more bishops like Canon Glasspool who have had extensive experience in the leadership of parishes so they are better able to be strategic partners with congregational leaders for the growth and mission of our parishes.
3. I am aware of some concern about the so-called moratorium. The House of Bishops did agree to a moratorium a number of years ago. That moratorium, however, was not one-sided. It was accepted in the context that certain of our Anglican brothers would refrain from crossing diocesan boundaries. While the House of Bishops exercised the restraint of the moratorium for seven years, others did not practice such restraint even for a year. So, in my judgment, the moratorium was no longing a compelling consideration.
4. I, of course, recognize that some in the Diocese of Georgia disagree with my consent. I welcome that. Disagreement in the Church is hardly new. In some ways, Anglicanism was forged out of an unresolved disagreement in the Elizabethean Settlement. After Queen Elizabeth, Protestants and Catholics within Anglicanism did not somehow see their differences go away, but they were committed to living with one another and serving Jesus together in the church. They were willing to live with what they perceived as significant differences. In many ways, the challenge we face today is not new.
5. I believe that this current dilemma we face needs to be seen and understood in the larger context and truthfulness of Church history and tradition. The catholic faith has always lived with differences while holding fast to the Nicene faith. For example, the post-Constantinian Church has lived with difference in how we interpret the Sixth Commandment. Some have insisted that all killing is wrong all the time. This is the so-called pacifist position. Others have insisted that there are times when violating the Sixth Commandment is the lesser of two evils. From this came the Just War constructs of St Augustine that provided ethical boundaries for the violation of the Sixth Commandment. We have had both positions held faithfully in this Church (with many nuances in between) and neither has insisted that the other is not welcome or that the other is not orthodox.
6. More recently in my lifetime, we have had disagreement about violating Jesus' teaching on divorce. Jesus is clear: If one marries after divorce one commits adultery. That seems to be the plain sense of Scripture. Yet, many have recognized that while divorce is never a "good," sometimes it is the lesser of two evils for all parties. Others, however, still insist that Jesus' words must be interpreted plainly. There are still others in our Church that hold even more nuanced understandings about this that fit somewhere in between the two extremes. Yet, in all these, we remain together in the same Church and receiving God's gracious sacrament from the same
altar.
7. I understand our current dilemma in a similar historical context. Faithful people will disagree about this. I do not understand such disagreement as a problem to be solved, but a dilemma God is asking us to live with for the time being. There are faithful people in the Diocese of Georgia who are anxious for a definitive resolution. I do not believe that is possible right now and may not be in my lifetime on this earth. If that is true, how are we to live together with this dilemma? I think the answer to that question is this: We will live together just like the saints who have gone before us who heeded Blessed Paul's admonitions. We will love and honor one another. We will bear one another's burdens. We will not have a higher opinion of ourselves than we ought. We will not look only to our own concerns, but the concerns of others. We will forgive one another as we have been forgiven.
8. There is a prayer in the Marriage Rite that has always touched me deeply. When praying for the newly married couple, the Church hopes that "their life together" may be "a sign of Christ's love to this sinful and broken world, that unity may overcome estrangement, that forgiveness heal guilt, and joy conquer despair." I see this as an image of our relationship together. I have been Bishop of this Diocese for three months now. In that sense, we are newlyweds together. Like in any relationship that is not worked at and nurtured, we can fall into patterns that lead to estrangement, guilt, and despair. You and I will work hard not to let that happen. We will seek unity, forgiveness, and joy. We will seek to make our life together as bishop and people "a sign of Christ's love for this sinful and broken world." Of course, we will not always achieve such virtues, but I know we will constantly seek them and commit ourselves to practicing them.
As your Bishop, I am committed to leading this Diocese faithfully and effectively. I want those who have differences on the issue of human sexuality to know that I will not play favorites by rewarding those who agree with me or seeking to punish those who do not. All of us share in the mission of Jesus Christ together. All have an important role to play in that mission. I pray that we not allow whatever differences we have to distract us from taking the saving Gospel of Jesus to the world.
+Scott
Saturday, April 24, 2010
Friday, April 23, 2010
Weird Roles, Weird Movie
A movie I haven't thought of in a while -
The Loved One
I read the book by Evelyn Waugh, years ago, in college, and that was my introduction to really black comedy - and it is. The film has significant differences, of course, but when I first watched it and saw the cast, I thought it was going to be extremely toned down from the book. It had a pretty mainstream cast for 1965 - Robert Morse, John Gielgud, Rod Steiger, Roddy McDowall, Robert Morley and Jonathan Winters -- it even had Liberace. Come on, how bizarre could it be?
