Tuesday, April 20, 2010

Waking Up and Breaking Up

For years, now, I've just been on the edge. It doesn't happen at home, outside of actual emergencies, or "at church" in my parish. It doesn't drive me in time spent with friends and family. The fact is, ladies and gentlemen, I've had to come to the grindingly dull conclusion that I am, in fact, profoundly sane and ordinary, with maybe a touch of ADD or Asperger's.

What makes me nuts, and what people see here, is my absolute inability to process or be anything other than baffled by the institutional religion we call Christianity.

I've woken up to realizing that my relationship with "THE CHURCH" is like that with my abusive ex. It consists of keeping me off guard, on the defensive, in a dysfunctional relationship that is codependent, at best, and parasitic, at worst. And it's not just one side, it's the whole thing! Liberal and conservative both are equally bad, and can't be separated, but make the whole structure of the religion of Christianity! It's not the people - I'm not sure they even have and individuality when the whole trumpet call of religion starts - but the religion itself. The conservatives bash me because I'm too soft, the liberals because I'm not loving enough.

Here's the thing. I want the war to be over, and that means fighting it, taking the spoils, dividing the territories and getting on with living.

So, the conservatives tell me I'm awful and warlike and un-Christian, the liberals tell me that I'm crazy and have to talktalktalktalktalk and stay at the table and understand and be kind, and both sides try to grind me into their own image and I actually believed that I was crazy, for a while. But, I'm not the crazy one here. I want an end. I want it over and the reality of an unbridgeable gap recognized and dealt with.

The Church wants other.

I say The Church wants it because, individuals who make up the Body of Christ, lost themselves completely in the Leviathan of The Church. The Church is a shadow creature, with it's own life drawn from millions of unconscious individuals. It lives for its own continuation, nothing else. It doesn't serve Christ - whether Catholic, Protestant, Orthodox, Evangelical, Charismatic - none of it is for Christ because Christ is transformation of the world, and when that transformation occurs, The Church will cease to exist. The Church, this subconcious creation of millions of minds, subconciously kept alive by millions of minds, is interested in war. The conflict hides the stagnation, the inability to bring transformation. Hardening into lines of battle, without ever fighting!, is the way it perpetuates itself, gives a shape to its purposelessness. It's very nature is to generate constant rage and conflict without providing and practical method for moving on and transforming, either the anger or the person whose angry! It provides a plethora of platitudes and vague advice under the names of "Telling the Story," or instruction, but these are nothing but vague observations, as effective to actual practical living as "Be nice!" or "Don't associate with the wrong people!" and as relevant as spats!

Christianity, regardless of denomination, is corrupt in the most literal sense - stagnant, decaying - because it is The Church. The war has to keep going to keep it alive by keeping anyone from noticing it's lack of vitality or purpose, so, any attempt to break the deadlock has to be beaten down. It's devouring us. All of us.

This is why the Desert Fathers took the best of ritual and learning and left the rest and went to the desert. It's too easy to get drawn into the illusory "life" of this institution, which multiplies and splits without growth to generate a veil of conflict.

Transformation can only come when we reject Christianity in favor of Christ - I know that now. There is no war, because the only thing being fought for isn't worth a plug nickel.

I'm not the crazy one, and that's great to finally realize. The futile fighters can have the religion, I'll take the faith, be a good Christian, and I'll grow into Christ, including the passion, the fully human life, shortcomings and all, and, most of all, the decision to transform and actually live. I'm not going to give my soul for this unending, puerile Hell of slap-fighting.

6 comments:

johnskytalker said...

Wow, Mark! I love what you've written (well, most of it). I think you've touched some important truths about the condition of The Church. Breaking up is tough, but the wounds heal with time, as you know.

How do you mean "be a Christian"? I broke up with the Christian church about 6-7 years ago, and could not imagine calling myself a Christian again, for any reason short of political cover in a State-enforced religious context. I'm quite content, even happy, to consider myself an atheist. After 36 to 37 years of life in Christianity, I walked away and am glad I did.

MarkBrunson said...

I think, Skywirelynx, you are likely to be disappointed with me, as I cannot say that I am an atheist, nor would I, short of the reasons you would call yourself a Christian.

To me, to be a true Christian is to follow Jesus and be transformed into a Christ. I see very little in the actual record of Jesus that reflects the ornamentation the church - as institution - has put on him. He didn't set himself up as the one-and-only-magic-demi-god, but as the man (Son of Man) who pointed us toward our own innate potential.

