Monday, March 8, 2010

Please, Somebody Help Me

This is an earnest plea.

I don't know what to do, and have no one to talk to who can help in any practical way.

My wages have already been garnished once, and it's ongoing, for student loans. Now, Michigan Guaranty Company is after me - another administrative wage garnishment - for even more. I don't know if they can put one garnishment on top of another, but, given it's government, and finance companies make D.C. their whore, I expect they can.

Yes, I owe the money. Yes, I haven't paid - at least all of it. No, I'm not looking for justice. I'm looking for mercy. I'm useless - I accept that. I simply am so dysfunctional, that I can only possibly eke out a marginal living. I have accepted a future old age in which I will simply struggle as best I can to make ends meet, cause that's my present. I'm not going to say "It's not fair!" because the world isn't. Mercy, someone, please! $244 a week is just enough to live on, even with a home owned and paid for. I have to fix the roof, pay high food, vet, medical and utility rates. And there's only one of me.

I welcome assistance. If it makes me a beggar, well, beggars have a proud history in religion.

I also welcome advice, as long as it's practical. This is why I don't "Talk to your priest!" He can't help. Frankly, seminary teaches very little of any real world use to anyone. "Pray!" is equally pointless. Yes. I believe God helps. Here's how He helps: He made a whole world full of people in His image to help one another. "God will provide!" Yes. He provided you.

Here's things suggested that I already have dismissed:

1) Mortgage the house. It has a lien because of these debts, and the suggestion is still unsound. I can't pay school loans, then I certainly can't make usurious mortgage payments. So, I wind up homeless.

I'VE GOT NO ONE AND NOWHERE TO GO TO BUT ME AND THOSE WHO WILL HELP ME. I've tried to make this clear. Maybe yelling it will help.

2) Get a roommate. No. Just no. I am not being stubborn, but sensible. I've tried it. It drove me to a near psychotic break, living with someone else whom I don't know and trust, and enjoy being around. Seriously. BAD idea. I don't want to go into details, but believe me.

3) Get a part time job as well. Can't. Tried that, too. Look; maybe I'm high maintenance, or just so second-class I deserve to drop through the cracks, but I've accepted I'm "Not right." At the very least, I'm diagnosed with depression that is so low that even my euphoric moments seem simply even. I've never been officially diagnosed, but I'm pretty sure I'm high-spectrum autistic. Add all of it together, you've got someone who's exhausted from a 40-hour work week and is no longer young and is of such a need for solitude he'll go nuts trying to go without time off.

Right now, they've asked for objections to the garnishment. I did that last time, and it was a run-around. I provided copies of six months of receipts and a detailed breakdown which consumed weeks to compile, and I was told there was insufficient evidence and the government went ahead and garnished me, anyway.

I'm useless. I'll never be a great priest, like Jonathan, so I can't claim even that. I'm a charity case, a useless drain on society that Ayn Rand would've gleefully had euthanized. I'm a thinker, and I write these little dribs and drabs, and that is not anything useful to anyone. I wouldn't know how to publish anything, and no one cares to hear folksy advice and insight without a Ph.D. So, all I've got is to ask for mercy. For me, or, if you like, for the cats who depend on me.

I suspect, though, that I'll simply fall through the cracks. I really am that useless, and, since only God cares, that's Who I'll have to be with to be useful, or at least valued.

I'm aware that, having just received this news, I'm panicked. Completely terrified and brought to a halt. My mind is clearer and more active than usual in an emergency - it's not just in animal agony like last time - so, clearly the meditation has been useful. I'll probably be in complete shutdown for a few days. My work, here in the office, lay here. I can't really see it. Trying to force concentration just makes the interior more real, and becomes an overlay obscuring what's really before me. I'm aware of the panicked me, the depressed me, the me scolding my weakness and begging, the me that's weeping as a scared child, and none of it really I, just me. Still, habits die hard, and I am being overwhelmed by "me." I'm aware of the voice that says "St. Francis" as the answer - and, yes, poverty's great, if you can do it. Practically, I know I can't - at least not abject, homeless poverty.

Mercy, someone.

UPDATE 3/10:

James has sent me some information that has been of great assistance, as has TwoAuntees and everyone has been of great help to my morale.

First, a word of explanation:

There seems to be some concern over my emotional state. Naturally, I am frightened, angry, frustrated, depressed and distressed. It is important for me to acknowledge, rather than repress, these realities. It is a grieving process, of sorts. Anyone who did not feel these things in the circumstances would be either in a state of severe psychological repression. The important thing is that I am aware of them, thus able to negotiate my way through them. I am not suicidal. I am not absolutely despondent. I am simply in need of any aid or advice that can be given. This is an emergency, which is why I posted this, not a desperate plea to keep me from doing something foolish. I am aware that, in the past, I have allowed myself to see things as bigger and darker than they are. This is not the case, here. It is a real emergency, and it is solvable. However, it would be foolish to ignore the emotions attached in this case.

