Tuesday, January 3, 2012

Why Libertarianism and Tea Partiers Won't Work

Because they already failed. 

Victorian England was exactly what they are proposing, when you see Gingrich and Paul and Bachmann and Romneybot 5000. 

Here's how it actually worked - or actually didn't - since history is learning, thus discouraged by the state under the United States of Business Owners:

Most people don't know about the Poor Laws - reformed Poor Laws, actually - under the Victorian reign.  When I see a complete nincompoop who was able to buy an economics degree write a defense of Scrooge's business practices, and the very employment policies Dickens exposed as evil and destructive lauded, I realize how abysmally ignorant - no, stupid - the American public really is. 

When I was a child, I just knew Dickens was being OTT.  After all, we don't have places you can go to if you're unemployed and homeless and receive clothing, shelter and food.  It sounds really kind of the state.  No doubt, Ron Paul and the mindless hordes and the parasitic business owners feel the same. 

Now, what I know now is this:  Dickens was underplaying it. 

Oliver Twist's gruel, and no second bowl - absolutely accurate, except that much gruel would've been a luxury.  You see, it was decided by businessmen posing as concerned citizens that the previously fairly generous system of work houses and public assistance was being abused and savings made - and, more importantly, the taxes of the wealthy lowered - by reforming the Poor Laws. 

Under this reform, to discourage the indolent from sponging off the state ("I don't want my money going to taxes to feed lazy bums!"), conditions were required to be worse - yes worse - than the worst job found in England . . . not the region, mind you, but England.  Now, you might think that there were kind Workhouse Unions and charitable parishes that gave extra and made a better living condition in some workhouses.  That's because you're not paying attention.  Conditions were required to be worse - worse diet, worse clothing, worse working conditions, worse shelter.  It was against the law to make it better.  Think of some of the jobs in the Merrye Olde England of Victoria - yes, crossing sweeper, night-soil man, ragman, rat-catcher, match girl all count as official jobs - and how luxurious their conditions were, then . . . lower it.  That was what the law required - to, you know, keep those fat, lazy non-employer types from stealing the money of rich, upstanding, generous employer types through taxes, regardless, of course, of whether any jobs actually were available.  Now, yes, in truth, some did get slightly better conditions - because there were also laws governing the acceptable number of deaths and level of starvation and disease in workhouses, no doubt those wonderful capitalists' generosity and compassion again.  "Many would rather die than go there"  becomes less melodramatic and more understandable, and the response becomes more telling - the parasites that drive capitalism, the business owner and employer, only want just enough walking meat to be productive and make jobs scarce . . . the rest are surplus population.  Malthus would've been horrified to hear his views so used, as I believe Darwin, Marx and a good many others would be.

And here's the interesting part - England was not under absolute rule, had a representative (however limited) government, and this still went on.  Why?  Because everyone was told how lazy and cunning and unworthy the "so-called poor" were, and didn't bother to look any further.

Ah, Dickensian America.  What a vision, huh?
 

By the way:

Pluralist gets it.

No comments: