There has been, from some of my commenters, a great deal of concern of my choice of words in regards to my socio-economic views.
Unfortunately, such concerns, far from being paranoid or touchy, are warranted these days. People no longer have the ability to discern between violence and graphic imagery, perhaps. I consider that a tragedy, but also a truth.
So, let me be clear: I - in no way - can or will endorse or request or direct or personally enact violence against any individual or group of individuals! This is not the answer! My words were graphic, but metaphoric - not to be acted upon as literal!
My view is that the entire private business sector needs heavy government regulation, and the government must become more directly-controlled by a free populace. This includes the practice of law, which should, ideally, be the province of legal aid solely, not private enterprise. I support entirely the socialization of our medicine. If finance is such a huge and absolutely necessary part of our society, then the society must have a strong say in its running.
I believe this because, first and foremost, the only lasting prosperity is societal prosperity, and the only lasting good is found in community. To that end, we are poised perfectly in this country. We still control the vote, and, by the good graces of the internet, can use one voice to connect with others and influence the outcome of elections and international affairs. We can sway public opinion, and we are still civilized enough and have enough to lose and gain to operate within law and order. So long as we are part and parcel of the U. S., we profit by self-giving and care for other.
Because I believe in community and holistic wellbeing, I believe this mean that we - none of us - has the right to deprive anyone of societally-responsible livelihood, freedom under legal circumstances, or life under any circumstance.
If any of this has been misunderstood, allow me to state - firmly - that there is no individual or group to "target," no one whose loss will be our win; any "they" out there is a part of our society, our poverty will soon become theirs, their poverty ours, harm to "them" will become harm to "us." Rather, the greed and excess that has become a part of our nation's mindset and the cause of our current financial problems, must be addressed by legal and political means while we have that option, and by exercise of our personal freedom to speak, reason, and persuade. Absolute freedom is nothing left to lose, but we still have much good in this nation's makeup and - above all - people to lose and its preservation is still in our best interest.
I have always believed the only enemies to be defeated were Ignorance and Self-Harm, and that we will defeat these all together or not at all.
I am horrified that anyone could find other in my words, and it has pressed upon me my responsibility.
5 comments:
You write (optimistically, I think) that "We still control the vote." But there's the rub, in my view. A whole bunch of folks are voting ignorantly, controlled by the media, and voting against their own self-interest ... as shown by the large numbers of poor people who vote for the Republicans.
I believe too few people in the U.S. are now able to think critically and analytically. And the under-educated automatons are now voting for their own oppression.
I agree with the thrust of your essay, Mark. But I am terrified by the under-educated people in this country who believe (wrongly) that we have a direct democracy ... and believe they have the right to vote on the rights of others. Which is not how this constitutional republic was established.
Nothing scares me more in the current political milieu than
* the mistaken belief in direct democracy
* the mistaken belief that U.S. legislators are supposed to reflect popular opinion.
In particular, the Constitution established the Senate to be a deliberative body, fairly insulated from popular opinion. And I fear that few Senators understand that's their role.
Uh-Oh! I'm using your blog for my own rant. Sorry.
Ranting on my blog is fine. I frequently do it. This blog is (has been) used for blowing off steam.
When I say "control the vote" I'm not speaking idealistically - I'm an idealist . . . but only sorta.
Demagoguery works. We need to use it. Get control, then we can start curing the "undereducated" problem. As long, of course, as we realize that undereducation isn't necessarily the problem; we lack an ethical core to our country that values one another.
In the meantime, that's why I specifically mention the web - we have to make the voters terrified of the Republicans and the Tea Party. If the voting populace is unthinking, then don't appeal to reason, appeal to fear, catchphrases, slippery slopes, unease, poverty.
I am reminded of a line addressed to Helen Mirren's Elizabeth I in the miniseries:
"Bess, you suffer the defect of the clear-sighted - you believe everyone sees as clearly as you do."
That's the progressive/liberal defect.
We know these people don't think, stop standing outside yelling facts hoping to make them think.
Thanks for that further clarification, Mark. I agree about the need to inform [or, if need be, terrify] the masses. But here's the problem: They're not reading, Mark -- not newspapers, and not blogs. They're just sitting in front of the TV watching Glenn Beck. Alas. :(
Yes, Lisa, so how do we get where they will see us?
They do read - you just have to write in a way that gets their attention. They don't like complex thought, but big words can make them feel smart. It's like fast food - big, filling, hollow calories, little nutrition.
As for what they watch, we may be impressed with our cleverness and satire, but they need something easier to digest. We have people on tv - Jon Stewart, Stephen Colbert and Lewis Black spring immediately to mind. We have to convince them to let go of at least some of the satire and embrace a bit of pure, head-on scaremongering.
Unpleasant? "Beneath us?" Perhaps. Is it better to be unsullied, or to save people? Our "ethicality" on the left has a deep feeling of the big "P" Pride to it.
As for those outside the mainstream media, well, Beck had to start somewhere - he didn't spring full-grown from Fox's temple. Palin started somewhere - and if that bimbo can get on tv, anyone can. All McCain has to put him in the spotlight is a fantastic failure to avoid the enemy and a subsequent failure to die. Believe me, people read editorials and political cartoons. They need bite-sized, easily digestible information-like substances. Manipulation is the only way with minds incapable of grasping anything outside their own desires.
We have to play dirty or accept that we cooperated with the collapse of a civilization that could've been great and noble.
I agree with your diagnosis, Mark. I just don't see a solution. :(
Post a Comment