Actors - even the mainstream ones - like to take risks, occasionally.
For instance:
Lee Liberace
Rod Steiger
Jonathan Winters
This is all just as strange in context.
Obviously, it's satire, and influenced as much by Patricia Mitford's The American Way of Death as by Waugh's novel.
Jonathan Winters as the Glenworthy brothers (you meet the "Blessed Reverend" Glenworthy, who runs the luxurious mortuary to the stars in the clip - his less successful brother runs the mortuary to the stars' pets) and Rod Steiger as mortician, Mr. Joyboy, are outstanding. The only casting I didn't like was Robert Morse, who, I suspect, was in the lead because of his success with How to Succeed in Business . . . on Broadway.
The Loved One
I read the book by Evelyn Waugh, years ago, in college, and that was my introduction to really black comedy - and it is. The film has significant differences, of course, but when I first watched it and saw the cast, I thought it was going to be extremely toned down from the book. It had a pretty mainstream cast for 1965 - Robert Morse, John Gielgud, Rod Steiger, Roddy McDowall, Robert Morley and Jonathan Winters -- it even had Liberace. Come on, how bizarre could it be?
Actors - even the mainstream ones - like to take risks, occasionally.
For instance:
Lee Liberace
Rod Steiger
Jonathan Winters
This is all just as strange in context.
Obviously, it's satire, and influenced as much by Patricia Mitford's The American Way of Death as by Waugh's novel.
Jonathan Winters as the Glenworthy brothers (you meet the "Blessed Reverend" Glenworthy, who runs the luxurious mortuary to the stars in the clip - his less successful brother runs the mortuary to the stars' pets) and Rod Steiger as mortician, Mr. Joyboy, are outstanding. The only casting I didn't like was Robert Morse, who, I suspect, was in the lead because of his success with How to Succeed in Business . . . on Broadway.
Tuesday, April 20, 2010
Waking Up and Breaking Up
For years, now, I've just been on the edge. It doesn't happen at home, outside of actual emergencies, or "at church" in my parish. It doesn't drive me in time spent with friends and family. The fact is, ladies and gentlemen, I've had to come to the grindingly dull conclusion that I am, in fact, profoundly sane and ordinary, with maybe a touch of ADD or Asperger's.
What makes me nuts, and what people see here, is my absolute inability to process or be anything other than baffled by the institutional religion we call Christianity.
I've woken up to realizing that my relationship with "THE CHURCH" is like that with my abusive ex. It consists of keeping me off guard, on the defensive, in a dysfunctional relationship that is codependent, at best, and parasitic, at worst. And it's not just one side, it's the whole thing! Liberal and conservative both are equally bad, and can't be separated, but make the whole structure of the religion of Christianity! It's not the people - I'm not sure they even have and individuality when the whole trumpet call of religion starts - but the religion itself. The conservatives bash me because I'm too soft, the liberals because I'm not loving enough.
Here's the thing. I want the war to be over, and that means fighting it, taking the spoils, dividing the territories and getting on with living.
So, the conservatives tell me I'm awful and warlike and un-Christian, the liberals tell me that I'm crazy and have to talktalktalktalktalk and stay at the table and understand and be kind, and both sides try to grind me into their own image and I actually believed that I was crazy, for a while. But, I'm not the crazy one here. I want an end. I want it over and the reality of an unbridgeable gap recognized and dealt with.
The Church wants other.
I say The Church wants it because, individuals who make up the Body of Christ, lost themselves completely in the Leviathan of The Church. The Church is a shadow creature, with it's own life drawn from millions of unconscious individuals. It lives for its own continuation, nothing else. It doesn't serve Christ - whether Catholic, Protestant, Orthodox, Evangelical, Charismatic - none of it is for Christ because Christ is transformation of the world, and when that transformation occurs, The Church will cease to exist. The Church, this subconcious creation of millions of minds, subconciously kept alive by millions of minds, is interested in war. The conflict hides the stagnation, the inability to bring transformation. Hardening into lines of battle, without ever fighting!, is the way it perpetuates itself, gives a shape to its purposelessness. It's very nature is to generate constant rage and conflict without providing and practical method for moving on and transforming, either the anger or the person whose angry! It provides a plethora of platitudes and vague advice under the names of "Telling the Story," or instruction, but these are nothing but vague observations, as effective to actual practical living as "Be nice!" or "Don't associate with the wrong people!" and as relevant as spats!
