Thursday, September 15, 2011

Further

I don't mean to say that there is no value in prayer, or that God is remote to a mechanistic universe.  Indeed, I believe He acts through us, and prayer has its value as action. 

What we call theology, though, is this world of mental nonsense, presuming to dissect and disclose a mind that none can comprehend, then distill and standardize answers to "Why?"  That, to put it bluntly, is mental masturbation of the sort which has made a profession out of an avocation - rather like the legal profession, it has set its own ground rules which profess its indespensibility to belief and practice, all because of a self-invented and self-perpetuating insinuation into society. 

The one really clear answer that God gave as to Divine Being is "I am."  More accurately translated, "I shall be howsoever I shall be."  It's a name of verbs that combine being and time.  The claim that Jesus showed us who God really is is short-sighted, as one sees that God really is what part of Jesus one focuses on - Jesus loved/Jesus condemned; Jesus taught/Jesus obscured; Jesus embraced/Jesus rejected; Jesus affirmed/Jesus denied.  Why?  Because the central reality of God that Jesus embodied is that He Is as He Is.  That's it.  We are as we are - so do what you can do, take responsibility for that, act as the situation calls for, and stop playing around in your head.  God is.  Man is and God Is through man.  There's no different angle, no bureaucrat's stamp, no trickety-trick that's going to reveal the Divine Totality to you.  You can't pigeonhole reality, and God IS through reality. 

When will the Kingdom come?  When we do it.  When will the world end and the Eternal Blackness of the Pit fall?  When we do it. 

4 comments:

June Butler said...

When will the Kingdom come? When we do it.

Of course!

Perhaps the mental nonsense of theology provides part of the motivation for getting out there to do our small part to build the kingdom, but that's only the beginning. Thinking and talking, without deeds, will contribute little toward the establishment of the kingdom.

For now we see in a mirror, dimly, but then we will see face to face. Now I know only in part; then I will know fully, even as I have been fully known.

I agree with Paul.

MarkBrunson said...

A little silliness, now and then, is treasured by the wisest men - but the churches have made a profession of it; canon law fiddliness, endless speculation on the nature of God, it's not just nonsense, but destructive and distracting. God happens here, not in the publishing house, just like we do.

The endless parsing of Scripture and sermons for insight into the Mind that is unfathomable is not helpful, and dangerous when it becomes its own self-justifying and self-perpetuating industry.

David Shepherd said...

Well said, Mark. However, we are now the new rag-tag bunch of misfits that follow Christ without a 'discerned' vocation. Outsiders, who truly see in Jesus the opportunity of a lifetime, but need the same lifetime to sort out our prejudices, mistakes, power cravings and foibles.

When the Kingdom of God is reduced to forming an educational elite who spend their time in mean-spirited arguments about precisely worded logic...Oops, guilty as charged, but it did feel like a whole lot of brain-power was going down the drain. Surely, it was just another mental challenge: a spiritual Rubik's cube? How blasphemous.

So, I'll go out and buy a portable first-aid kit, just like the ones that Samaritan used to carry. You never know who might fall among thieves today.

And it might just be more useful in fixing situations of real harm than the iPad (that I've been trying to justify for on-the-go blogging) and the subscription to award-winning scholarly dissertations on theology that my bishop reads (and in which I had really hoped to be included next year with an honourable mention).

Mea culpa, mate, mea culpa!

MarkBrunson said...

I think, David, that I may be coming across as anti-intellectual. I hope not, but that may be the case. In the same way, I'll probably be seen as utilitarian, but that can't be helped.

True "theology" has a real-world purpose. It's not to stroke our egos, or show how cleverly we argue. In a way, I see it in the way that the Orthodox do - a quiet moving toward understanding of my place IN God.

Thinking - any sort - is a food for the mind, an exercise, and a good thing. Thinking of God and our (individual) relation to Him is marvelous and strengthening exercise. However, when it becomes an end in itself, or simply a means of self-gratification . . . well, that's why I use the term mental masturbation (rather than solely for shock value). In truth, many "award-winning" theologians can, in my opinion, be seen as mental prostitutes, seeking to make a profession of so intimate and life-giving a thing.