Tuesday, August 10, 2010

Shu! The Rabbi is Speaking!

Niles Elliot Goldstein is the Rabbi Emeritus of the New Shul.


I believe his understanding of what makes effective worship communities is what I've been feeling and largely unable to articulate.

For Goldstein, the central part of being a worship community is community. This, I believe, is central and obvious in any Judeo-Christian-based religion. Our faith is based in community, yet we have become obsessed with cultic observance and administrative detail, forgetting that those were always only tools to focus the community. The denominations - indeed, the religions themselves - have become juggernauts rolling along with neither vision nor understanding.

If you doubt that, consider your gut response to this:


One thing that has become crystal clear to me is that men and women are looking for communities, not congregations. Most people care very little about denominational labels or theology. Some don’t even care about the institution of religion itself (I know some individuals who actually belong to two or more different congregations of different faiths and move with ease between their respective worship services and programs).

The remarkable thing is that the Rabbi understands this. It is the reality, but more than that, how can one be in community in a group, a community, that doesn't accept or understand them, without some desperate and hollow theological twisting-and-turning to show that, while not "accepting" them, they really do accept them! It's impossible!

Still, as Goldstein points out, the community approach will cause problems as it solves others:


If we can transform congregations into sanctuaries and safe havens, we can begin to offer the shelter that so many people yearn for but cannot seem to find. But then new questions will arise that we must confront:

•With less emphasis on prayer, study, and theology, and more on interpersonal connection and inclusivity, what is it exactly that our spiritual institutions stand for?
•Are we simply giving the people what they want, or are we holding fast to age-old values and principles?
•Is it possible to strike the proper balance between creating innovative projects and initiatives and conserving the traditional pillars of our rich and ancient faiths?

These are difficult questions that are appropriate for these difficult times. In an age of shocking religious extremism, how do we as religious leaders present our respective faith traditions as relevant, meaningful, purpose driven, even edgy?


I encourage you to read all of Goldstein's words. I believe he's on to something. Perhaps, we have to ask whether we want to grow our churches, or spread the good news of our faith, and whether they are rapidly becoming mutually exclusive.