Second,

The ground is covered with a thin layer of pollen, and the lead ball in my skull is covered in a thick layer of cotton batting - this makes me seem less rational than I am.

Third,

I believe, for the time, I am allright. There is the Legal Aid Society, and I'm fairly sure that I would qualify for their assistance. There is also a link to attorneys and their requisite pro bono work. I have til April 2 to challenge, based on financial hardship, which will probably fail, as it failed once before in the shadowy and uncommunicative process of Administrative Wage Garnishment.

I am not, however, in immediate danger, as the The National Consumer Law Center's website on Student Loan Assistance has this:

[In] an administrative wage garnishment, the government can take no more than
15% of your disposable wages. No matter what, you get to keep an amount equal to
30 times the minimum wage (now $217.50/week). With Social Security offsets, the
government cannot take SSI payments. They can take Social Security disability or
retirement benefits, but no more than 15% of the total benefit. No matter what,
the first $750/month cannot be taken.

The full explanation, with example, is here ---- Administrative Wage Garnishments.

In the meantime, I will be compiling info to send to the local Legal Aid (I explain myself much better in writing) and will wait to hear what they say. My challenge will postpone the actual garnishment.

22 comments:

Ellie Finlay said...

This is quick, Mark, as I'm in between appointments here but the first thing that comes to mind is that you simply MUST get your depression treated. Your lack of energy is a symptom of depression. Many people don't realize that. You might well be able to do a VERY part time second job if you had more energy.

More later.

Oh, I completely get it about not getting a roommate. That's been suggested to me before and I just can't.

Kay & Sarah said...

Check this out http://www.ibrinfo.org/what.vp.html

I am not familiar but it may help.

Cathy said...

Mark, I don't know you well, but if it's any comfort, if you are holding down a full-time job and you have a house paid off, it seems to me that life for you is not as hopelessly bad as it seems. I can't say either of those things. And to have any living creature depend on you, like cats, may not seem like much, but it isn't absolutely nothing, either. You are certainly not useless. And if Ayn Rand would have euthanised you, then in my book you're very probably a decent human being. I won't offer advice, except to say that the first thing you should do is find out for certain whether one garnishment can be put on top of another. If not, your problem goes away. I have two questions, though: are you being treated for depression? And if you have not sought diagnosis for autism, do you plan to? I'm only asking the second question because maybe it's not autism and maybe there are solutions to it that you haven't come across yet.

MarkBrunson said...

Ellie,

I take Zoloft. Usually, I'm fine. This is situational depression, and can't be helped. Energy has always been a problem for me. I've been tested for diabetes, hypoglycemia, all sorts of things. When I drank, I had a LOT of energy, so much so that I could ruin my life on no more than two hours of sleep.

MarkBrunson said...

Thanks, TwoAuntees!

MarkBrunson said...

Cathy,

First, the autism thing. I've not been formally evaluated, but have had it suggested as a real possibility at every turn. I wouldn't find that distressing - autism isn't retardation or craziness - and, in fact, it would explain a great deal about me that has otherwise worried me.

I don't believe I am useless in an absolute sense, but relative to society. I have no ambition, you see. Our society wants you to WANT! - here, society meaning human society, not simply the U. S. - and loves to play the zero-sum game.

I work from a position of cooperation, which, ironically, also sees human beings as more valuable in their individual sense. If I have enough, I generally don't WANT - I may desire, and learn to deal with that desire, but the drive is largely absent. I mindlessly consumed as a child and youth, and it gained me nothing, so why do it? I find the societal goals pointless, so, society finds me pointless.

The problem here is that this, if it occurs as I fear, will put me out of the balance and I - and those who depend on me - will be in real trouble.

JCF said...

Who are your connections, Mark? You MUST have some. Family, friends, neighbors, church, frat brothers, choir members, softball team, something? Turn to them, NOW!

12 Step Slogan: I Need People.

It's OK to need, Mark!

...and One Day at a Time. If you've got a full belly and a roof over your head NOW, at this moment, then you're OK for the day/night.

You can try again---WITH SOMEONE'S HELP---tomorrow.

[Dial 211 for help---or 911, if you're on the edge of self-harm.]

MarkBrunson said...

I appreciate your concern, JCF, but people to talk to is not what I need. I'm not in danger of taking my life or any of that.

My feelings aren't the problem.

Erika Baker said...

On a purely practical point I don't understand how they can legally add any more financial burdens for you when you already do a full time job and when medical reasons (unexplained but very real low energy) prevent you from doing more.
Is there no legal or medical angle left to explore?

Are they talking about vast sums of money? Could they be paid off very very slowly over time? Here in the UK many companies agree to ridiculously low repayment plans for loans (up to £1/week)because getting a little is better than bankrupting the debtor and getting nothing.

Do you have savvy friends who could explore the legalities and negotiate sharply on your behalf?

