Tuesday, March 13, 2007

Words I Enjoy

Labrador
Varsouviana
Recondite
Prestidigitation
Hurdy-gurdy
Lapland
Hamantaschen
Ahasueris
Filbert
Palimpsest

Those Who Risk for Love

MP has asked that we spread this letter across the blogsphere, and I, for one, am glad to and acknowledge my gratitude.

AN OPEN LETTER TO THE CHURCH
Conversion of St. Paul, 2007

Dear Sisters and Brothers in Christ,

As you are no doubt aware, our church finds itself in a turbulent, confusing, and painful time. Many issues are involved in our current struggles: authority, hermeneutics, ethical and theological visions and convictions, and the complex relationships of gender, power, and patriarchy. Though the “presenting issue” is the place of LGBTT folk in the Body of Christ, the roots of our conflict go much deeper.

As a priest in the midst of this struggle, it has become clear to me after much prayer and soul-searching, that my spiritual conscience can no longer abide by the laws which I am required to uphold in regard to the blessing of same-sex unions and marriages. It is my conviction that our current ban on such practices is theologically problematic and fundamentally unjust. Upholding such a position (even unwillingly) forces me to bend severely (if not break) my priestly vows, my baptismal covenant, and the Word of God inscribed within my heart. I therefore publicly declare that I will, when requested, officiate at same-sex marriages and offer blessing upon committed same sex unions. I will no longer discriminate against homosexual people when it comes to the exercise of my priestly duties.

I am aware, of course, that the stance I am taking will likely lead to serious consequences, and I am prepared to face these consequences openly and publicly. It may be helpful to consider my action a form of ecclesiastical civil disobedience. With conflict and rhetoric rising in the worldwide communion, too many queer brothers and sisters are being further marginalized and excluded. In some parts of the world, this takes the form of outright violence: as I write, the coordinator of Changing Attitude (a sister organization of Integrity) in Nigeria is living under a death threat from his “fellow Christians”. Here at home, it is often a more subtle form of oppression: exclusion rendered invisible. As a priest and leader in the church, my complicity in upholding our current law makes me at least partially responsible for the ongoing suffering of LGBTT Christians, and I can no longer take part in that. If my current action helps render visible that which has been made invisible, then I will be happy to bear the consequences. I too will stand “outside the gate”, where so many other queer Christians have been sent.

To be clear, there are three main reasons for my choice of taking this stance. On one level, this is a clear issue of justice, solidarity, and human rights. On another level, this is an issue of evangelism: our church’s continuing discrimination against LGBTT people is a scandal which keeps many of my peers from being able to hear the good news of Jesus. And finally, this is an issue of personal integrity: I can no longer, in good conscience, uphold a law which I consider unjust, as well as theologically deficient.

Some might say that my actions sidestep the legitimate process of discernment underway in the church. I understand that concern, and I have wrestled long and hard over what to do, working within our established canons and structures to the best of my ability. However, I also see my current course of action as being part of the wider church’s discernment. We have heard many arguments about the cost of blessing same-sex marriages and ordaining unclosetted queer folk; we also need to recognize that there is a cost as well to not moving in this direction. The cost is a huge amount of suffering for LGBTT Christians who are pressured to remain silent. The cost is that some of us, straight and gay, will no longer be able to abide the status quo, and we will simply cease to obey an unjust law. The cost is that others will quietly leave. That reality needs to be part of our church’s discernment. In this, I am not leaving the church, nor relinquishing my orders. Instead, I offer my current action, with all its consequences, for the ongoing discernment of the Body.

Yours in the unquiet peace of Christ,


The Rev. Shawn Sanford Beck

Thank you, Fr. Beck.

Monday, March 12, 2007

Look What They Done!

I'm angry!
No. Not about Matt Kennedy, alleged priest of the alleged church of The Good Shepherd (who must be regretting giving His name on that one) -- you can find Kennedy's mockery and public foolishness on Stand Fallacious.
I'm angry about something serious.
They've desecrated my beloved Persians.
I've always had a thing about the ancient Persian Empire -- you know, the ones who also worshipped One God and basically kept the Middle East for the last time in history? And then, this, this movie! 300 -- the usual rah-rah, chest-thumping, frat-boy "heroism" you've come to expect from Frank Miller - who attracts a sophisticated enough audience in his graphic novels to get the complexities of his vision. Movies attract a less sophisticated crowd, and that, my friends, is why I'm angry that they brought 300 to life.
Some lessons, to prevent the l.c.d. amongst moviegoers from assuming 300 is history:
The Spartans were terrible people.
Compared to the Persians, the Spartans were barely people at all.
Xerxes, though a jerk, was not a complete jerk, and the sadly predictable result of a privileged life, while his father, Darius, and grandfather, Cyrus, were geniuses.
Leonidas was a brute.
This is Xerxes



This is not a Persian emperor:

This is a Persian emperor:
This is not a Persian Immortal:

This is a Persian Immortal:

Finally, and MOST EGREGIOUSLY . . .


This is NOT NOT NOT HOW RODRIGO SANTORO IS SUPPOSED TO LOOK!





This IS how Rodrigo Santoro is supposed to look, not like Ru-Paul on crack.


Sorry, but it needed to be said.






























Friday, March 9, 2007

Disappointments All Around

Grandmere Mimi wrote about her "Windsor Bishop" on her blog, Wounded Bird.
http://thewoundedbird.blogspot.com/index.html

I find myself deeply disappointed in my diocese, as well. The Diocese of Georgia has "committed" us, in our last convention, to working on this increasingly unpalatable Communion. Like the other "good folks" out there, I hear no condemnation from them, through our Deputies or our Bishop, for Akinola's support of Nigeria's monstrous anti-gay legislation (http://politicalspaghetti.blogspot.com/2007/02/passage-imminent-i.html, for a debriefing).

I have contacted both the Presiding Bishop's and the Diocesan Bishop's offices, asking for some explanation on all sides, some balance of the pros and cons of all that came out of Tanzania. I've begged to hear someone talk to us rather than at us about this. Wondered why we have heard no reproof at the blatant disregard for our church and its members by the ABC and the rest of the Primates.

So far, I have received no reply from my bishop, though it is a large diocese, to be fair, and he is active in making personal visitations. I'm still holding out hope to hear.

From the PB's office, I received this reply:

Dear Friend:

I am writing on behalf of the Presiding Bishop to thank you very much for youremail. On Friday the Presiding Bishop held a community gathering with EpiscopalChurch Center staff to discuss the Primates' Meeting in Tanzania. For your convenience I am copying into the body of this message an article fromEpiscopal News Service regarding the Friday gathering, and a link to the mp3file may be found by navigating this link:http://www.episcopalchurch.org/3577_82812_ENG_HTM.htm. Please know that this comes with the Presiding Bishop's prayers and best wishes for you during this time in the life of the church.

Very truly yours,
Robert B. Goodfellow
Communications Aide

Bland, thy name is Goodfellow. I've communicated since, receiving no reply. You'll find this person's email below in "Once More Unto the Breach" -- my hope being that, if we simply flood him with enough requests for clarification, continue pestering for real info and not spin, someone may give us the info out of sheer frustration and annoyance.

I don't know which would be more depressing, to think that my diocese and my bishop, my brothers and sisters, agree with Akinola, et al, or are simply trying to preserve some presence in an increasingly meaningless and absurdly comical bit of conceit allowing us to, as we have been accused of doing by the RCC, "play at being Catholics."

Neither position speaks of the maturity of our church and its witness.

Thursday, March 8, 2007

Maturity of Faith?

It seems to me that a mark of maturity (and I'm certainly not claiming any great measure of maturity for myself) is the ability to tolerate uncertainty, tension, disagreement, even conflict. I'm not talking of hopeless confusion, on the one hand, nor a dead resignation on the other. Rather, I'm talking of the ability to pick a way through life's multiplicity and facticity in a way that is authentic, that has integrity, while recognizing our own limitations and the possibilities within others, even in the face of conflicting beliefs.

