Monday, October 3, 2011

Paul Schmaul

I'm sorry, I still don't trust St. Paul. 

My suspicious nature asks, if I were trying to bring down an underground movement that's spreading despite my best efforts, what would I do?  Take it down from inside.  Make myself the spokesman for that movement.  We know Paul was "zealous for the law," so the idea that it's laughable for him to have given his life in that fashion is null and void;  zealots will do anything to further their goal.  It's Paul who moved Christianity farther from Judaism and made such effort to focus it's message away from the central locus of Judaism and establish (abandon?) it among the Gentiles. 

This is, of course, merely my thinking.  What is fact, however, is the frightening worship of Paul which has become part and parcel of Christianity.  We would not consider ordaining a wildly enthusiastic brand-new convert to the priesthood, but Paul is given - according to him, primarily - equal place with the disciples.  The inclusion of his writings in the canon does not impress me, frankly, as the Holy Spirit can move and it still be ignored.  I'm alarmed by the fact that we have a dual deity, not a Triune God, as there is the One God embodied in Christ, and Paul, who's writings - so quick to show fury and disdain and self-absorption - even liberal theologians feel are co-equal, if not more authoritative, than the recorded sayings of Jesus.  Even conservative evangelicals who tout a "clear meaning of Scripture" will, when faced with a bald statement by Jesus, then go off to tell you what He really meant, because Paul said so.

No.  I grant that Paul shows the ineffability of God's work, as there are beautiful passages and good works have come out of - despite it's basically sour nature - Paul's writings.  I will not, however, grant Paul the level of worshipful respect that the institutional church traditionally has.  He's simply not that impressive, and exactly the sort of self-aggrandizing "theologian" that still causes problems.

2 comments:

JCF said...

I heard a preacher once (critically) describe Paul as "having gone from being Jewish Pharisee to being a Christian one."

MarkBrunson said...

That's just it, JCF!

He's still a Pharisee, whatever his reasons for "conversion."

I guess that I've too much experience down here in the South with Baptists or Pentecostals, whatever, becoming SUCH. ENTHUSIASTIC. NEW. CONVERTS! Oh, they just love TEC . . . except do we have to let women up there near the altar? Can't we have a few services with plain clothes and speaking in tongues? Can't we just preach and leave out some of the mumbo-jumbo? Can't we just preach the literal King James Bible? Can't we just not worry about seminaries and let God choose our preacher? Hmmm?

They were never converts to The Episcopal Church, but to the pretty candles and novelty of structured liturgy and worship. In short, they believe fervently in the selfish enjoyment of the externals, as long as they can make it comfortable for their personal beliefs, as well.

Generally, they drift away, but, if not, they become those screaming what Anglicanism "really" is and "really" was and "really" will always be and we've strayed and . . . well, you get the picture. It just depends how selfish they are about enjoying the pretty show.