Human consciousness has outgrown the necessary stage of seeing Jesus as the big protector, the mother bird that we just sit and wait with open mouths for, but the institution of church has not. It once served a great purpose, building hospitals, providing social services, creating schools and universities. It still does that, but it's like a senile old man who keeps painting over the same spot while others finish painting the house! Those things are being done - more effectively, in most instances - by others.

I won't sit and argue the innate evil of "church," as, I believe, it has brought positive change. What I argue with is that, now the change has been brought, and we've climbed to a large extent out of the stink and blood savagery of the Dark Ages, it stays doing the same thing, which, frankly, is no longer where Humanity's consciousness is at. Thus, wars began in the church, which spread and spread, and, ironically, began to drag down the same consciousness it helped build up.

It's a river that's been dammed, a room sealed and shuttered. Yet, it has a power - a sort of Ellulian consciousness that perpetuates itself in the "always-done-it-this-way" fashion. We are a world of so much interaction, now, and can learn so much from one another, and the church still squats apart and uncommunicative - nothing can be learned, nothing can be gained, our little empire is perfect and must never change. Our consciences drive us to cosmetic change - gays in the clergy, women's equality - but we can't explain it because that requires looking outside, and, without the outside "fresh air" the change is glacial and confused and simply chaotic.

I know of only two who have embodied a true reaching across mindsets and dogma, both religious: Thomas Merton and Thich Nhat Hahn, both of whom grew and enriched their own truest selves, without falling into some chaotic loss of way.

Thought for the day: Why is "syncretism" a bad word?

johnskytalker said...

Mark,

Thank you for taking time to reply to my comments. Being a Christian as you describe it--to follow Jesus and be transformed into a Christ--is actually not disappointing to me. My own past with Christianity would prevent me for the time being from identifying myself as a Christian in that way, but I can certainly applaud it in another. In a strange way, my atheism and your redefinition of Christianity are very much alike. I also think we share similar views about the ways in which the church has benefited humanity. I identify myself as an atheist primarily, I think, because the God I grew up with is no longer a God I can believe in.

To me the accumulated evidence from science (in the broadest sense) exposes the Christian bible thoroughly as a book written by people, and not, as it claims to be, a book inspired by "the God of all wisdom and knowledge". After years of literal interpretation and sincere faith the only option the Christianity I knew offered me was complete rejection. There was no room to redefine Jesus as "the man...who pointed us toward our own innate potential" or to allow the Church to slip into the pages of history as an institution that had simply outlived its usefulness in the upward development of humanity. If there had been, perhaps I would still consider myself a Christian today.

For a while some years ago I attended an Episcopal church, so I read with interest your entry posting recent comments from Bishop Scott Benhase on the Reverend Canon Mary Glasspool. The Bishop sounds like a good man.

Best regards,
John (aka Skywirelynx)

Bradley said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
MarkBrunson said...

John,

Good to hear from you again!

I'm sorry to hear your story, which, to my frustration and anger, is becoming a very familiar one. I find it a tragedy because the very people driving people to lose a belief in God are the people who claim to treasure the Scriptures most - the same Scriptures which speak scathingly of those who drive people from God! It's also the reason for my often poorly-to-un-controlled rage at so-called conservative Christians.

Still, I've felt similar disenchantment with liberal churches which become dogmatic in their liberalism - about what constitutes being liberal and worthwhile - and engage "the World" only on their own terms just as surely as the Southern-Baptisty Southern Baptists I've ever known! In the end, I believe dogma is a symptom, a symptom of a straitjacketed worldview that supports a particular institution. I won't say anymore at present, because high winds kept me awake all day (I work at night), and I express myself poorly at the best of times; all I could do is wind up being confusing and probably insulting to all parties!

I would agree with your view of the Bible. I tend to take an approach which is more akin to Buddhist or Taoist advice which is to test what's written against itself, reality and what our own hearts and minds find underneath, then take away what is useful. Still, I don't want you to think I'm arguing theology or making an attempt to convert you; I respect your view, and your willingness to engage, and my personal belief is that those who seek to do good to the best of their light and ability are following God, whether they believe in God or not - not in a triumphalist sense, but in the sense that I cannot imagine that good returns null and void because you didn't get in the right line!

MarkBrunson said...

Bradley,

I think you meant that comment about Paul Lynde and Jonathan Winters to be on the post above this one about The Loved One. I copied it and moved it up there, so your post starts, basically, "MarkBrunson said . . . Bradley said . . ." so it's all hearsay anyhow. :D