Anyone who has studied adolescent behavior, or, for that matter, dealt with or been an adolescent, knows that a part of that developmental stage is a need for certainty coupled with a passionate defense of one's own understanding as the only, or at least, best certainty. There is little tolerance in most adolescents for differing opinion, and passionate defense -- to the point of stormy and melodramatic displays -- of one's understanding is typical. This is a good and necessary part of development. It allows the adolescent psyche to seek a stable platform from which to operate while in the process of differentiation from the parents, thus facilitating the development of a more secure individual for the future. At the same time we respect that development, though, we recognize it is not a stable way to form a society. It's why we restrict the voting age, why we have ages of consent and allow for an adult to have custody of a youth who is physically capable of caring for and providing for him/herself.

Yet, Christianity has historically not given its own structures the same consideration. One needs only to read any theologian, including (perhaps especially) the Church Fathers, to see a sort of adolescent brashness. Edith Pargeter, writing as Ellis Peters, noted in one of her Cadfael mysteries that theologians seemed more intent on discrediting and deriding opposing theologians than on glorifying God. The Church, in its structure and traditions, has attempted to grasp at God, to encapsulate and delimit God's activity and structure Grace in an absolutist, closed system. Again, this is necessary to support the maturing of Christian faith, but, should such a mindset be allowed to define the Christian religion? We protect our socio-economic systems, our political systems, from the excesses and perversions that arise from such artificial certainty, recognizing that these systems must be an adult contract. At the same time, we give over our faith systems to the loudest, brashest and most demanding voice - "Give us Barabbas!!" It would seem we take the care of our money and land far more seriously than the nourishment of our souls.

Tuesday, March 6, 2007

A Long Slog

That's what my mother used to call a particularly difficult stretch of road, work . . . life.

This is a long slog in the church for me.

It's confession time, so if open emotions embarrass you, please look away.

During all of this, I have actually come to the point that I've hoped and, paradoxically, prayed that I would be able to simply lose my faith. You see, if that happened, I would be able to move on, stop caring what "those wacky Christians" are up to, because it would mean nothing in any case.

But I can't. I need God.

I've prayed to be able to simply walk away. To forget the whole damned thing, and move on.

But I can't. I need God's people, my parish family.

I've prayed, finally, to simply not wake up. Don't worry. I'm not suicidal. It's simply that I am that tired, heartsick, and soulsick.

I have to admit that, even though I will not, cannot, give up in this struggle in the church's history, I have been damaged. Maybe I've damaged others. The worst part is the bitterness within myself, the lost serenity I once knew in prayer, the constant anger, even hate. The sense of betrayal in others . . . and self. Maybe it's just me. Maybe I'm just too weak.

Maybe . . .

This is Gethsemane.

We've certainly seen our Caiaphas, who's said it's better for this one group to die than the Anglican Communion be destroyed. We've had our Pilate who's washed her hands because it would put her up against it politically to do what is just. We have had a Judas or two, telling us we're loved, kissing us to betray us and deliver us up to destruction in return for a payment of greater power in the communion. The Sanhedrin met in Tanzania, and, though the evidence was lacking, we were still convicted. You must enter to win. But Christ entered the tomb to win. Maybe . . .

. . well, I'm depressed. Can you blame me?

What the Hell is Wrong With This Man?!

Rowan's produced another nugget. Apparently, he's determined to either force us down or force us out.

http://www.archbishopofcanterbury.org/releases/070305.htm

A conservative on Thinking Anglicans spoke of our democratic polity with derision, and suggested that, if the consent of the governed in our church is to be sought, we can remove the word "episcopal."

If this increasingly monstrous ultimatum and its toxic fallout is approved by our leadership, then we have no leadership, and we can, indeed, remove the episcopal. A bishop is a pastor, not just upper management, and to accept this is breaking the pastoral relationship. To that end, if this is agreed to, we need to withhold all contributions. The worker deserves his wages, the one leaning on the shovel does not.

Tell the PB that this has to be a "no thanks."