Cathy said...

I've not been formally evaluated, but have had it suggested as a real possibility at every turn.

Who by, though? People who are in a position to make that judgement?

I'm not saying the knowledge that you have some kind of condition is something you should find distressing, and of course it doesn't say you are "retarded or crazy", but to my mind it would be useful to get it formally evaluated. What if it's not autism, but ADHD, or something else that responds well to medication? ... If it comes to that, there might be treatment available to help people with autism (I'm no expert there). That would be my thought.

Cathy said...

PS I'm with you on the roommate thing too. No, no, no, no, no, NO, NO, is what I say.

MarkBrunson said...

Erika,

That's one of the reasons I've put this out here. I really don't have anybody who can tell me these things, and am hoping someone may be able to help me with this. TwoAuntees gave the link above which indicates that I may have a chance to get an income-based adjustment on payments.

The difficulty comes in the fact that the loan is in default, so much harder to get any sort of negotiation on. They generally aren't interested in working out a sliding-scale payment when they can force an Administrative Wage Garnishment through without court order.

However, as far as I can tell, they cannot take more than 15% of the paycheck. To that end, it would simply mean they'll either have to wait for the other garnishment to run out, or split the garnisheed money already being taken.

As for other legal options, James has been of help there, letting me know how to contact legal aid.

MarkBrunson said...

Cathy,

I have taken an informally-administered autism-spectrum quotient test, and, yes, the suggestions all came from trained mental health and behavioral professionals. There are therapies for coping with high-end autism, but no medication or therapy.

Cathy said...

okey dokey Mark - it was only a thought. I've just logged on to add that I should have specified that I meant the type of ADD that doesn't involve hyperactivity, which often goes hand in hand with depression. But you've already answered my question.

If they can't take more than 15% of your paycheck, that's at least something. A great deal of what seems so unsettling in this sort of situation is the uncertainty - being besieged by a faceless moneysnatching organisation who seem to have all the power is an awful feeling. Once the issue is sorted out, whatever happens, you will hopefully feel it is more under control.

MarkBrunson said...

I should point out, Cathy, that you do have a very valid point and I'm not trying to minimize what you're saying as part of the long-term solution: if, for instance, I were to attempt to discharge the loan(s) through bankruptcy, I would want a definite, formal diagnosis.

Cathy said...

You don't want to go the bankruptcy route though, Mark - that would involve giving up your house, wouldn't it?? ... Don't do that under any circumstances (and I agree you should avoid mortgaging it, too).

Ellie Finlay said...

Good morning, Mark. I'm so glad to see the rallying of support for you here.

Actually, there are some medications that help high-end autism. I know because I have it and I HAVE been formally diagnosed. Please email me privately if you would like to know more details and perhaps discuss this further.

Said medication, by the way, has had a HUGE positive impact on my everyday functioning and sense of well being.

I'm in your corner, friend. Please know that.

efinlay[at]intcon[dot]net

June Butler said...

Mark, I don't have anything in the way of practical solutions to offer you, but I want to say again that you remain on my daily prayer list. You are God's wonderful creation, and God loves you, and I love you insofar as I can through the ether of the internet. You count for me every day, since I take the time to think about you and pray for you.

Cathy said...

hi Mark, just to add, I agree totally with every word of Mimi's and you are in my prayers too. It sounds as though financially they can't sting you for too much, too, which is good news. Hurray!!

Victoria said...

Well, I was about to advise that you could simply room with someone that you know and trust, but then I read on and saw that you enjoy solitude.. and to be totally honest with you I do not know what to say to your problem, I havn't had the chance to experience what you are going through, I think that you may have a case of Bipolar though, because you change moods a lot in this blog. Hope that you find a solution to your problem soon. :]

MarkBrunson said...

I have been formally diagnosed as not being bipolar, but, it's a tricky diagnosis. I'm definitely depressive.

For me, this is a discipline. I think most people have absolutely the same reactions, they simply don't express the panic, anger, joy, despair, and I do. I mean to. It's part of being fully-human. I also find that since I embraced that discipline of expressing - with friends in a safe environment - my emotional response; then, I can move on. Most people are angry, nervous, sad or just plain baffled by things so long ago they don't know what it is. For me, it's not just a luxury, but, given the obsessive and inward-looking nature, it saves me from actually letting it become a long-term problem.

I've gotten what help I can, and will update on it. It's still not looking good.

If there is anything you can learn from what you read here, it's this: for some of us, life really is that desperate - that's what working poor is.

Victoria said...

I know it is desperate at times being that My mother hasn't had any luck with her job (mainly because they won't giver her any steady hours) she is in school also, which makes things worse, so sometimes there may not be any food in the house, so I eat the ramen I have stashed just for when that happens... that is good to hear that you are NOT bipolar, my grandmother is and she complains and nit-pics about every little thing! hope your situation gets better soon. :]