I've always considered it odd that JRR Tolkien - himself so devout a Roman Catholic as to refuse to abandon Latin responses in the Mass - created Middle Earth as a place of great spirituality, reverence, holiness, full of the power of Divinity, but, largely, religionless. It's not a thing I find unpleasant, but unexpected. The only mentions of an actual religion - organized religion, as opposed to active devotion to and service of Eru and the Valar - is Sauron's imposition of the state religion of Morgoth-worship and human sacrifice.
Perhaps, even an old die-hard RC knew, somewhere, that long ago the question of authority and discernment, so important to the early Christians, was a lever for lesser men to seize power and take authority upon themselves to the exclusion of the Body. It has been so so long that there may be no saving the religion.
As a side-note; if you ever wondered what a temple to Morgoth would look like, Tolkien said that the Radcliffe Camera looked like it:

4 comments:
For all his devotion to the Roman Catholic Church, perhaps Tolkien knew deep in his heart that the followers of Christ were never meant to form a religion.
From Wikipedia:
The Radcliffe Camera (colloquially, "Rad Cam"; "Radder" in 1930s slang[1]) is a building in Oxford, England, designed by James Gibbs in the English Palladian style and built in 1737–1749 to house the Radcliffe Science Library.
Significant?
That it housed the science library?
Perhaps, but I've never gotten from Tolkien's work that he was the sort of rabid anti-science "christian" we see so much of today. He certainly wasn't an anti-intellectual, as he was a professor and one of the things he did truly despise - shown in his depiction of the orcs and their interaction - was the debasement of language and the ravages of work-for-its-own-sake ideals.
Though Tolkien did not use allegory - he professed a deep distrust and disdain for it - it's helpful to look at the complex relationship of science and technology in Middle Earth. The elves, dwarves and wizards - even the men and hobbits - were deeply interested in understanding and working with the principles of the natural world around them. The elves and dwarves developed rather complex and wonderful technologies and devices, and the elves seemed to have regarded what hobbits and men called "magic" as simply another technology. However, in Saruman and Sauron, to a lesser extent Denethor, we see what happens when technology and industry and science become their own ends, without a guiding ethic of reverence and service undergirding their users' intent - when they become an end to self-gratification and power.
That it housed the science library?
Yes, that the temple resembles a science library seems ironic and significant to me, but I could be wrong. I'm not anti-science at all, but I do think there are those who make a god of science, and Tolkien recognized that.
. . I do think there are those who make a god of science, and Tolkien recognized that.
Oh, agreed! I think that that is what Saruman is, to a great degree. Sauron's use of the science of Middle Earth is for power. So is Saruman's, but to a greater degree he just seems enchanted with his own cleverness; "a mind of metal and wheels" as Treebeard noted.
The actual story - which doesn't preclude the subconscious act of connecting the science "god" and the temple - is a bit anti-climactic: Tolkien was walking home and the position of a huge billow of cloud made it seem to issue from the Camera's lantern, and put the idea in his mind.
Post a Comment