Christianity, regardless of denomination, is corrupt in the most literal sense - stagnant, decaying - because it is The Church. The war has to keep going to keep it alive by keeping anyone from noticing it's lack of vitality or purpose, so, any attempt to break the deadlock has to be beaten down. It's devouring us. All of us.
This is why the Desert Fathers took the best of ritual and learning and left the rest and went to the desert. It's too easy to get drawn into the illusory "life" of this institution, which multiplies and splits without growth to generate a veil of conflict.
Transformation can only come when we reject Christianity in favor of Christ - I know that now. There is no war, because the only thing being fought for isn't worth a plug nickel.
I'm not the crazy one, and that's great to finally realize. The futile fighters can have the religion, I'll take the faith, be a good Christian, and I'll grow into Christ, including the passion, the fully human life, shortcomings and all, and, most of all, the decision to transform and actually live. I'm not going to give my soul for this unending, puerile Hell of slap-fighting.
What makes me nuts, and what people see here, is my absolute inability to process or be anything other than baffled by the institutional religion we call Christianity.
I've woken up to realizing that my relationship with "THE CHURCH" is like that with my abusive ex. It consists of keeping me off guard, on the defensive, in a dysfunctional relationship that is codependent, at best, and parasitic, at worst. And it's not just one side, it's the whole thing! Liberal and conservative both are equally bad, and can't be separated, but make the whole structure of the religion of Christianity! It's not the people - I'm not sure they even have and individuality when the whole trumpet call of religion starts - but the religion itself. The conservatives bash me because I'm too soft, the liberals because I'm not loving enough.
Here's the thing. I want the war to be over, and that means fighting it, taking the spoils, dividing the territories and getting on with living.
So, the conservatives tell me I'm awful and warlike and un-Christian, the liberals tell me that I'm crazy and have to talktalktalktalktalk and stay at the table and understand and be kind, and both sides try to grind me into their own image and I actually believed that I was crazy, for a while. But, I'm not the crazy one here. I want an end. I want it over and the reality of an unbridgeable gap recognized and dealt with.
The Church wants other.
I say The Church wants it because, individuals who make up the Body of Christ, lost themselves completely in the Leviathan of The Church. The Church is a shadow creature, with it's own life drawn from millions of unconscious individuals. It lives for its own continuation, nothing else. It doesn't serve Christ - whether Catholic, Protestant, Orthodox, Evangelical, Charismatic - none of it is for Christ because Christ is transformation of the world, and when that transformation occurs, The Church will cease to exist. The Church, this subconcious creation of millions of minds, subconciously kept alive by millions of minds, is interested in war. The conflict hides the stagnation, the inability to bring transformation. Hardening into lines of battle, without ever fighting!, is the way it perpetuates itself, gives a shape to its purposelessness. It's very nature is to generate constant rage and conflict without providing and practical method for moving on and transforming, either the anger or the person whose angry! It provides a plethora of platitudes and vague advice under the names of "Telling the Story," or instruction, but these are nothing but vague observations, as effective to actual practical living as "Be nice!" or "Don't associate with the wrong people!" and as relevant as spats!
Christianity, regardless of denomination, is corrupt in the most literal sense - stagnant, decaying - because it is The Church. The war has to keep going to keep it alive by keeping anyone from noticing it's lack of vitality or purpose, so, any attempt to break the deadlock has to be beaten down. It's devouring us. All of us.
This is why the Desert Fathers took the best of ritual and learning and left the rest and went to the desert. It's too easy to get drawn into the illusory "life" of this institution, which multiplies and splits without growth to generate a veil of conflict.
Transformation can only come when we reject Christianity in favor of Christ - I know that now. There is no war, because the only thing being fought for isn't worth a plug nickel.
I'm not the crazy one, and that's great to finally realize. The futile fighters can have the religion, I'll take the faith, be a good Christian, and I'll grow into Christ, including the passion, the fully human life, shortcomings and all, and, most of all, the decision to transform and actually live. I'm not going to give my soul for this unending, puerile Hell of slap-fighting.
Bitterness
I realize, as I read about the Global South Encounter, that I truly hate these people.
I see no good in them, whatsoever, and any good deeds they've done cannot, for me, ever wipe out the evil deeds they've done. In fact, anything charitable they may have done I would regard with suspicion. I can not possibly have love for these people. They are evil.
I desire Peace, Oneness with God, with the Ultimate, and this view of other humans is no good for that. What can one say when The Church, the very institution purporting to follow and emulate God, steals Peace and Harmony, leaving only confusion and fear and hate? Is there any good in this?
I look at what happened this past weekend. These are two people who are not particularly "church-going" types. We're pretty vulgar and secular when together. I met them at church, yet friendship has nothing to do with that, developing in spite of, rather than because of, church. No one in my church has helped me, or even offered advice as they have. I've seen nothing but hate and spite in the larger church. "Orthodox" Christianity is the least loving, most horrific vision I've ever seen - a religion of devils, designed to destroy and lay waste and pervert. Yet, progressive Christianity, which I believe is the only real Christianity, is weak and feeble and survives only in a most tenuous way.
I feel nothing but anger and confusion from my religion, and that harms my spirituality. I feel abused by both sides, frankly. Perhaps it would be best if we left the "religion" to them. Cut ourselves off from them, and from those who insist it is our duty to stay with them, and get on with it. No church can be the Body of Christ. Of this, I'm now certain.
I see no good in them, whatsoever, and any good deeds they've done cannot, for me, ever wipe out the evil deeds they've done. In fact, anything charitable they may have done I would regard with suspicion. I can not possibly have love for these people. They are evil.
I desire Peace, Oneness with God, with the Ultimate, and this view of other humans is no good for that. What can one say when The Church, the very institution purporting to follow and emulate God, steals Peace and Harmony, leaving only confusion and fear and hate? Is there any good in this?
I look at what happened this past weekend. These are two people who are not particularly "church-going" types. We're pretty vulgar and secular when together. I met them at church, yet friendship has nothing to do with that, developing in spite of, rather than because of, church. No one in my church has helped me, or even offered advice as they have. I've seen nothing but hate and spite in the larger church. "Orthodox" Christianity is the least loving, most horrific vision I've ever seen - a religion of devils, designed to destroy and lay waste and pervert. Yet, progressive Christianity, which I believe is the only real Christianity, is weak and feeble and survives only in a most tenuous way.
I feel nothing but anger and confusion from my religion, and that harms my spirituality. I feel abused by both sides, frankly. Perhaps it would be best if we left the "religion" to them. Cut ourselves off from them, and from those who insist it is our duty to stay with them, and get on with it. No church can be the Body of Christ. Of this, I'm now certain.
Monday, April 19, 2010
Blessedness
This past weekend, my friend James came down, and brought his brother over.
Now, I know his brother, but not well, and certainly not with the intensity of friendship I share with James. So, it was a real surprise to me when the two of them repaired the hole in my roof that I had not been able to afford to. Their sweat - I was fairly useless - and work did this for me, with nothing asked in return and no sign of resentment or joyless duty.
The sheer enormity of it - a close friend doing such a thing is unusual enough, but a relative stranger, a mere friendly acquaintance, doing so much as well is amazing - leaves me speechless, and the Grace behind it moves me beyond the ability to express in the words of this world and life.
That I, so undeserving, should receive such love and kindness.
Now, I know his brother, but not well, and certainly not with the intensity of friendship I share with James. So, it was a real surprise to me when the two of them repaired the hole in my roof that I had not been able to afford to. Their sweat - I was fairly useless - and work did this for me, with nothing asked in return and no sign of resentment or joyless duty.
The sheer enormity of it - a close friend doing such a thing is unusual enough, but a relative stranger, a mere friendly acquaintance, doing so much as well is amazing - leaves me speechless, and the Grace behind it moves me beyond the ability to express in the words of this world and life.
That I, so undeserving, should receive such love and kindness.
Thursday, April 15, 2010
SHAKUJO IT TO ME, BABY!
Wednesday, April 14, 2010
Crazy - It's Not Just For Nigeria, Anymore!

This is orang-worthy news:
Apparently, former Archbishop of Canterbury Carey is not pleased with how the legal system in his nation works, when it doesn't give him what he wants.
He's decided that Christians (his kind of Christian, at least) must receive a trial only by other Christians (his kind of Christian, at least).
There we have it. Sharia Law. The one thing missing from right-wing "christianity" to make it radical Islam. Congratulations on your meltdown!
On a completely unrelated note:

(The problem is - that's a Buddhist monk's staff)
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)


